2/21/26 - Read a lot of the reviews on Delios Pizza in South Amboy and decided I needed to give it a shot. Notes: when you walk into Delio's, you truly have stepped back into the 1970s. As you can see from the pics, it doesn't look like they've changed a stick of furniture in this place since they opened. Both owners were on premise today when I ordered my pies. When you meet these people, you will feel like you are talking to your grandma and grandpa. That alone gives my review a boost. I ordered a grandma pie (of course) and a pepperoni pie. Both were very good. Both pizzas are firm and stand up nicely as you are eating. The sauce is very tasty, but there's not enough of it on the slices. Both pies could also use a bit more Italian spices. And both pies could have stayed in the oven for another 2 to 3 minutes. Parking is a bit of a headache here too. And Im not crazy about their cash only policy but when you see grandma and grandpa, these things are very forgivable. Overall Rating: B read more

See all

Delio's is the place to go if you want to pick up a quick slice in between running errands! It's run by an elderly couple who do everything from A-Z to keep the shop going. Friendly and cozy interior with plenty of tables. Cash only so come prepared! read more

I wouldn't waste your time if you want to order pizza. I wanted to try their pizza but I called and they said they don't deliver.

Wonderful pizza and how its supposed to be. Those old enough can tell the difference. So glad I stopped in and was worth missing the bus for a slice. Will plan better-- according to another customer the sausage and pepper with cheese rolls are delicious but take 10 mins to heat up to perfection. Ambiance reminds me of my childhood. read more

Grandma and grandpa are running this pizzeria with tons of love and character you can taste it. making the best meatballs sub I've ever tasted. Meatballs are very tasty sauces sweet worth the trip. It's the meatball I travel an hour and a half form Brooklyn to smell Monday's freshly cooked meatballs. Don't be in a rush soak up the 1970s ambience, and relive old school school meatballs. read more

Delio's Pizza - Delio's frontage - Pizza Near Me - South Amboy, New Jersey

Delio's is Delicioso! Let me tell you somethin'. Growing up between Brooklyn and Jersey, I know a good slice when i see (and eat) one. Being rather new to the area, we were on the hunt for the pizza spot to make our family friday night ritual complete. Delio's sicilian is so spot on, nothing else compares. We tried Krispy's in Old Bridge. Been to Sciortino's a million times. This was it. Delightfully crispy crust on the bottoms, the cheese isn't heavy and the sauce is impeccable. I love how old school this place is, sends me right back to Bay Ridge on 3rd Ave. This Nonna and Nonno not only captured our taste buds, but they captured our hearts as well. Take our money forever, we love it here. Thank you for being so kind and generous! Come check it out! You won't be disappointed (as long as you bring cash with you). read more

Delio's was the second spot we went to for our South Ambon pizza crawl, and it was still amazing even though we weren't even hungry! We came on a Tuesday night so it was fairly empty but the warmth was still very present in the restaurant--there was a tiny Italian woman who welcomed us and threw our slices in the oven, and she was so sweet! She threw in an extra slice for free for us. The interior is filled with so much history--family portraits on the walls, the menu sign hanging that looks like it's vintage, and all their decor. This is a restaurant with local history and legacy, and it's so wonderfully refreshing to eat at places like these. No frills, no tricks, no gimmicks, no trends. Just a family and their honest business in good, hearty pizza. Pizza itself was crusty, cheesy, and generous. Couldn't recommend it more! read more

Delio's Pizza - pizza! - Pizza Near Me - South Amboy, New Jersey

The 2 liter soda was expirrd on Wednesday night speciall. No ambiance not renovated since 1970. Pizza undercooked. Service equals huh.

Delicious peppero pizza with a crispy crust! Meatball parmigiana sub was very good!

