D'Amatos is our absolute favorite place for pizza For flavor, the pizzas NEVER disappoint; for the LOOK of the pizza, they never disappoint! When you open the box, it is a work of art. Also, loads of cheese and perfect crusts - EVERY TIME (we buy about one a month). The service is also spot-on. read more

Yumm!! Love Medium size pizzas! The large pizzas are too gooey and the crust is too thin. ** Well maybe because We order extra sauce because it is so delish along with the pepperoni and sausage! read more

A treat from the cheese pull gods. This place is takeout only and it takes a bit for the food to come out, we waited about 20 minutes. There's no seating inside or out so I would recommend calling ahead and just picking up. We got the turkey sandwich and the cheese calzone. The turkey sandwich was yummy, had nice soft bread and fresh veggies. And the cheese calzone? SO cheesy. The cheese pull went so crazy it was almost too much haha. It had a nice garlicky flavor and they did not skimp out on the sauce! The sauce was sweet and slightly herbaceous. So yummy! read more

See all

This is hands down My family's favorite pizza joint in San Diego.. I'll go by saying, I'm a NYC Pizza connoisseur! Hoboken Connoisseur... I've had pizza all over Los Angeles and basically everywhere in San Diego that's good ( I lived in downtown for 10 years ). My ex even owned his own brick oven pizza company so I know my pizza! This is what you order : The Guissepe Works ( omg let me tell you yum!!!! )... Sometimes we get the family special it's a great deal if you are entertaining people. But if you are going for the pizza... Get THE GUISSEPE!!! My Mouth is watering thinking about it... FYI these aren't my normal go to toppings... haha but this is the real deal !!! I'll take a photo next time ... These other yelpers got it all wrong;) read more

Love this place. It's a tiny little spot, no seating, so I usually just call ahead and order my pizza. It's always got the most deliciously thick layer of cheese on top of the toppings. The sauce has great flavor and the crust is perfectly chewy. Service is quick and friendly. read more

Food is amazing. Staff is very very friendly, service was impeccable. I felt like I was in Italy.

Ordered a Family feast deal, Pizza , ravioli and the Lasagna was absolutely delicious . From ordering to picking up order service was excellent! Highly recommend this place! read more

Been coming here for their food for years. But lately the constancy has not been there. Both pizzas had so much cheese you could not taste anything eked the toppings. We ended up not eating most of it. The doughy was great as always. The bummer is I wrote to them with the date and time do they could speak to the guys a reiterate the process to making thier great pizza. They never responded. Do Ivam searching elsewhere because 50 plus $ spent you should be able to enjoy it. read more

D'Amatos Pizza - Pizza with to much cheese. - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

Yo this place was sick, everyone was nice. Definitely coming back bro holy it was so good the service fantaatic

Some of the best pie I've had in a LONG TIME no seating but that no problem, great customer service, very polite and professional read more

D'Amatos Pizza - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

great pizza ! I love the works and I get a bbq chicken pizza for my dad. He loves it! thank you everyone for all your hard work here !

This place SUX!!!!!! The rep spoke like he was on cracc! I could not understand a word he said. He never asked me how much I would like to tip my driver. He just assumed I was tipping $2.00! When my driver arrived, I had to ask what amount he was tipped via my card. That's never okay! The CSR kept putting me on hold as well. This was very irritating to me being a business owner and professional! Also, how are you charging me $30.00 for a personal pan pizza and dessert?? I don't like how this establish works!!! At my Financial Firm we treat clients like they come first! and AMAZING! You all need a lot of training!!!!!!!! I get treated better at my nail establishement! read more

I ordered the family deal.. specifying 3 times on the phone no meat sauce.. we got meat sauce.. the spaghetti sauce was VERY watered down .. The manicotti sauce was no where near what it use to be.. ( this was a favorite in our house) the pizza was lacking in flavor.. I have been coming here for years .. I am sad to say this will be my last time.. read more

This is my go to pizza place here in La Mesa. Absolutely the best around! It's a small carry out or delivery restaurant right next to Baskin Robbins. I normally just have it delivered. Their meatballs are fantastic, I always get a pepperoni and meatball pizza. They also have pasta and calzone with are delicious as well. But the pizza...mmmm. read more

Best pizza in the county!! we have been going here for several years and absolutely love it.

