This is your typical strip mall pizza parlor. Mostly outdated decor. Could be updated but probably not necessary...yet. I was served by a very attentive, enthusiastic, lovely young lady who made my entire day today. Pure sunshine! I ordered the Stromboli Special which is a small Stromboli with a salad and a drink. The salad was simple, but fresh, with homemade ranch dressing. The Stromboli came out hot and cheese was oozing from every orifice. Great cheese pull too. I felt like there could've been more meat inside but honestly for the price I'm not complaining. The marinara was ok. Overall had a great experience. Food is good. Very good portion size. Friendly staff. I would recommend and I'll be back to try other menu items. read more

See all

My son and I were coming back from Durham and he pulled in Elizabeth's parking lot. I looked at him and he said you said you were hungry. We had eaten at the Denton and Thomasville location on numerous occasions. The Siler City location is by far the biggest I have been in. And the most options of any.It was around 3ish so other than some to go orders we appeared to be the only customers. Our waitress was pleasant and fast with the menu and our drinks. My son ordered Stromboli and it was the first time either of us had been asked which sauce did he prefer. So he got the meat sauce. I ordered the meat lovers pizza. And naturally we needed some wings for our appetizer. As with any location either of us has been to their wings or always spot on. Our food came as we were finishing up our wings. Both the pizza and Stromboli and the pizza were Hot. So we had to nurse our bites till it cooled.Pizza and Stromboli were just as good as any of the other Elizabeths we have visited.Our waitress was very attentive to us and we never had an empty glass. And when she brought some to go boxes she also brought a bag and to go cups. We had a good meal and some good service. read more

Great Italian food, particularly eggplant parm and pizza, unfortunately no alcohol. Staff is fabulous, good ambience.

Excellent Stromboli and garden salad!!! Outstanding service!! Thank you for a delicious lunch!!! read more

Food quality has declined over the years. Prices are too high for food quality delivered. Never a crowd in there which I relate to overall impression of the restaurant. Service is average. No plans to go back unless someone tells me they have improved. read more

Absolutely loved this place! The pizza was so good -- super fresh, perfect crust, and the flavors were amazing. The staff were really friendly and the service was fast. The whole place had a comfortable, welcoming vibe. Definitely one of my new favorite spots. Can't wait to go back! read more

Don't waste your money expensive got burnt bread first course was served on plastic plates.

Since I was a kid this exact place was the best of the best of all first of all the service amazing Food goated never disappoints me Ambiance super amazing of all Love this place read more

I will start by saying the food is good. I just don't think it's good enough to up charge on condiments I can understand passing on the credit card surcharge to customers but I'm just not willing to pay a premium for mayo and ketchup!! read more

Elizabeth's Restaurant - Additional charges are out of control. - Pizza Near Me - Siler City, North Carolina

Traveling back to Raliegh took a chance stop by for dinner. Older business in a small strip mall. Entered and sat myself. Was immediately greeted by server with menu and took my drink request. Drink came back quick and I ordered from a generous optioned menu. Decided on the lasagna. Came with a small salad and bread. Salad was fresh and plated. Nothing fancy but salad is salad. Dinner came. I was a little surprised by what I got. I like Italian food and order lasagna alot. This was a new presentation to me. The lasagna was centered on plate and drowned in red sauce and then draped with 2 slices of mozzarella cheese. OK so its here I will give it a try. I pulled the cheeses slices off and uncovered the noodle top. The lasagna was only 3 noodles deep. In between the noodles was what tasted like meatloaf. No other cheeses was evident even though the menu said it had regatta cheeses in it. The sauce was also an experience. It tasted like tomatoes all right but thats it. The whole plate was like chef-boy-RD. I did eat it. It just didn't taste like any lasagna I have ever eaten. The 3 starts are for the service. I wont ever eat their lasagna again. Others may see it different. Have a great day y'all. read more

Whoever is making gyro never had it before)))))) maybe saw it in movies or adds but never had it before

One of my favorite restaurants I eat here few times a week love the steak stromboli and Italian burger if you want great service asl for cici she is the best good food good environment overall great family place . read more