I have one thing to say, the best Sicilian pizza I ever had. I love this place and go as much as I can. My kids love the Chicken parm subs too. It's one of the best hidden jewels in my opinion. Try a loaded Sicilian you will not be disappointed Dan M read more

wonderful staff and pizza - highly recommend if looking for a slice of pizza in South Amboy

This is an old establishment with very mature owners although the food is pretty good, the place needs a refresh. You won't find a big menu but what they do have is classic Italian food. read more

We are avid and loyal clients there! Best pizza dough in town for sure They always make you feel welcomed Great pizzeria and holding strong clients (following) still. The town absolutely love them read more

Real old school Jersey Pizza. You can not go wrong. It might even be worth the trip off the parkway. read more

Great old school pizza and food!!! White pie is delicious as well as the dinners. Highly recommended.

I'm back for a third visit this month! Today I learned her name is Catherine. I got a delicious white slice & she put in a half regular slice. She remembered I like my slices piping hot! If you don't burn the roof of your mouth it's not hot enough. The regular slice was delish. Perfectly seasoned with a homemade red sauce & a flavorful thin crispy crust! She makes everything from scratch. No canned tomatoes here. High quality cheese. I don't know when I will have business in this town again but you residents are very lucky to have this authentic pizza shop! I can only visit this place in my daydreams since I live 2 hours away; in a land where pizza isn't made by Italians & they still don't know what a bagel is. Mangia you lucky people. read more

Delio's Pizza - Sicilian slice & a half. - Pizza Near Me - South Amboy, New Jersey

Grew up with this place. Recently revisited and it did not disappoint!! Great pizza and great owners!!

45 years making the pizza that I judge all others against. 45 years, the same wonderful couple at the same location. Think about how special that is! I was born and raised in South Amboy...so much has changed. People have come and gone, businesses have come and gone, mega storms have come and gone. Delio's is still there; think how special that is! I visited Delio's on my last trip back east, Mr. Delio told me that they had been at the same location since 1972. I responded that I knew; I remember my Mom ordering then sending us up town to pick up, I remember getting a slice and coke for lunch during my high school years, I remember watching their daughters grow up. Enough tripping down memory lane. Perfect fold in half, drippy red grease, burn the roof of your mouth pizza. The crust is amazing, the sauce is just right (not too sweet, not too thick). The Sicilian pizza is thick with a soft inside, crisp outside with globs of stretchy mozzarella. The pasta dishes are old world and delicious, I especially love the Eggplant Parmigiana as a dinner or a sub. My sister has sworn by their meatballs since we were old enough to walk up town. The calzones are classic with home made dough, Ricotta and Mozzarella inside; get a side of sauce for dipping. The interior hasn't changed since 1972, I giggle to myself that the Italian National Team poster has been on the wall as long as I can remember... I wouldn't change a thing if I could. Parking is street or in the City Hall lot behind. Cash only. Go have a slice and soak up the history, order a pie and enjoy. Cheers! read more

My favorite pizza in town! The owners are awesome people too! Try a chicken slice or a pepperoni slice. You won't regret it!!

Best pizza!! Loved it!! Consistently good and fair price. Nice variety with old school feeling!!

Been living in South Amboy for six years and finally gave Delios a try... Pizza was excellent... This eatery is cash only as they don't accept credit cards.... They also do not deliver... These are the only two down sides... Give Delios a try you will like them.. read more

Old school Italian pizzeria not trying to be something they're not. Excellent pie some of the best in the area; sandwiches are generous not sure where they get their rolls but have that crusty bite. Reasonably priced; been around since I was a teenager always stop in when visiting the area. Family operation could not meet nicer people they go above and beyond. read more

For years, I would drive by this place and I never thought to stop in. However, I'm so glad I was recommended to try this place because it sure is good! The pizza here takes a bit of time but that's only because it's prepared for perfection literally. No exaggeration this place is top 5 places I have ever had a single slice from. I'm definitely a fan of this place now and that says a lot after only one visit. read more

Classic Italian Pizza Joint. The pizza is good for the local area but it is not the best. It is operated by a sweet Sicilian couple for over 40 years. It is a bit old I bet that the restaurant looked pretty much the same since it opened. They probably kept the recipe the same since they opened. It is a bit greasy for my taste. The service is... its a pizza place. The couple that owns it seems nice. They only accept cash. The decor looks straight out of the 70s. It could use a makeover. It is very dark. read more

old school pizza place they have been in business for 50 years they are doing something right great pizza

