A sunset cruise out of Sag Harbor sounded irresistible and the reality was even better than the…read moremere idea. Captain Hagen's vintage wooden vessel was comfortable and accommodating in all ways for our party of six old friends, but the revelation was the skipper's detailed knowledge of north haven, where we've had a home for many years. He shared what he knew about the waters and coastline features both there and along Shelter Island... in waters we'd sailed past many times in our own old cutter without the benefit of a great story teller's rich narratives. There are creeks and inlets and beaches we'll want to explore again, thanks to a delightful summer evening cruise with just the right captain on just the right vessel for the job. Mike Taibbi Elisa Rojas

Our guide was so informative, funny and accommodating It…read morewas a smooth ride, very comfortable Definitely will go again!

A beautiful sail on Saturday the fourth, and the chance to experience it with a wmll tuned first…read morerate crew. At first they went in search of enough wind to sail, and we ended the cruise racing it to stay clear of impending storms.

Hands down the best thing to do on the North Fork. Erick, Hannah and Christian took 8 of us out…read moresailing for several hours on the schooner Bonnie Lynn, and it made for the most memorable, vibrant and relaxing time. Bonnie Lynn is an incredible boat, with Erick and Hannah the perfect hosts. I can't think of a better way to introduce people to, and share with them, the beauty of the North Fork. We cannot wait for next time, and neither should you.

This was a highlight of our bougie Bachelorette party in Montauk! We rented our own private…read morecatamaran for six people for three hours. It was about $700+ after fees, tip, etc, and it was totally worth it. Our captain, Mason, was super cool. He was friendly, knowledgeable, and we felt comfortable being really annoying and weird in front of him. The sail itself was just a short ride in the bay, where we anchored close to a beach. We loved dancing on the boat, trying out the SUP board (included), basically chugging our BYOB drinks (no hard liquor allowed on board), taking pics lounging in the net, gawking at the yachts, and pretending the pool noodles were seahorses that we were riding. Bachelorette stuff! I think we had the Mon Mini boat, probably the smallest option. Included: one SUP board, bluetooth speaker, cooler, two pool noodles, the captain.

I booked the 26' catamaran for a Friday sunset cruise from 5-7pm. The catamaran was larger than I…read moreexpected. Also, the bean bag chairs were very comfortable compared to other boats. They provided two Yeti coolers and a Bluetooth speaker for music which was nice. The staff were very friendly and helpful. They helped take pictures for our group and the sailing was very smooth. I would definitely book again, probably earlier in the summer for the 3 hour cruise to be able to do the paddleboarding.

We booked a very last minute sail with Eric. He was so flexible and easy going! We arrived with our…read moregroup of 10 which included 6 children of various ages. Eric's boat was clean and comfortable. Big basket of snacks for everyone and a cooler with drinks too. Eric was patient and kind with the kids and let them steer too! He also played the role of lifeguard after we stopped to swim near Shelter Island. Take your family out on a charter with Eric while you're in the Hamptons. It was so so nice!!

Awesome Captain, awesome boat! We have enjoyed Captain…read moreEric's sails since last year and we are real excited to take a sail on the new vessel "Sea Escapes" this season.

It was absolutely amazing trip Thank you do much for fun,…read morevaluable information and super affordable price Well invested money Thank you

They cancelled our charter with 15 minutes notice to arrival time as we were already about to…read morearrive with a party of 15. "Mechanical issues on the charter prior." I bet. This was my plan for my 25th birthday. I had a party of 14 about to be there, and we all already paid. Beyond disappointed as this last minute cancellation has ruined my birthday and left a party of 14 in sag harbor with no backup plan since we received a final confirmation the night before. Thanks American Beauty. Not feeling beautiful.

Played a game of crazy gold with the kids and then rented a hobie cat and sailed around the lake-…read moreloads of fun. What a great place! Reasonable prices.

Perfect spot to rent a hobie car sailboat for an hour on Fort Pond. Remember they are cash-only!…read moreYou can leave your essentials at the front desk with he friendly staffer. We had no trouble getting one mid-day Friday, and the weather cooperates with a nice wind. $50 might seem steep, but it was worth it for the 3 of us to get out on the water and for my daughter to learn how to captain. The dude at the dock made sure my wife could control the boat and gave us a little guidance, then we were on our way to some light sailing fun. Most boat rentals in Montauk seem to be for bigger or motorized craft, so look for what suits you.

We stayed nearby and rented bikes from here…read more Rental prices not cheap although reflect the area. Giving these guys 5 stars because... Rented bikes and headed off with my son towards Montauk lighthouse. About halfway my back tire went flat so I was kind of screwed... was not sure what to do- called the bike place, a young guy from Jamaica drove straight out and was there in about 30 mins. He sorted the bike out in formula one pit stop timing. He was super nice. They saved the day!

love how I gifted the owner 2 nice 'Specialized' brand bikes from the 90s for Free last summer,…read moreworth hundreds of dollars, and then when I come to ask a favor to fix my girlfriends brakes on her bike just now he says I need new tires so I'm like ok ( thinking he'll give me a deal ) he bills me $130 bucks!! $25 of it for ten minutes of labor , so petty, charging me when I gave you hundreds in free inventory?! Gave me zero leeway or hook up. Not how you return a favor or kindness. I figured if you give you'll always have, not in this case! Sorry but you did me dirty guy! Not cool, especially when I say how I knew your main guy Harrison for nearly a decade before he left you & mentioned that.

SO MUCH FUN!!! I've…read morebeen Jetskiing before but I decided to surprise my cousins because they both have never been. Kevin was an AMAZING guide! He helped my cousins learn how to operate a Jet Ski properly and he was incredibly helpful out on the water as well. The Jet Ski's were Yamaha Waverunners and for a 30 minute rental the price is not bad at all. Overall I'd definitely recommend and I can't wait to get out on the water again with Peconic Water Sports!!!

We hired two boats for two hours, and we had a blast. The staff were former professional wake…read moreboarders, and the boats were brand new (literally a week old) specialized water sport boats that generate extra wake for better tubing, wake surfing, wake boarding, etc. The two staff members on each boat were patient, encouraging and polite. They gave great tips and instruction on how to wake board. Our group of 6 (aged 6 to adult) will be back!

Lovely evening sunset cruise aboard the Mary Lloyd!! What a beautiful and very safe feeling boat. I…read moream a little skittish on the water and felt very comfortable especially with Capt. Scott and Mali his first mate. My friends and I enjoyed our time so much we are looking forward to trying an afternoon cruise with some swimming. I highly recommend a charter on the Mary Lloyd.

From the owner: A Fun, romantic and idyllic day out cruising on a beautiful classic boat docked in East Hampton,…read moreNY. Mary Lloyd Boat Charters offers sunset cruises, day cruises, wedding or proposal cruises. She provides a perfect setting to spend a day with friends and family away from the crowds. We can accommodate up to six guests for cruising, swimming, dining, exploring or just relaxing! 1/2 day, full day or sunset cruises tailored to suit you in the surrounding areas such as Three Mile Harbor, Gardiners Bay, Sag Harbor and Shelter Island. Catering can be provided.

The gas dock crew is super helpful and patient. They are friendly and super conscientious.read more

Top notch experience. One of the finest facilities I've ever visited! Super clean, perfect location…read more and professional employees make for a 5-star visit.