Update: I've given them chance after chance to improve. Now, I go out of my way to go to Pittsboro and eat from Ahmed's Elizabeth's Pizza. Elizabeth's in Siler City has went so far downhill. From the use of cheap products in the steak. Very poor quality. Not only do you not get a lot of meat--now it's more like poor version of "steak ums". Ordered baked tortellini tonight hopeful it would be good. I was served with 20 small multicolored GRREN and ORANGE pasta from the grocery store. Like what???! No thank you!!! Ranch is runny and not the same. Cutting back costs have them cost them my business. Staff--both cooks and waitstaff are rude and just ugh. I really hate Elizabeth's has lost me as a customer. read more

Simply delightful! The chicken gyro, chicken fingers, senior spaghetti and meatballs, the chicken wrap, and the chicken soup were all perfect. The service and the kitchen were exceptional speedy! Please give 5-Star Kudos to our waitress - who we think was Nikki! She was so attentive and polite it was the perfect evening! Thank You So Much! read more

This a great locally owned Elizabeth's Pizza restaurant. Management here is phenomenal. Heather is as good as they come. Food is consistently good as well as the service. Menu is full of items that offer something for everyone to enjoy. Large tables inside that can sit large groups as well as additional party rooms located in the back. Beautiful outdoor seating is also an option here. Takeout is a big hit for this restaurant as well. I tend to eat the Philly cheesesteak with fries when I am here. They also have great sweet tea and several desert options. Check these folks out! read more

Solid pizza place, delicious crust and the pizza taste is very fresh. We got the pepperoni and their supreme pizza which were both excellent. Recommend you check this place out! read more

Salad was ok. Hubby had ravioli it was fair. I had eggplant parm sub and it was nasty. The eggplant was very bitter and I couldn't eat it. read more

Sometimes it's really really good but most of the time it's just OK. They have some items that is are always good. Don't get the Lasagna the do not know how to prepare this item. The first time I ordered it I got a refund. The second time I ordered it shame on me for thinking it had changed. Same as the first time oh well. Go by and give them a try and see if it's the food or it's just me being too critical. read more

I really do love their salads, cauliflower bites, and pasta but their is one problem. There have been multiple times I have found hair in the pasta. When I told the lady serving me last time she was very sorry about it I showed her the long black hair and she took it away and made a to go order for me. I never had such good service before anywhere else they would ignore me but they really do care. They want their food to be great. This is why I keep going back I just wish that the girls would wear a net to keep their hair out of the food.... read more

Absolutely disgusting. $17 for some nasty pasta?? No thanks. Save your money it's not worth it.

Had the shrimp Alfredo $14.99 and the shrimp still had the shell on it, I went there to eat my food not play with it. Checked out a picture at Elisabeth pizza in Pittsboro NC of there shrimp Alfredo and no shells on the shrimp, Siler City you need to get your s_ _ _ together take the shell off the shrimp and they had 10 pieces Siler City only gave me 8 pieces read more

Elizabeth's Restaurant - Shrimp Alfredo from Elizabeth pizza in Pittsboro NC no shells on the shrimp - Pizza Near Me - Siler City, North Carolina

This used to be a good place to eat but they've recently raised prices but gone way down in service. Such a shame! read more

The worst Italian restaurant I've ever eaten at. I would go to Olive Garden before here. That's how bad it is. Italian? Huh? You guys need some new recipes. Your sauces are bland and who the heck knows what that crappy cheese is on your dishes. I've ordered 3 times from here and each and every time has been underwhelming and so very bland. read more

Great little chain in the "greater Chatham Co" area. Today had the cheesesteak special. Great combo price. Fries were nice an hot, bread crispy, and the sandwich was superb. Service very good, they don't let your tea get below half. Good people, good menu, good prices. Gonna try the Pizza next time. read more

Very good and tasty food plus some Mediterranean food, very good Greek dishes, fast services and excelente

first they forgot the drink with my delivery order then after the driver went back for that, they forgot to include the dessert. clearly this restaurant doesn't care about their customers. I even called and said "please make sure everything is included with the order." I usually order from here 2 or 3 times a week but after today I am done. sorry for bothering you guys. read more

This place is as close as you will find to getting a taste of NY without actually going to NY. I have eaten everything on this menu, and it is all good. My favorite is the chicken deluxe sandwich. The grilled chicken salad is a generous portion. The pizzas are large. My daughter loves the ziti and my son loves the stromboli. My kids think the ranch dressing is the best ever created. Nice friendly atmosphere with a good staff, and when the owner is there, he often comes out to make sure everything is okay. Probably the best place to grab something to eat in Siler City. read more

