Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    El Maguey

    4.0 (5 reviews)
    Closed • 9:00 am - 10:00 pm

    El Maguey Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - El Maguey

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Julie M.
    48
    866
    153

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Mexican 6,520 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    El Mexicano Restaurant - Fajita Nachos-chicken Wonderful!

    El Mexicano Restaurant

    4.7(15 reviews)
    1.9 mi

    I wish I could join the chorus of 4 and 5 star reviews. Looking for a restaurant with atmosphere?…read more You won't find it here. My first warning was the decrepit sign over the door in a dilapidated strip center. But, as the saying goes, "don't judge a book by its cover." The food was good. Not great. My usual order is fajitas, this time a chicken, steak, and chicken combo. The plate was served sizzling. Served with 3 small tortillas and the usual fixin's. El Mexicano doesn't serve any beans other than refried, so, no option for black beans, pinto or borracho. The shrimp in the dish were perfect, the chicken was dried out and there were about 6 little strips of steak. The grilled onions and peppers were very good. My wife's shrimp dish was very salty. She prefers the interpretation of Shrimp Mexicana at others Mexican restaurants. And for good measure, because we asked for some lime to squeeze on the shrimp and they tacked on $2 to the bill. But what really resulted in my barely average review was the cleanliness of El Mexicano; or rather, the lack of it. You'll notice a yellow bucket that hangs on the wall in the dining room, yes, in full sight of diners. I witnessed a server drop something on the floor, grab a cloth from the bucket and clean the floor. Then, she returned the cleaning cloth to the bucket. Moments later, another server used the same cloth to clean tables! The health department would have a hissy fit if they saw this. Worse, when I mentioned this to the manager, he was indifferent. I know he understood me, he just didn't care. If the manager is so indifferent to such an obvious health hazard, I can't fathom what goes on in the kitchen. El Mexicano is a "one and done" for us.

    Love the food and great service! We have tried several places and this has become our go to!read more

    Photos
    El Mexicano Restaurant
    El Mexicano Restaurant - Salsa & chips are so good!

    Salsa & chips are so good!

    El Mexicano Restaurant

    See all

    Mexico City Restaurant - Arroz Texano

    Mexico City Restaurant

    4.3(49 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    •$

    Food was good and fast Guac was fire service was fast and accurate small place sound regular…read moreauthentic music. I like very good

    First, this establishment is no longer called Mexico City Restaurant. It's now El Mexicano. Each…read moreof our group of 4 tried something different. My wife had chicken with shrimp, grilled vegetables and smothered in cheese. I went with Chicken Monterrey. Same deal. Chicken with grilled veggies smothered in cheese. Our friends went with El Tres-3 enchiladas. Cheese, chicken & pork. Smothered in cheese. Are we beginning to see a pattern? Throw in a steak burrito and we've got a full table. The meal started with a good margarita, fairly thick, not greasy chips and a mild salsa. Thankfully, there was some habanero hot sauce to give the salsa some kick. Tortillas served with dinner were probably from a bag and served cold. They were wrapped in foil, but I doubt they ever saw the inside of an oven. Both chicken dishes came with the thinnest chicken breast I'd ever seen. Pounded to the thickness of a piece of tilapia. So thin, it was difficult to find the chicken once it was buried in cheese. The rice and refried beans were standard fair. They don't offer charro or borracho or black beans. And the lack of any noticeable seasoning made for a very bland dinner. Service was very good. The food was served piping hot. Prices were reasonable. I just wish it had some flavor beyond cheese.

    Photos
    Mexico City Restaurant - Chicken bowl (without lettuce)

    Chicken bowl (without lettuce)

    Mexico City Restaurant - Super Taco Salad

    Super Taco Salad

    Mexico City Restaurant - Lengua taco (left) pastor taco (right)

    See all

    Lengua taco (left) pastor taco (right)

    Taqueria Don Juan - Shrimp ceviche ( Chico size)

