Food is good, but the $15 margarita pitcher on Saturday gets it the stars. Idk what the coleslaw is all about though.

I ordered a super burrito, it was simply ground beef in a flour tortilla with lettuce, tomato, and sour cream, along with a side of beans, which did not present well on the plate. The taste was good, the ambiance was quaint. The salsa was very good! They also served the chips with coleslaw, which I actually loved. Overall I would stop here again next time I'm in town. read more

Great food, good and personable service in an authentic ambiance. Definitely coming back! read more

See all

Delicious food and a friendly atmosphere. I will definitely be back and recommend El Torero to anyone passing through the area.

food is typically good but every time it's missing items and the chips and salsa that come with the meal on Togo orders . read more

El Torero - Tamale - Mexican Near Me - Cortland, Ohio

I got the puck three. WORST FOOD EVER. Burger in taco and burrito was cold,had absolutely no seasoning. They say beef"really it's hamburger with nothing in it. Chili releno ok. Beans the best part of meal. Waitress had zero personality. Will never go back. read more

We were staying at Mosquitoe Lake camping. Looked this place up and took a chance. It was sooooo good. Best Mexican we ever had! Service was good Restrooms were clean. Highly recommend. read more

Since my last review was 2017 I thought I bring you all up to date. This is our all time favorite Mexican restaurant. It's the gold standard we compare all others to. Their margaritas are by far the best in the area. This is a hint of citrus in them that makes all the difference in the world. The staff is very personable and a lot of fun. The food is the best. The Cortland El T stands out from the rest of the franchise. Their tacos are basic but the meat seasoning is spot on. Their x-hot salsa is so good, not just hot but has a great flavor as well. What do I recommend? All their shrimp dishes are great, empanadas, tacos, appetizer shrimp quesadilla,... everything! Hang on, we're going there now! read more

This is our third time here in as many weeks. We've only lived here three weeks. Enough said. read more

El Torero - Kids eat free on Tuesdays. - Mexican Near Me - Cortland, Ohio

See all

Stopped out of the blue the food was delicious. Walked out stuffed. Chicken steak shrimp fajitas. Awesome would definitely stop again.

Nice little place with a very friendly staff. The food and drinks are always amazing. My favorite is the monster burrito with a mango jalapeño margarita.. read more

Went to dinner on a Monday at 4pm. Staff was friendly, everything clean and neat. Ordered a medium lime margarita on the rocks. Tasted very fresh-not the "house mix." I ordered the chicken quesidillas. Yummy! There were 3 of us. All agree food is amazing, staff friendly and prices good. Will definitely be back!!! read more

This is our neighborhood Mexican Restaurant. We go there often, the service is always fast, the food is always good, just wish they'd stock more Tecate beer.......they also serve cold slow and salsa with the chips-a bit different, but the wife likes it. read more

The food is always good and comes out fast. The Mango Margaritas are the best around! We try to come here whenever we are in town.

This place is horrible. I ordered online for a pickup order of Burrito Especial with beef. Got home and it was chicken instead of beef. I called to complain the lady wanted me to drive back up there so they can make me the correct order that I placed. I spent 31.00 for this pickup and now they want me to drive back up there, give me gas money your cook is the one that screwed up the order not me. UGH. I will NOT be ordering from them again. read more

This is such a nice gem, very quaint, nice atmosphere and most importantly good food! They have a variety of regular and frozen Margaritas to choose from. The outside patio is a nice choice if the weather is permitting. The staff is friendly, courteous, and really work hard. I recently had the Loco burrito with chicken and it was delicious! read more

El Torero - Loco burrito - Mexican Near Me - Cortland, Ohio

For a tiny quaint Mexican restaurant, they serve great food and have fast service. Can't wait to enjoy they outdoor patio in the summer.

