First off, I traveled with EF as a student and when I became a teacher, I became a tour chaperone. My review is based solely on those two facets alone, and not on hosting.
I believe EF gives the perfect You get what you pay for experience. When I travelled as a student in 1996, it was with a majority of the French class from my high school. Our teacher was selective of who came on the trip because she wanted everyone to have a wonderful experience and not cheapen it by disciplinary problems. She also let us know that our expectations may be different from what we experience. Growing up in Hawaii, we have an understanding that many mainlanders come here and expect houses with big rooms, food just like they have back home that lacks our cultural differences, and all the comforts and familiarities of home, not knowing Hawaii is predominantly Polynesia and Asian influenced. Our teacher gave us the same scenario for Europe (and the mainland US if we decided to go away for college.) We should not be traipsing around Europe expecting grand illusions. The cities are beautiful but not fairy tale like. She educated us on the different cultural norms, encouraged our curiosity about European ways of life, and warned us that we may not get to eat what we're used to. She also gave us a suggest amount of money we would possibly spend per day to shop and experience local cuisine. There was a lot of prep work within the school year prior to our trip. When she spoke with our parents, she assured them of our safety as much as she had control over, had our parents and us sign agreements to abstain from alcohol (or the parent would be responsible for any repercussions) and should any of the students misbehave and disrespect/cause damage/disgrace themselves and their schools, the parents were required to pay for their return flight home immediately. These were added contingencies onto EF. This made all the difference.
When I became a teacher and wanted to help students discover a world outside of our microcosm, I instituted the same policies, the same structure in addition to EF. The students I've travelled with were told to expect everything, and not be limited to what they wanted only for themselves. They were to foster a sense of community as well as education. I explained that because this is a budget tour flight and hotel info isn't readily available. I was also a customer service rep for a major cruise ship and worked with tour companies so I know how this can be a hang up for some people. The hotels aren't 4 star, but again, we get what we pay for. But they weren't one star either (at least not my last tour through London, Paris, Barcelona, and Rome.) The hotels were out of the way but EF paid for our transpo, whether it was the Tube, Metro, or by bus. And if the wait time was long due to God knows what for a bus to show up, we were generally in a metropolitan area where I instructed my students to absorb the scenery, journal write, or make new friends and talk with the locals. I would discuss with our EF tour guide away from the students how we can resolve the travel issues (bc, hey, stuff happens.)
Each tour guide I've had, as a student and teacher traveler, has been knowledgeable, took upon herself (Riu and Rosella) the responsibility to show us commercial spots as well as hole in the wall places. We were able to exchange emails and talk prior to the trip with Rosella, and we have continued our friendship after. If a student wandered off, she took it upon her shoulders to look for said student, even though it was the teacher chaperone's responsibility.
On a teacher's note, it is true that we as chaperones travel free for every 6 students, but I believe it is also our responsibility to make sure the trip is for our students and not ourselves. EF can't vet that. Parents should be parents and look into who they're allowing to oversee their kids. This is how we teach kids about cultivating relationships with different people from the get go, and creating global citizens. EF isn't paid enough to give parents that kind of peace of mind if the teacher chaperones don't do their part. Also, I let the EF tour guide know points of interest that were not mentioned in the tour and asked if we were given free time to explore these with our own students. It is not EF's responsibility to follow up because they are giving us an educational taste, like a buffet, not some in depth study abroad option. When they say they are the pioneers in education, they really do honor that, but teachers AND students sometimes do NOT listen when they are educating us during the tours, or as we walk through museums. If you want more time, go solo or in smaller crowds.
The missing star is because calling their 800 number really does take too long, but I'm thinking they're understaffed because I always received an email or call back a day later. read more