Twice now I got ham stromboli, thought first time maybe a new cook. Ate ate claysburg over 50…read moreyears and always loved their food But the past year or two food has been disappointing. Pizza don't taste the way it use to, not sure what was changed but other people had said same thing. And the ham stromboli, well if you call one thin slice of ham and mean thin in a ham stromboli acceptable to call it a ham stromboli, no thank you. Second time we got a ham stromboli , well it should be called a cheese stromboli. So I will find another place to get an actually ham stromboli. So disappointed in the cut is quality. Cause people are noticing it. Hopefully one day the good quality and taste of the old claysburg pizza shop will return.

There aren't many dining choices in Claysburg but whenever in town, we usually visit Claysburg…read morePizza. It's an interesting restaurant / car wash combination and this isn't fine dining, but rather pizza, subs, and pizza-shop items served quickly by friendly people. We've been coming here for years and not been disappointed yet.

OIP is consistently good. They also are familiar with regular orders of locals…read more We've only had take out recently and they have a good variety of offerings. The pineapple and chicken is one of our go to's and it is always loaded with toppings. The white pizza is a nice alternative with tomato slices instead of tomato sauce. The pizza is also good the next day (or two) cold or warmed up!

2nd visit to the area & 2nd visit to this OIP - another good one! First time (a few years ago), I…read moreremember the takeaway being a great spaghetti dinner. On this visit (better documented), the stars of the show were a Stromboli & Chicken Cheesesteak (with mushrooms). Both were knocked out of the park! Typical unassuming downtown 'pizza joint' ....with great food. Service was great - typical casual dining. (I think I was even called 'hon' - it's a PA thing ;) Other diners appeared to be regulars - which would make sense for a small downtown, but have felt welcomed when here - OIP is on my list, next time I'm in town!

Amazing food. I honestly haven't gotten anything that I didn't love…read more The employees are always nice as well. A bonus for sure!

things that could be approved are the cheese steaks. Little on the skimpy side. Their pizza is…read moreamazing but my girl and I got cheesesteaks that were pricey and I honestly felt like it was all bread.

Fantastic!!!! Ohhhhhhh yeah a perfect pizzeria. Big fat slices. Reasonable prices. Great staff…read more Amazing ice cream. Lots of selection and variety. We got two slices and a cup of ice cream for under $10. Unreal. New York style, thin crust but not floppy, great crisp. These guys know what's up. Excellent work.

Awesome food, great service, and outstanding people they are the triple threat. Everything is…read morefresh and made when you order.

We were in the area and decided to try Dunnys out. Don't regret it. The wife had a stromboli and…read moreshe lied it a lot while I had an Italian sub. The roll was decent. It would rival some Italian rolls in Philly. Very fresh. Staff was friendly and place was clean. Bathroom could use some more attention but survivable. All in all a good experience. Would come back. Thanks.

Horrible pizza! A sheer disgrace. No crunch, garbage sauce and cheapest mozzarella. So soggy, no…read moreidea how this place has a 4.0. Please go back to relearning the art of creating pizza and inserting some type of love and quality ingredients. I mean little Caesar's and dominoes are succulent compared to this place. So that tells you a lot. Please try pizza at this dump and tell me how I'm wrong.

Always fast friendly service. Pizza always excellent; always one of my lunch go tos.read more

I'm a native New Yorker that lived half my adult life in rural central Pa missing good pizza…read more Sorry , Brothers and OIP rank not much better than Little Cesar's which is the worst. After a 14 yr return to CNY, I realized for many reasons it was a mistake. The only thing I miss is the food. Best way Pizza has overfilled that void with the most delicious pizza and other items on their menu. I have never been so satisfied anywhere else with everything they have served me and never so fearless to try something different than I usually order or new to me. Best way is the best option. If the quality isn't enough to rave about, the prices are still affordable post covid. The staff are super friendly and helpful too which is a bonus!!! Love you guys, we plan on being regular customers.

First time going to this restaurant on Sunday morning, food was very good but the service not so…read moremuch. Server seemed to care too much about her smoking device and computer rather than her customers. Tried getting her attention a few times and ignored us. Great food but don't come when Shaina is waitressing

Extremely ignorant staff, allowed another customer behaving bizarrely to swear at and attempt to…read morephysically engage with me all while the offending customer was checking out and I was in line behind them. I had my young minor sibling with me. At least 5 staff were in front witnessing this occurrence and not one could conjure up the idea to intervene or tell the man to not use vulgar language in their establishment. Honestly disgusting attitude exhibited by staff.

We were visiting some family and friends in Raystown, saw this place, decided to try it. WOW!…read more There were seven of us in our group. A couple of us ordered the veal Parm with spaghetti, two of us ordered the chicken Alfredo, one ordered the Italian sub, and we ordered, as we were leaving, a Nutella pizza to go. We were impressed with the quality of the food, the taste and flavor, and the service. It seems like it is increasingly difficult to order good, homemade, Italian food. Thankfully, the Original Italian Pizza of Saxton delivered on every front. We came here the night before we left town and we were glad we had not tried this place early on in the trip. Why, you may ask? Because if we had found this place earlier, this would've been the only place we ate at. So yummy!

I love their bread and salads. And the people are very nice. It's one of my favorite places to eat.read more