Went for the first time last night! Got two medium pizzas for carryout! One 5 meat and one BBQ chicken and it's the best pizza I've had in San Diego! Can't wait to go back! Might go again today! Food was very easy to pick up and they accept cash or card! read more

Don't order from here ever it's cheese on bread pizza hella light toppings and soggy wings no extra dipping sauces worst 70 bucks I've spent food is so ex these days it's horrible when it's a jacked up meal when we pay so much go litt Cesar's next time read more

Pizza is delicious. I will say if you're not a fan of cheese, maybe let them know to use light cheese. They add cheese on top of the toppings. Personally, one of my favorite parts, but not everyone is like me... for example my husband thinks it a little much. read more

We ordered a D'Amatos special pizza and Torpedo Sandwich. Pizza was soggy and not as good as it used to. Sandwich was sloppy. Most likely will not be a returning customer. read more

Great prices for good pizza. I bought three pies for a birthday dinner. Meatball and black olives, pepperoni, and a veggie pie. All tasted great and I would order there again. It's about 20 bucks for their large pie. My order fed 6 people easily. Local and convenient place. read more

Absolutely the BEST pizza in La Mesa !! Have never been disappointed. The sausage is the BEST too. ALWAYS TOP QUALITY EVERY TIME

We were ignored in the store until I said "HI! HELLO?" And they kept talking, we received 10 wings not 12? And they kept asking for our name from the back! Like if you can't hear me out girl then come to the front to attend your customers. I used to love this place but the more I go the more disappointed I am. DONT COME HERE read more

D'Amatos Pizza - 10 wings!! Not 12? - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

Everytime I order for pick-up the order is 15 to 20 minutes later than the time I was told to pick up the order. I will not say that is the worse part. Tonight I placed an order and of course I had to wait per usual. I was charged and told to come back in 5 to 10 minutes. I come back 15 minutes later only to be completed ignored by the girl at the register absolutely rude and unpleasant. This place is getting a reputation for their rude employees and terrible customer service. As someone quite familiar with customer service the employees do not make the cut. Someone should train the employees in proper customer service and after all of that the pizzas were burnt The Pizza tasted like a cracker. I will take my business elsewhere and you should too. read more

Delicious pizza by the slice! The sauce had a very good Italian flavor and it had an adequate amount of cheese and I added pepperoni! You can add toppings as you like! It's a great way to curb your appetite when you want a little pizza! read more

See all

The Pizza I love most is the White Pizza, Delicious. There calzones are delicious. They make homemade ricotta, you can't beat that!! Go Try D'Amatos. You won't be disappointed. read more

This is SUCH La Mesa's favorite secret spot. My hubby and I have never, ever been dissatisfied with any order. Photos show the Rockstar Club! A must have. read more

D'Amatos Pizza - The Rockstar Club underside - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

See all

Always delicious and worth the price!! It's our go to for pizza. Service is great, we usually see the owner.

Overall Terrible... They barely drain the spaghetti so it's sitting in water till I get home and drain it. The salad that is included with the dinner is a joke... total throw away. It's evident when I go inside to pick up my food that it's run by adolescents and things like professionalism & decorum are a foreign concept. Sadly, cleanliness is also nonexistent. read more

I thought this pizza spot was pricey, that is until I opened the box and took a bite. Pepperoni pizza; you won't see the pepperoni. But trust it's there, underneath the generous amount of cheese! My new favorite pizza spot! read more

I love this place! Everything is so delicious! Staff is amazing. Delivery is always correct and on time. Sandwiches are absolutely amazing! Best bread ever! Best meatballs Best everything! I'd give more stars if I could! read more