We ended up going on "staycation" yesterday and this place came highly recommended. It was pretty packed but we went on a Friday night when the weather was perfect right at dinner time; if they hadn't been busy, then I would have started to worry. We were able get a high top table on the patio. Our server was quick and efficient. I ordered the Enchiladas Supremas and hubby got Enchiladas Jalisco (stuffed with seafood). My dinner was wonderful: 4 enchiladas (shredded chicken, ground beef, retried beans, cheese - one of each) in their red sauce -- which was delicious! Hubby liked his enough but said it tasted "ok" - his enchiladas were in a creamy cheese sauce. The prices of beer, especially on tap, was super reasonable. All in all, our bill came to under $30 (not included tip) and we left full bellies and satisfied. read more

Taco Tuesday and everyday that ends in Y! We've been enjoying their Mexican cuisine for years. Try the Avacado Mexicana mix. Great tasting strawberry daiquiris too! Service always excellent. An enjoyable affordable meal especially during inflationary times. read more

The El Torero restaurant is magnificent! The have the best cheese dip in the tri-state area. I've been to a wide variety of Mexican restaurants in the area but El Torero blows me away every time. They are polite, funny and the service is quick. This family own establishment really knows how to make you feel like one of their own! I would recommend El Torero to anyone and everyone! read more

El Torero - Fajita burrito - Mexican Near Me - Cortland, Ohio

Fantastic food, kind staff. There is an occasional mistake on my order, but they have always made it right when I ask.

Ok went there tonight. Very busy birthday party on patio. So asked the server if they could leave onions out of a dish. They told me no problem. 25 to 3o minutes later, can back and told me they could no do that. Just told them I did not want anything. Mean while my husband dinner came, told them just to box it up. That told anywhere from ten to fifteen minutes. No happy. If you can not handle a large party. Tell people as they coming in.they have to wait over an hour for the food. And let them decide if they want to stay. Do not think we will be going back there anytime soon. read more

Kevin and his dad run a good place. The food is quick to order and very well priced. You get 5x the value of food vs being in CA over here. Try out the margaritas as well! read more

I have been eating at El Torero since it first opened in the early aughts. I've watched many authentic Mexican restaurant come and go since then and none of them compare to this place. Happy to see they were able to expand beyond their humble first location and move into other markets. I'll continue to support this business as long as they keep the food delicious and the service exceptional. One of my favorite places to eat, hands down. read more

I saw this post on face book today and had to share it here. I hope the author doesn't mind. "I have never been to a Mexican restaurant in my life until last night. We decided to go to the one here in cortland. I really didn't know what to order so of course the one thing I did order didn't sit well. So I sent it back I explained to our very nice waitress that it wasn't their fault or anything like that so she apologized and offered something else but I said no thank you. Well a few minutes later a gentleman came out to talk to me and started explaining some things on the menu that being my first experience I would like more. So I ordered what he suggested and it was delicious. My point is I have never experienced such wonderful customer service in a restaurant and everyone was so friendly and nice. Thank you all at the restaurant." read more

We are new to Cortland and luckily this place is right down the road from us. We've both sat down and ate here, and ordered take out. The portions are huge and the food is flavorful. Seriously, this place tastes more authentic Mexican than pretty much any Mexican restaurant I've ever ate at. You cannot go wrong here. read more

Great dinner tonight. Carnitas was excellent. Angel burrito was wunderbar! AP special was great as usual. Service was great, best mexican restaurant in town!! Awesome. read more

El Torero - a woman sitting at a table in a restaurant - Mexican Near Me - Cortland, Ohio

I usually don't care one way or another about Mexican food, so when my family suggested we try El Torero, I was less than excited. The food amazed me! The refried beans are incredible. The prices are great but they are even better when you have one of their coupons (which are everywhere). The service was wonderful. The atmosphere is very nice and they really know how to make a great margarita! I love this place and will go back often! read more

Being from California, we were used to authentic Mexican food, so this was a disappointment. We tried the salsa, guacamole & different entrees but it just wasn't what we were used to. The service was friendly & efficient though. Not for us, too bad because we just moved to this area. read more

I have never had bad food here, and the service is awesome - we LOVE sitting outside, we love the margaritas, and we love this place!

