5/5 - Authentic Italian gem in the heart of West Palm Beach Just had one of the best Italian meals I've had in a while at this spot. The steak and lamb chops were perfectly cooked, and the sauce? All I can say is "WOW." It tasted like it came straight from Nonna's kitchen--rich, fresh, and packed with flavor. The ambiance is cozy and inviting without being stuffy--warm lighting, great music, and that perfect vibe for a date night or catching up with friends. Service was attentive and genuinely friendly; they really know how to make you feel welcome. We closed out the meal with their homemade cannoli, which were the perfect sweet finish. Buon appetito! Highly recommend -- I'll definitely be back soon. read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

See all

We took a chance on this place since it's close to us--we pass by it all the time and figured we'd finally try it. For $70, we definitely expected more than what we got. The food was edible, but not nearly as enjoyable as we'd hoped. First off... naming a dessert "Big Dig Chocolate Cake" and then giving such a small slice is honestly ironic. Since we ordered takeout, my husband and I planned to share it, trusting the name--but it didn't live up to that at all. Update: just tasted it and it is not good at all. I ordered the Nonna's lasagna, which was a good portion size, but it was overly salty and lacked that classic Italian seasoning flavor you'd expect. My husband got the chicken parmesan and was pretty disappointed--the sauce tasted like it came straight from a can rather than being homemade. Unfortunately, this wasn't a great experience for us, and we won't be returning. read more

See all

Review for Eatalia We had another wonderful experience at Eatalia on Okeechobee. I've already left a review about their steak tips before, but they deserve another mention--they're the closest I've found in Florida to the classic steak tips from Newbridge Café outside Boston in Chelsea, Massachusetts, and they are absolutely fantastic. This time I had the steak tips over the Greek salad, which was incredibly fresh and delicious. My husband ordered the chicken Alfredo and really enjoyed it as well--very flavorful and satisfying. The kids' meal was generous, with delicious fries and steak tips that my child loved. Our server, Camelia, was efficient, pleasant, and incredibly sweet. The service made the experience even better. We truly had a great time. I always like to share when we find a place that's worth recommending. I hope others enjoy the experience here as much as we have! read more

Terrific pizza and food! Owners are very friendly and nice. Best neighborhood Italian food place in West Palm Beach. Carla read more

This Italian spot is NEXT LEVEL ‍ We're at Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill in Royal Palm Beach / West Palm Beach, FL and everything was delish Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pizza Extremely cheesy, creamy & super fresh -- 9.8/10 Mozzarella Sticks Cheese pulls still going... absolutely insane -- 9.3/10 Buffalo Chicken Stromboli Juicy chicken, loaded with cheese, tasty buffalo sauce (add ranch ) -- 9.1/10 Fettuccine Shrimp Pasta Thick, tender shrimp & creamy sauce -- 8.8/10 Nutella Pizza Crunchy crust + gooey chocolate heaven -- 10/10 read more

See all

Great casual Italian pizzeria in Palm Beach. Has tons of indoor seating. Good service, great prices. Food was really good. Great for lunch

The food was not worth the value. Service was poor. It is a shame because it has a great location and a very good atmosphere

Excellent service and food. My server was fantastic and my margharita pizza was amazing. I was able to get in and out of there and under 30 minutes which was great considering it was busy ! read more

First time here! The food was delicious but the service was lacking a bit in the drink department. Our waitress was very sweet and smiley. However, We had to order a water twice and a beer twice before they got to our table, assuming they forgot to bring them. We came at a time it wasn't that busy at first so we thought turnaround time to get drinks and dinner would be quicker as well however, it was tasty! Chicken piccata was creamy and lemony jsut as it should be. Kids pizza was perfect for my daughter. Husband loved his veal parm and my friends enjoyed their meals as well (pictured). Will be back in hopes the service improves in the future. read more

See all

Went for lunch around 130pm and ordered the Steak tip lunch plate after reading reviews on Yelp.. I was not disappointed the Steak tips were delicious , great flavor, seared/grilled to perfection. I got pasta as my side dish and the pasta itself was cooked al' dente though the sauce was a little watery (probably from not draining the pasta enough after cooking ) but still had a good flavor. Service was good, Ambiance was comfortable. I would recommend Eatalia and will be back read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Lunch Steak tip plate with side pasta - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

See all

My favorite Italian restaurant! My nephews and niece love the pizza, wings and pasta !! The cannoli they enjoy. I order often from here since they enjoy it so much. My go to spot !! I highly recommend this place. read more

Absolutely one of the BEST Italian meals I've ever had. This hidden gem truly captures that authentic, mom and-pop charm that's hard to find these days. From the moment you walk in, the owners and staff make you feel like family warm, welcoming, and genuinely passionate about what they do. The food? Incredible. Everything tasted unbelievably fresh and homemade, like it came straight out of a traditional Italian kitchen. You can tell there's real love and care put into every dish. From the sauces to the pasta, every bite was full of flavor and perfectly executed. Honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. If you're looking for authentic Italian food with amazing service and a cozy atmosphere, this place is a must-visit. I'll definitely be coming back again and again read more