    Taqueria Don Juan

    4.7(20 reviews)
    0.4 mi

    Let's be clear, if all you know is Tex-Mex, this taqueria may disappoint. You won't find nachos,…read moreburritos, fajitas here. This is strictly Mexican food. And darn good at that. They start you with these funky fried crisps. No salsa or pico-but on the bright side you don't fill up with chips. Good thing, because the portions are ginormous! It's rare I can't finish a meal, but my shredded beef with mole was more than enough for a takeout box. I ordered the platter, so my meal came with rice and refried beans. We had the leftovers for lunch the following day. My wife ordered two alacart items. Shrimp cerviche and a chicken taco. Both well prepared. And as a side bonus, the tortillas were outstanding. I'm not a fan of corn tortillas, but these home made gems had flavor and didn't fall apart like packaged ones. Same with the crispy corn shells for the tostada. Great crunch and real flavor. Beer was served cold along with a frosted mug and a slice of lime. Everything is made to order. One fella was the chief, cook & bottle washer. And waiter. He speaks English when he sees you struggling with the menu. He made us feel very welcome. This is a down to earth diner that hasn't seen any updating since day one, but the food is excellent, the restrooms are clean and the service was perfectomundo.

    OMG, this place is fantastic!…read more I was lucky it wasn't busy when I arrived. I was welcomed in in a family style way. This made it more authentic. I was able to explore the menu but I knew I had walked in for a ceviche. Glad waitress clarified the typo on large shrimp ceviche's price, which immediately translated to honesty. Thei give you a complimentary savory broth with hints of seafood flavor and potatoes which is a welcoming opening. The flavor was excellent the tostadas are like home made non commercial, loved them. Their give you fresh lime or already squeezed natural lime juice. I had a campechano (mixed) taco and a pastor taco. Which they have for .99 on Tuesdays so I will be a regular on Tuesdays too. There is parking on the front and on one of the sides of the place. The team was quick with food, attentive to all needs and very professional and friendly. And the price value is amazing. There are many items I still have to try but it is in my top 3 list for Mexican food in Kentuckiana!

    Photos
    Taqueria Don Juan
    Taqueria Don Juan - Chicken Tacos

    Chicken Tacos

    Taqueria Don Juan - Chicken gringa

    See all

    Chicken gringa

    Marisquería El Puerto De San Blas - Tacos de pescado

    Marisquería El Puerto De San Blas

    4.1(8 reviews)
    2.2 mi

    Came here today on a whim while scrolling through the Yelp app and saw this place was very highly…read morereviewed. I'm sitting here scratching my head as why because at best, this is a 3-star place and barely at that. The food was okay but nothing to write home about. I've had much better Mexican food at other places. I ordered the Chori Pollo which is chorizo on top of grilled chicken with cheese and white rice. My order was taken down wrong and I ended being given something entirely different. They did end up making it correct for me. The horchata I ordered was really good and one of the better ones I've had from a place. My server was nice despite taking down my order entirely wrong. The interior is nice. It the music is absolutely too loud and constantly playing so you may need to talk a bit louder than usual if you want to have a conversation with anyone dining with you. I can't see myself returning to this establishment and one that I wouldn't recommend. I had to fight with flies the entire time I was dining which added to the rather displeasing time I was here. The prices for the food isn't too terrible and pretty standard if you've been to most other Mexican restaurants that have a similar menu. Do yourself a favor and find another, much better place for Mexican food than here.

    Wifey, daughter and I came for lunch after church. Miranda…read morewas our very friendly, knowledgeable server. We started with chips and salsa. I would say their salsa is above average of most Mexican restaurants. I would compare it to my own which is dynamite. Wife ordered Carnitas Street Tacos. Daughter ordered Arroz-con-pollo. I ordered Lunch chicken fajitas. We all thoroughly enjoyed our meals. Pictures included. There was some kind of constant banging noise and loud music. No one new what the noise was or where it came from. I wouldn't come back if I had to hear that again. It ruined the ambiance. No discount for Veterans :(

    Photos
    Marisquería El Puerto De San Blas - Main dining area

    Main dining area

    Marisquería El Puerto De San Blas - Carnitas Street Tacos

    Carnitas Street Tacos

    Marisquería El Puerto De San Blas - Front of the establishment

    See all

    Front of the establishment

    El Maguey - mexican - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...