THE. WORST. When we walked in, my girlfriend and me had to wait for about 10 minutes before anyone came to talk with us. All the waitresses just kept looking at us. When we finally got a table, I was in the bathroom and the waitress asked my girlfriend if she wanted salsa for the chips and she said yes then she asked if she wanted cheese dip without telling her that it was extra. We were seated near the patio (?) door and it was so cold and smelled like cigarettes. The waitresses kept going in and out. Good luck getting the attention from anyone. No one cares. The mountain dew was gross and watery. The chips were stale. The waitress came to our table like 2 times asking if we were ready and the manager (maybe?) had to tell her literally refill our drinks. We ordered the food and 5 minutes later it came out, which probably means it was already made earlier. The food was lukewarm. We sat there for 20 minutes waiting for a box and the check. The waitress was too busy sitting at the table or the bench for waiting doing nothing but being on her phone. I would rate it 0/5 if I could. read more

Nice people, good service, tasty food. Enjoy sitting on the deck on a nice day. Excellent happy hour specials!

Not very impressed overall. Food was nothing to write home about. Seemed mostly like items you could buy at the grocery slapped together. Service wasn't very good either. Our waitress dropped off our food them was nowhere to be seen until the check was delivered. We also noticed several tables that needed to be cleaned the entire time we were there. It definitely wasn't busy enough that they couldn't clean a few tables. Doors were also on the sticky side. read more

This place is super close to home and we dine here often. Super friendly staff, specials on drinks & meals everyday, local coupons given out in newspapers, live entertainment during the summer one night a week, beautiful patio, wonderful food. Out of all the Mexican places I've tried locally this is hands down the best. read more

Filthy, terrible service, 40 minutes to get our appetizer at 7:30 on a Thursday. Chips and salsa have no flavor, beer was warm, atmosphere bad. Never go there again! read more

Well, lets start out by saying that I should own stock in this place! :-) I am here at least once a week, if not more. Lunch is always super fast, which is perfect when you work and need to get a good meal in a hurry. I have a broad pallet when it comes to Mexican dishes and everything that I have had here is amazing. The AP Special and Chicken Quesadilla are the hubby's fav and I really enjoy the wet burrito and this amazing dish that has half of a fresh pineapple filled with grilled chicken and rice. To die for!!! read more

I would love to say that my visit to this restaurant was pleasant and enjoyable, but unfortunately, it was not. When we first arrived, the hostess seated us in this booth and hands us menus covered in wet salsa. They were not clean and we had to wipe them down ourselves. Then we go to order and so far we just have the menu incident. I order the torero supreme with bean and no rice, I am not crazy about rice to begin with, my mother orders grilled chicken. After patiently waiting for our orders to arrive, we began to eat our meals. To my surprise, the beans were grossly burnt. Why????? How could you do this to beans? You are a mexican restaurant! Beans are child play, taco bell has better-refried beans! Then on top of that, my mothers grilled chicken was burnt and the menu stated three chicken breasts and she only received a small piece of ONE chicken breast. I wish that my experience could have been better, but it wasn't. The only person who enjoyed themselves was my father. He ordered the seafood tacos. The restaurant looked more aesthetically pleasing than the food was delicious. read more

This is one of our favorites restuarants. The entrees are always made to order, plentiful and delicious. Margueritas are the best! The staff is always accomodating and friendly. Very extensive menu and I've tried about 15 of them....each one was great. Good prices. read more

Not very good! When finally seated we received a bowl of tortilla pieces too small for any salsa which was fine considering the salsa was just red water, no chunks of tomatoes at all. The table was dirty. Very unorganized. We were seated by the bar, it was very loud and the bartender talked constantly about personal matters. We won't be going back. The only decent part of our visit was the food. read more

Just had a great meal. 2 dinners that each had more than we could eat of great food for under $20. Friendly staff and great chips and salsa brought to the table. Going to be back very soon. read more