We stopped by after catching an early Tuesday afternoon screening of Sonic 3 (on Christmas Eve). We'd been wanting to try the pizza here for a while, so this seemed like the perfect opportunity. When we walked in, the place was mostly empty, with only three other tables occupied. A sign near the entrance instructed us to "wait to be seated," so we did--awkwardly, for quite a while. Another customer arrived not long after us, and we all just stood there, waiting. The kitchen is visible from the front door, so staff could clearly see us, yet no one came over to greet us or even acknowledge our presence. Even on a busy day, you'd expect at least a quick word or gesture, but there was nothing. Eventually, a young woman appeared with a bright smile and told us to sit wherever we liked--making the "wait to be seated" sign feel unnecessary. I wanted to take advantage of the happy hour specials ($5 Tito's and well cocktails) and tried to order a margarita with well tequila. Oddly, the waitress told me this wasn't allowed--something I've never encountered before. She seemed confused, so I settled for a tequila and pineapple juice instead. It tasted fine, but nothing special. My son ordered an apple juice from the kids' menu. For our meal, we decided to share a medium pizza, half cheese and half pepperoni. Wait time for a standard pie was as expected. The pizza arrived hot and fresh. At first glance, it was extremely greasy, but the taste was solid. The crust was thin and slightly charred, just the way I like it, with a flavorful red sauce that complemented the toppings well. When I finished eating, I asked for a box. The waitress nodded to acknowledge my request but then got distracted cleaning tables, rearranging furniture, and assisting another table before finally bringing the box over. It felt like an unnecessary wait. One highlight is that this restaurant offers a discount for paying in cash, which I appreciated and took advantage of. I'd consider coming back to try other menu options, but I'd avoid visiting close to a holiday, hoping for a better overall service experience. read more

See all

My family stopped in for a last minute dinner while on vacation and the food and service were both great. We especially liked the eggplant parmigiana and the rigatoni alla vodka. Will definitely add it to our go-to list when we are back in town. read more

Visited on Halloween, fyi. Negatives: -Was not greeted for a few min -We walked in and people were gathering by the bar and everyone ignored at first to the degree we thought we walked in on a private event One Positive: -Service was good Back to negatives: -Food was mediocre at best *plain salad *alfredo was watery and flavorless *the other pasta dish was flavorless including the sausage which is crazy b/c sausage should never be bland Another Positive: -It was clean Don't think I'll be back. Another review giving it to you straight no chaser! Enjoy! read more

See all

Great food and service.. never had a bad meal ................................................................................. read more

The food was delicious. My sister had to ask for water 3 times before they brought it to her. They had live music but he was a bit intrusive at times. read more

See all

The waiters and staff are so great here. They have a "we have anything you want" mentality. And they delivered on it. We had pizza and drinks and it was top notch. Can't wait to try the pasta next time. read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - I got a pepperoni and pineapple with Alfredo sauce and they have never made that before and it was delicious! Thank you Eatalia - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

This place has been in my list finally tried it. The ambiance is casual. It was not too busy when I arrived around 6pm. I found their prices a bit higher for the quality, location, and ambiance. I had a glass of Chianti and ordered the lasagna. I was disappointed with the food, the meat was salty, no extra cheese offered. I felt like it was something I could make at home. Maybe the pizzas are good but I was not thrilled. My friend had the carbonara, it was ok. The plates came with a house salad. We had to ask for water after the meal, none was offered. The server was friendly. When she brought the check I was charged for another wine and when I mentioned it she said it's more than likely the same price. I had to tell her it was not. After getting the corrected bill all was well. read more

See all

Friendly italian. Very large entrees that they were happy to divide into 2 portions. Kind of confusing when you enter the restaurant because the cash register and hostess is at the back near the kitchen. Can't remember wait to get back. read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Eggplant main course was shared and divided in the kitchen for us!! - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

See all

Waited forever for terrible food! It has such potential. And your knowledge of wine is comical!

Super impressed by this unassuming place. Service was fantastic and friendly. The environment was casual and appropriate. The food was way more than I imagined. The eggplant stack was the perfect combination of flavors and absolutely delicious. It came out room temp, which may be the way it's supposed to given the amount of greens, but even if it wasn't, didn't bother me a bit. It was so good! The garlic twists are a bit pricey for the amount you get, but so amazing, you just can't skip them! The pizza was truly notable. The whole package was phenomenal, but the crust tipped the scale. I kept eating thinking this is SUCH great pizza. And warmed up the next day in the oven was almost as good! The large was huge and very reasonably priced. We got cheese, but I imagine their specialty pizzas are just as good! read more

See all

We looked on Yelp for a great place to eat in the area we were shopping. Eatalia came up and the ratings were great so we decided to try it. I was 4:30 so the place was basically empty. The restaurant is located on the side of Okeechobee Blvd and has a pleasant atmosphere. The staff was super friendly and helpful. The food was very fresh with lots of flavor. My husband had the steak points and I had the shrimp scampi. Both were as delicious as the fantastic warm bread served with the meal! read more