The pizza is really great and the staff extremely friendly and helpful. I had the pizza Primavera and husband had the stuffed pizza. We loved both! I've had pasta there, too, that is really good and their salads look really fresh. read more

Delicious food. I had the Fra Diavlo, it was absolutely delicious! The rest of my party had pizza which was yummy and large portion. Definitely worth visiting. read more

Honestly, I didn't expect much. In fact, when I first walked up, I thought "What have I gotten myself into? This building should be condemned. Call the fire marshall." Such thoughts were contradicted instantly, however, by the first delectable morsel. The pizza was simply incredible. They actually know how to make pizza here and actually use the right oven. It's the real deal and not typical NC Italian (a.k.a. Chef Boyardee or Macaroni con Ketchup). Lesson learned. Don't judge a book by it's cover. Highly recommended! read more

Wow, it's so hard to know what to actually write about tonight's cluster. We used the online ordering system to place a to-go. Three dinners, three salads, three desserts. When our son arrived for pickup, the waitress went over the order and sent him home with three big bags full of stuff. While unpacking, we realized his chicken Stromboli was missing, so we called to ask for a refund. They told us we had to drive back for a refund, so we drove back to get the Stromboli -- - 30-minute round trip (for the second time tonight). We called called and asked for them to either refund the Stromboli or give us a credit for a Stromboli next time. Then I asked if I could make a constructive suggestion to the manager -- that when they have multiple bags/boxes, they number them so the waitresses know the whole order has been given. But she snapped at me that she knew how to run her business and hung up on me. I called back to confirm she was going to confirm the refund and she hung up again. But no amount of call backs or yelling helped. I am so disappointed in the whole situation tonight. There aren't that many great restaurants in our small town, but we're so done with this one. Sigh. read more

When you move away for 6 years, when you return there are many changed. And, so much remains the same. The later describes Elizabeth's Pizza. The food is great. High quality, tastes great and good quantity. My wife and I are Retired from the Navy and were stationed in Sicily. Elizabeth's has about the best. Service was pretty slow for no apparent reason but it was worth the wait. We waited almost a year after coming back to eat there. Big mistake. Again, well worth the wait. read more

I've had the Supreme Pizza and the Spinach Calzone with Marinara, both were pretty tasty! Definitely the tastiest in Siler City. I would reccommend. read more

My family and I had lunch here it was great. We had Jumbo wings for an appetizer the we big and cooked just right. I then had a steak and cheese sub it was full of meat an cheese the taste was good. It's the was by far the best food I've had in a long time. Not to mention the service was excellent the server was very attentive and nice as can be. We will definitely be returning. Thank you for a wonderful experience. read more

Use to be a good place to eat, but they have changed recently. Raised prices on the subs and even started charging for the chips. Service is terrible and you are lucky to have your waitress check on you. They also have a service charge for ordering online which is something I have never experienced. Strongly suggest dining elsewhere. read more

Love Elizabeths Pizza! Great service, great food! Our favorites are the bread knots, wings, and stromboli!! So happy to have this business in our town! read more

Really wish there was something lower than a one to rate this place with. Sadly it was terrible! We were expecting much better after reading the reviews. The place is disgustingly filthy first of all. Dirty tables, dirty floors, etc. We had to find our own silverware, napkins, and to go box. The lasagna was like eating rubber. I took two bites and couldn't eat any more. The Stromboli was edible but not much better itself. So disappointed. read more

The most amazing pizza, grew up eat here and when ever I come thru siler city I try to stop there.

Food was very good and waitress was great. Cheese sticks were a little hard but my stromboli was very fulfilling!!

We eat at Elizabeth's every few weeks and enjoy the food and the very good service. Salads, calzones, Philly steak sandwiches are among our favorites. What I don't understand is why they don't clean up the over-crowded entrance areas. There's barely a place to sit and wait, and the "arcade" games there are useless. There's always lots of trash around the front door, trash on the foyer floor and a cluttered checkout counter. The glass door has notices that have been taped to it for YEARS and the glass itself never seems to be even close to clean. My advice to the owner/manager: slowly approach your restaurant from the parking lot, stop at the door and read, walk in the foyer and sit on the little bench. What do you see? Is it inviting, or is it a turnoff? read more