Tasty pizza and subs. Nice lady making the pizza. Ordered a meatball pizza and a chicken parmesan sub. Pizza was tasty and cheese was stringy ( I like that). Chicken parmesan sub was lightly breaded and moist. Place is sort of between retro and hole in the wall. My T-Mobile signal very low and no wifi. read more

See all

Been going here since 1976. It was our go too for lunch when I wad in school. Great pizza! Oweners are awesome! Closeted to NY Pizza in town! read more

Old school pizza perfection. Meatball and chicken parm are delicious. Best Sicilian pie around!

The best pizza in town and around. Stop by for a few slices. The owners are always there an older Italian woman and man. She always gives extra slices if you're nice ... she makes the best pizza and hot dishes nothing ever frozen always fresh food read more

Wow I just drive by this Mom & Pop pizza pie place. Stoped in for a slice while house hunting. Omg so amazing. I got a large cheese for $14. So nice, great customer service. I will be back. I ate 3 pieces in the car. So yummy. read more

Delio's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - South Amboy, New Jersey

Been going here since I was a young boy. My favorite place to get pizza from. I have to tell you the pizza with the works is the bomb. It so good and tasty. I guarantee you will enjoy it. I used to like their subs years ago, but not sure if they are still are making them. The owners Cathy and Pete who have owned this place forever are great friendly people. read more

The pizza is amazing! Locally owned and the family I is very friendly! Worth the trip and worth going to grt cash out!

When I hear people hyping up certain restaurants, I usually try to ignore it the best I can. I like to keep an open mind on a new place, and have my own opinion on it. So anyways, I tried out Delio's, because all I've been reading on Yelp is that Delio's is second to none, and the reviews make it sound like their ingredients come from the Garden of Eden. Nope, sorry Delio's. Nice try though. I had the pleasure of meeting the nice Italian couple who run the place. They really are polite to their customers, which I can appreciate, since bad service is so common here in NJ. Inside their store, they keep a lot of family pics hanging on the walls, along with a lot of small religious statues standing around the cooking station. Nothing fancy, but makes it a real comfortable setting. We had a large pie with "The Works". The pizza had a good amount of toppings: pepperoni, peppers, mushrooms, onions.. I would definitely go back to try other items on their menu. It's good pizza, don't get me wrong. But life-altering? No... If you're looking for a mind-blasting, out-of-body pizza experience, head down the street from Delio's, and you'll find it... *cough*SCIORTINO'S*cough* read more

You have to stop and get a sub and share a slice with someone. Quaint surroundings in small town Americana. read more

Delio's Pizza - Pizza and subs in the best little city of the US - Pizza Near Me - South Amboy, New Jersey

Pizza is legit. I have been coming here for 15 years now, nothing has changed. Husband cooks and wife watches the register and deals with the customers. You cannot go wrong with their pizza - probably one of the best in this area. read more

it's cash only. it's a family business. old school awesome Italian food. inside a bit outdated but they are so sweet and want to make sure you are happy. the best pizza!! awesome baked ziti. read more

You want this place to both be recognized as one of New Jersey's best (if not THE best) while at the same time wishing it to remain "undiscovered" and remain as is. Absolutely some of the greatest pizza I've ever eaten, and that includes every marquee place in NJ, NYC, Chicago, (wood ,coal, gas, whatever) and all points in between. Perfect crust on a basic tomato pie. Perfect sauce/cheese ratio and flavor. Obviously high quality ingredients and a lot of care. The owners have that "pride and hospitality" thing happening, about which way too many other eating establishments at all levels remain clueless. Can't wait to go back! read more

I've been coming to Delio's all my life. Pete & Cathy make the best pizza in So. Amboy. I've never gone wrong with this place :) read more

See all

Best pizza I've ever had in NJ. And I'm from NY so I'd like to think I know a thing or two about a thing or two.

Always a quality pizza. I love how passionate they are about their product. The clientele is loyal for a reason.