Eatalia is a hidden jewel that locals love to go to for lunch or dinner. Whether it's pizza , spaghetti or their homemade soups, you can't go wrong! Service is fantastic as this establishment makes everyone feel like family! read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill is a casual, welcoming restaurant located in West Palm Beach, Florida. The staff, including our server, were extremely friendly and helpful. The menu offers a wide variety of items, including pizza, salads, and an array of pasta dishes. We thoroughly enjoyed the Penne Ala Vodka and Lasagna, both of which were delicious. We also recommend trying their Pasta Fagioli. read more

See all

The restaurant is more appealing than your average Italian/Pizza spot for dine in. It's casual but has a nice ambiance. Great for meeting friends for lunch or dinner. And to top it off, they have a bar. The service was warm and welcoming. Our server was a sweetheart and very attentive. The food also came out fairly quick. I ordered the Nonna's lasagna which came with soup or salad. I chose the clam chowder and it was chef's kiss! You can actually see and taste the clam pieces with soft potatoes. The lasagna was saucy, cheesy and pretty big. It was delicious. Eatalia satisfied my craving. I can't wait to go back. read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Nonna's Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

Despite a packed house, Enrico along with the rest of the team were gracious hosts and squeezed a table in for us. Food was delicious, as always - we're looking forward to the opening this Friday! read more

Excellent food. Take out or eat in... the quality and quantity is outstanding! The staff is welcoming and accommodating. I'm picky about Italian food coming from a an Italian family in the northeast. I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

I was in the mood for some pizza and have been disappointed lately by the popular chains so I decided to order delivery from this spot where I had good wings from in the past. The hand tossed 18" Neapolitan pepperoni pizza was huge and delightfully delicious with Italian flavor in every bite as it looks like oregano is already sprinkled on. Crust was thin and a bit charred. The Caesar salad with grilled chicken was crunchy and fresh. The portions are extremely generous with plenty to share for two and ordered was delivered a little earlier than expected. read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - 18'' Hand-Tossed Neapolitan Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

We called for a pizza nothing else. The pizza was excellent, flavorful, and right in time for our pickup. The vibe is nice and the place was nicely crowded on a Saturday evening. Staff was very nice. Not much of a review but from this one experience, we'll be back. read more

Wow I have been fairly disappointed with my last few visits here. I don't know. Where to start. Food is good. I like the pasta Spoken with owners they are nice Only good bartender left is Monique and she is nice and talks with you. They have some new people that need more training on customer service The servers are focused on the regulars that hang at the bar way too much. I could see other tables frustrated waiting for someone To check on them. Like everyone know when food gets delivered to a table you should go get on your guests to make sure the food was correct. They have a new girl with blonde hair Who was always behind the register Looking at her phone. I saw her looking at herself. I came up to ask for to go boxes because my sever passed me 3 times made no eye contact nor asked me for help. I think I'm officially done coming here not worth it for me. I rather drive farther to get good pasta! Sorry Monique you are still the last hope this place has. read more

See all

Friendly attentive staff, scrumptious food. Market and bakery are a must when here. The donuts are heavenly.

The extra cheese pizza I order was Delicious and hot... can't say much about the rest as I have only tried the pizza.. will be back for other items read more

Pizza was good so were the pastas the staff was friendly and stayed on top of our needs refills and such. Ambiance is nice casual restaurant

The food in the service are excellent here and the prices are reasonable, really reasonable. The place is nicely decorated, and there seems to be a lot of seniors dining here, which tells me that the food is pretty good. In my 8 years of yelping, seniors, frequenting a venue, spell good dining cuz they're a particular sort. The pizza lured us in. Wow, delightful. Check out the menu. To us it's more of a lunch/early supper place. I'm sure take out is big in the evening. read more

See all

Had dinner there last night. We were a table of 7 all flew in for an event for the weekend. I found your place on Yelp and I'm glad we chose this restaurant. The food was very yummy. The pizza was made to perfection! The desserts and appetizers were delicious as well. Highly recommend for a fun dinner! read more

Went here because of their best pizza awards but it turned out to be so much more ! When we entered and were asked if we had reservations we knew it wasn't going to be what we expected. We started with the lamb chop appetizer and proceeded to the burrata ravioli . Both were delicious. Burrata is my new addiction. lol. Although busy it was quiet due to acoustic tiles , appreciated by this senior citizen. Will definitely return. read more

This is a super solid joint. Same Boston family that owns County Line Pizza in Juno Beach. Food is spectacular. The ambiance isn't as intimate and old school as CLP, but it's a nice space. They have a great appetizer menu that you could just try a few things off that, and as always don't forget the House Special Pizza. Enjoy! read more

Food is incredible. We usually get delivery and it's worth every penny. Every now and then if there's an issue the owner gets right on it and fixes everything. Try the pizza and the penne ala vodka with chicken is awesome. Highly recommend!! read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Sign - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida

Grabbed a pizza slice, a salad, and some mozzarella sticks from here while out running errands. Everything was delicious and had great service too. I'll be back at dinner time to try more! read more

Eatalia Pizza Pasta & Grill - Pizza Near Me - West Palm Beach, Florida