Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Crusty Pizza

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Crusty Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Crusty Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    We get pizza here quite regularly. Always a favorite at our house. Service is great and delivery is a big bonus.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 154 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Taste of Naples Pizzeria - Taste of Naples Pizzeria - 16" round pizza with pepperoni & mushroom

    Taste of Naples Pizzeria

    4.7(83 reviews)
    61.9 kmPine Grove
    $$

    Mama Mia! Is this the best pizza in town?…read more I finally came to check out the top reviewed pizza shop in Vaughan. Taste of Naples Pizzeria is hugely popular for locals here with many Italians in the area. The 16" pizza yielded 8 large tasty slices with a soft light pizza crust, fresh tomato sauce & good topping ingredients. Crisp thin crust bottom gave a nice finish. This is a real Neopolitan pizza that's a touch better than I've had elsewhere. You do pay a bit more for the quality compared to another local fav next door. Be sure to order takeout early as we encountered a queue but our pizza was ready in a timely manner. Just wait for your number to be displayed outside before heading in to pickup. As they say on the restaurant wall, you owe it to yourself to try. Let me know what you think!

    Pizza was decent. Better than the budget pizza restaurant chains. Although I found the crust to be…read moreslightly burnt and they charge 2.4% extra to cover the cost of accepting credit cards. It wasn't mentioned at the time of purchase, and I didn't realize it until I got home. We are the pizza about 30 minutes after pickup, and found the crust to be hard and chewy. For the reasons of the pizza being burnt, the surcharge, the tough crust, and that there are many pizzarias to consider in Toronto instead, so I will not be returning.

    Photos
    Taste of Naples Pizzeria - Outside

    Outside

    Taste of Naples Pizzeria - Taste of Naples Pizzeria - 16" round pizza with pepperoni & mushroom with fresh tomato sauce inside

    Taste of Naples Pizzeria - 16" round pizza with pepperoni & mushroom with fresh tomato sauce inside

    Taste of Naples Pizzeria - Thin crust, well done. Pepperoni, bacon, sundried tomatoes and roasted peppers

    See all

    Thin crust, well done. Pepperoni, bacon, sundried tomatoes and roasted peppers

    Crusty Pizza

    Crusty Pizza

    3.6(5 reviews)
    20.6 km

    Crusty Pizza really should get more than 3 stars, their pizza and wings are pretty good actually. I…read morewas very impressed with their wings. Normally I don't like baked wings, but somehow they taste like they are fried. Reason they are getting a lower rating is there seems to be managerial/operational problems with this location. I went in to order, staff were in the back talking. Not a big deal, but no one heard me. So after waiting a few minutes, I had to open and close the door again to get their attention. I order pizza and wings with hot sauce. I end up getting an overdone pizza, and wings with honey garlic sauce. These are all minor things, but it makes a difference between a great experience and a disappointing one.

    I gave this review back in December. Not sure why it was deleted, but here it is again…read more If I could give Crusty Pizza Port Perry a zero star review I would. I ordered a pizza and panzo for delivery. It arrived an hour and a half later, and the order was wrong. When I called to advise them that it was wrong I was told that was what was written down, and that was what I ordered. I told them that was not the case as I would never order spicy sausages on my pizza or mushrooms for that matter. I was told by the girl on the phone that I could either get a credit or I could have them remake the panzo and they would bring it to me in an hour. I told her that was fine I would wait the hour for the correct panzo. 10-15 minutes later I get a phone call back from the same girl who advised me I would have to pay another delivery charge for their mistake if I wanted my order . I told them there was no way I was paying for their mistake and that I would appreciate my correct order delivered. She then proceeded to tell me I was in the wrong and that when I had placed the order the girl had confirmed my order twice. This was not the case as I would have told them they got the order wrong. So basically they called me a liar and then refused to bring me my panzo. My options, according to the girl were to come in for a refund, pay for the extra delivery charge or come in and get my own corrected panzo. I told them I would be in for my refund. I get all the way to the store and the girl refuses to give me a refund. Tells me I can take my pizza and leave. She refused to give me a managers name, refused to give me the owners name, refused to give me any information. Essentially they took my money and made me the wrong order and wouldn't give me my money back, that they yet again told me I would get over the phone. I spoke to their 'manager' this morning who in no short words told me to go elsewhere and then proceeded to yell at me and hang up on me. It's no wonder the employees act this way if this is how the manager acts. I would highly suggest they work on their customer service!

    Crusty Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...