The level of professionalism is beyond what I expected. Everyone is friendly and knowledgeable. I…read morewill continue to do business with them.

The gentleman Mike was beyond helpful in sorting through my grandmother's jewelry, he gave us a…read morefair price. I also brought some of my own coins to sell and he was very knowledgeable. With currency and other collectibles. Definitely will be back again.

Very friendly and helpful. Worked on my watch quickly and was very affordable. I would absolutely…read morego there again for jewelry repair.

Great service and great people. Very welcoming right when I walked in. Clean atmosphere in there…read moreand also a great selection of jewelry.

I purchased some coins from them in 1996 and just called them July 2024. Their phone number does…read morenot work. Neither the new York phone number nor toll-free. Toll-free number has been taken over by somebody who wants to sell back braces to people over 65. Their website has not been built. I looked them up under New World Rarities Limited, and found a number for Hyde Park New York with a telephone number that has been disconnected and again a website that is not set up yet. I also looked them up under New World Rarities Limited in Happague, New York, and again their phone number is disconnected/not valid and the website is not built yet. I think they went out of business. The original coins that I purchased were very nice but now I need help with them in obtaining past photos as the coins were stolen and there's nobody to answer my questions.

Offered to sell gold for a friend and they gave best price along with Patchogue Buy and Sell. If…read moreyou don't want to get ripped off, sell your stuff to either of these two businesses. I have no personal interest in either company.

I am not a jewelry person but i wanted some custom work done to a cross that was given to me as a…read morechild from a family member who passed away. They took my family members ash diamond and made it look perfect in the cross. Vanessa the rep who helped me when i walked in was very welcoming and did not make me feel weird about the request. John the jeweler who did the work did a phenomenal job. I couldn't be happier. Not only did it come out great but the cleaning they did to it made it look brand new again. It was literally almost black with tarnish. I will be going back whenever i need it cleaned. I would recommend them to anyone.

I'm appalled that this jeweler tried charging me $265 for the smallest repair. I didn't feel good…read moreabout it and I'm glad I trusted my instinct and went to a different jeweler. Who did it for $50.

Guys a LOW BALLER! First he said my diamond wasnt real which it clearly was! Then as I was leaving…read morehe tried get me to get my best offer then call him back! You're supposed to give your best offer upfront! Don't say I didn't warn you!

Great store to sell your stuff!! I was on the hunt to sell some old jewelry that I had. Went to a…read morefew different stores and they wanted to give me basically nothing for my gold necklace and diamond earrings. Walked into this store not only did I get double the price others were offering I got myself a really nice watch in the process! Owner was also really nice and honest which I appreciated.

Unimpressed no real jewelry and big mark ups on silver. The associate was not very friendly.read more

Worst customer service. The guy was absolutely rude and lacked any sort of compassion in dealing…read morewith clients. Horror show. Not recommended

I found this jeweler in Smithtown while looking to create a ring. My grandfather was a jeweler and…read morehad made a beautiful pair of earrings for me years ago, unfortunately I lost one of the pair. I wanted to make a ring out of the remaining earring. This was about 4 years ago. Surge, the owner described exactly what I envisioned and made me a heartfelt piece. I recently went back as my ring needed a little repair. This time I also brought in a broken bracelet and asked that earrings be made out if it. Again, Surge did not disappoint. He even paid me for the pieces of gold leftover from the bracelet. I have two unique pieces from LI Gold Mine and will continue to bring my business there.

Brought in a watch to have a new battery installed. The new battery didn't help the watch to…read morefunction properly and so sadly it couldn't be repaired. In the process, though, Jill was very accomodating and so was the young man who was disappointed that he couldn't bring my watch back to life. So, I can't comment on their workmanship, but I can say they went the extra mile to be helpful.

Wow wow wow! What can I say! I am so in love with my ring from Bellport Jewelrs! Dianne worked with…read moreme to comb through many options of stones and settings until we came up with my ring! She was patient and informative and most of all really took time to understand and execute what I wanted. I highly recommend you getting your custom engagement ring here! The best part about Bellport jewelers is that they have a passion for antique and showed me a beautiful vintage round diamond after looking at so many newer cuts that I wasn't loving. Most jewelers shy away from vintage! Seriously if you are looking for a lifetime piece, something you will love forever, Bellport Jewelers is your place!

Love having Bellport Jewelers as my personal jeweler. When you go there and meet Peter, Dianne, and…read morePeter Jr - you feel instantly welcomed and become like extended family! They really do exceptional work and take great pride in it. This place is not like those generic super mall chain store jewelers which I personally can't stand. Their store is in the quaint town of Bellport which is very historic and beautiful to walk through, shop, enjoy an ice cream or grab a slice of pizza. Instead of selling my unwanted gold.... Peter did the most amazing thing with my pile of jewelry. He made me custom pieces that were so artistic and organic.... and I am the only one who has them! If you are an artist or appreciate art like me - definitely see Peter. Plan on staying awhile in the store because odds are you will sit down for a good chat!