I ordered delivery to the hotel. The food was here in less than 30 minutes. The delivery driver…read morewas a vet and we had a good conversation. The food was great. Delivered hot and fresh. Will have to stop by the location next time I am in the area.

This is a gem in Newcomerstown. Working this far from major businesses leaves people lacking in…read moreoptions for lunch. The pizza here I would compare to Flyers, Joeseppies, etc in Columbus but some of the options are not as good as them either. The pepperoni pizza or all meat pizza for example are top notch but everything else is above average. I order chicken bacon ranch subs often from them but only because it's better than Subway chicken and fresher tasting due to the oven baked method versus the microwave Subway uses but the sub is not as good as Penn Station or Charley's subs. The steak sub is not great but better than Subway due to being baked. The service is fast and friendly and they always deliver on time or ahead for me. The ambience, well this is in a run down looking building and I am not sure why but this could be out of their hands. They do appear to keep it clean every time I have been in there but it does need a facelift inside and out, and better sign for location and door to distinguish it from the other businesses. Overall not a bad place.

Lovely, quaint and friendly restaurant. Food is delicious. I highly recommend. Service is…read moreexceptional.

Great little pizza shop i have been going to since high school! Never disappoints - alot of great…read morememories there from high school days.

We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The…read moredetail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb!

Best pizza I have ever had..and I have had a lot of pizza! If you are in the area this is…read moredefinitely a must eat!

Hometown pizza done right! LOVE having a buffet style lunch here with friends. Always 5-8 kinds of…read morepizza, (including a dessert style one maybe two) 2-sandwich styles, spaghetti & marinara sauce with garlic bread, & a whole salad bar selection. It's SWEET! You won't be disappointed!! Sorry I go so very often. I didn't even think to take pictures. I love it here.

The best pizza I've ever had. Would be my last meal if I had a say in the matter. My family has…read morebeen eating it for generations

Always very good across the board…read more Well made, reasonably priced Pizza and subs Love the owner as well. Very good

We were passing through and were staying at a hotel not too far away from Pizza Milano…read more Yelp searched for late dinner as it was after 9PM and Pizza Milano came up as "open". Ordered a large pizza with (1/2 cheese & 1/2 veggie) and it was absolutely delicious. They piled the veggies high on our pizza and the cheese side too was amazing. We sat and ate our pizza in their dining room and it hit the spot!!! I even asked for extra onions and they were even generous with them too. Keep up the service & quality and you will never run out of customers.

Food was ok, most of it didn't appear to be "home cooking". Husband ordered a patty melt and only…read moregot his sandwich, no fries or side for $9. Service was more interested in their private conversations with regulars or other staff to pay much attention to their tables. Coffee went empty and waited for a refill then had to ask another server for more cream. The restaurant was very dated and just a small town diner. The ambiance needs some attention if wanting to continue the place, but the building is for sale so not sure.

I LOVE this little diner! I always go there when I'm in the…read morearea Good food at reasonable prices

Great atmosphere , cold beer , plenty of bar seating . A lot of tvs as well . The also have kenoread more

Our server Kristen was very personable and friendly. We small talked and she gave us good advice…read moreall around. Nice place to watch football, big bar and outside seating. Lots of tvs. I had the Philly cheese my hubby has the club. They were both awesome (and I'm picky about my beef). The bread was to die for and made down the street. They have gluten free bread and beer!! We will definitely be back.

We were visiting the area and were looking for a local place to grab a bite and this worked…read moresplendidly. The pizza was good and the wings were great. The pizza was perhaps the cheesiest I've ever had. That's a plus for us but maybe not for everyone. The service was timely, friendly and accommodating. The seating was outside via covered picnic tables which worked great since the weather was nice. The take out business was brisk while we were there during a work day evening which we took as a good sign. We wouldn't hesitate to go back if we were in the area again!!

Pizza was yummy!! Service was excellent! No indoor seating, but weather was perfect for the outdoor…read moreseating area!

Back again & still WOW! This time we noticed too there is almost like a subtle sweet crunch to the…read moreedge of the crust! They truly are cooking up some delicious eats!!!

They cook some great quality good tasting food staffs friendly and helpful services are great…read moreambiance is good atmosphere is good their great for community

Please fix your yelp listing. I passed other places that were open I could've stopped to come here…read morebecause you were marked as open. When I got here your sign says open, the sign on the door says open, but clearly nothing about the place is opened. I would've liked to have tried the pizza, my three star review does not reflect positive or negative to the quality... It looks great in the pictures. It annoys me that you just caused me to not get to eat tonight now that everything that I've passed is closed. Please just fix listing.