While we were visiting family, we had D'Amatos Pizza delivered for dinner. Ooooh my goodness!! This was sooooo delicious!! We had ordered sausage and mushrooms. I wanted to add extra cheese but I was told they were very generous with their cheese!! WOWZA!! They were correct!! Basic pizza ordered but D'Amatos made our pizza with perfection! Our delivery guy delivered our pizza on a timely matter. The next time we're in town, we'll be ordering another pizza!! read more

See all

This place is great and the staff is very nice. $2.30 for a big slice of pizza. The lasagna is amazing. Cheesy, meaty, and covered in sauce. It comes with a whole baguette of garlic bread and a side salad! You could definitely split it. Real Parmesan cheese on the side (not those little packages). Great price and great food. read more

Ordered a TBA 6" sandwich thru Grubhub. Plenty of turkey, crispy bacon, and a little skimpy on the avocado. Which is pretty understandable given the price of avocados right now. As long as they keep their prices low. Overall A 4.5 rating. Would be a 5 if their tomatoes had any taste at all and were sliced a little thinner . Definitely ordering from them again read more

D'Amatos Pizza - TBA no lettuce - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

Eh. Ordered a couple of sandwiches and were told over the phone it would be an hour. No problem. Got there an hour later and the girl at the counter said it would be a few more minutes. Waited another 10-15 and got our food which was cold. Husband loved the food aside from the temperature so he will want it again but I wasn't impressed. We got their pizza before and it was fine. read more

Every time I get a pizza here the cheese slides off of the slice with all of the toppings. $30 for a large pizza where you pick up the slice and it goes so limp everything falls off? No thanks! $30 for pick up. I won't be going back read more

So far so good ! Had the pizza first time . It was good . Definitely not like dominos and all those pizza chains . There is allot of cheese in pizza and it does come off be careful it'll fall o. Ground if not handled properly. My son still thought it was good and I like the pizza as well. I have yet to try the pastas and sandwiches! read more

Ooooooooohhhh no! Lol I can't say I'll be back. If we are judging this by lasagna standards it is a 3.5 but this is supposed to be pizza . The sauce is a win but that is the only win here. This pizza is UNNECESSARILY MOIST. There is so much cheese, like... more than any lasagna you've ever had in your life amount of cheese. This causes it to harden and separate itself from the crust. Thankfully, that allowed me to cut the wet bottom from the crust and remove the cheese completely and eat the sauce only part... Sauce is dank. read more

See all

I always love coming to this place they have the best epic family meal deal that includes the best pizzza ever and lasagna or manacotti or spaghetti! With two salads and breadsticks! Or garlic bread! Customer service is always kind ! Highly recommended read more

Worst pizza ever. Ordered it at 6:30, got there at 6:50 to pay for and pick it up- had to wait until 7:20 when it was ready (nice and hot!). Got home to find little cheese and chewy as well, burnt crust, super greasy too. Got a couple anti-pasta salads - all for over $40 bucks. The pizza was worse than frozen from the store. Had to go since it's my father-in-laws favorite place because of the cheap 18 inch extra large pizza. Like I said, Worst. Pizza. Ever. read more

D'Amatos Pizza - Mmm, burnt chewy cheese... - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California

See all

I wish I could give them 0 stars because this is a JOKE. I placed an order for my boyfriend to pick up around 4:30. Mind you, I worked until 6 and just got home at 6:30 ready to eat my food. I told the man over the phone that I wanted manicotti but NO MEAT. I literally asked him "there's no meat in that right? I can't eat meat." He said let me check-- went and checked, "nope there's no meat." I get home and open the food. It's very clearly in a meat sauce. I call the guy back and nicely ask if it can be remade because I can't eat meat. He says I can BUY another one, but there will be no refund or remake. Are you kidding me? The food is UNEATEN and will not be eaten because I'm a vegetarian. I recently moved down the street and we've been here a few times and never had any issues. NEVER again. Terrible service. How are you gonna mess up my order and then refuse to remake it? read more

D'Amatos Pizza - a cheese pizza on tin foil - Pizza Near Me - La Mesa, California