We tried Crumbl Cookies for the first time. The line was outside into the a parking lot but it moves very quickly. Many cookies were sold out but if you agree to wait, they will make more for you. We waited about 30 minutes total for the line and for fresh cookies. Chocolate chip, Fruity pebble, iced oatmeal, and frosted sugar cookie were the ones we tried and they were all good. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Building - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Cookie was waay too sweet. It was like eating just sugar. Overpriced & not that good. Not as many options as I was expecting.

to start out I placed a pickup order for a certain time. my order was not ready and I stood around for 30min while people who were ordering in the store were receiving their orders ahead of me. I watched the guy making cookies slamming everything around and when he brought peoples orders over he never once opened the box to show them so they could see if the order was correct except for one girl who appeared to be about his age. that was the only time I saw him act halfway friendly. he was throwing the cookies into the box. when I finally did receive my order there was icing all over the outside of the box that got all over my shirt and my turtle cheesecake looked like the toppings had all slid over from him manhandling it read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

After repeated experiences in this location I felt compelled to post a review. This restaurant is often dirty and the service is slow. At this particular time, there is 14 orders to be picked up and 1 single person boxing up orders read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Absolutely filthy location. - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

the cookies are so good but I was missing half of my order which really sucked especially since I'm 40 minutes away and didn't notice until I got home read more

Best cookie dough ever the staff need to be trained on how the cookie reward works it has been very difficult to get my rewards cookie and I still havent read more

Love this location , I usually love there cookies, my cookies were raw and this is not the first time that I get raw cookies at this location it's a hit or a miss with Crumbl , I have mentioned to the manager on several occasions and she stares at me like a deer in the headlights, I mentioned it once to a team member they stayed this is how the manager has us to cook them !! Sorry no one wants to eat a bunch of raw cookies, they taste disgusting and in edible!! Staff is always polite and professional but the manager only cares about a sale because you keep giving us / me raw cookies and after I get home and try to cook them more it's to late and I just wasted 30.00 or more on cookies trying to salvage the edible ones !! Very disappointed customer !! Raw cookie from Crumbl Cookie from Saturday !! I couldn't touch it with my hands I had to put on a glove , would you want to eat this ? read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Raw cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

I love the location and the customer service that Crumbl Cookies provides. And the cookies there are super yummy too! Definitely a place for the whole family to try out and enjoy the different types of treats. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

4/5 times we went the cookies were raw. Friends in other states rave about their cookies so we kept trying to see if we maybe just went on an off day but every time seems to be an off day. Staff aren't the friendliest and wait times are long. Biggest issue is the raw egg in the cookies since they're always extremely raw and cold in the center. Would recommend a local bakery instead. Overpriced raw cookies unfortunately here. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Crumbl Cookies are okay. I really enjoyed the pumpkin cream cookie, the rest were just okay. The oatmeal tasted nothing like an oatmeal cookie. The chocolate chip although warm, was almost not cooked enough. It was not work $13 that I paid. I'm not sure when I'll go back if I go back. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

I was in a rush and ran in to get a business snack taken care of. The staff was helpful and quick! However- it is summer and very hot. So by the time I had the meeting the cookies were half melted or falling apart. If the box had compartments/ was sturdier I think it would have held up. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Employees avoid eye contact, and are quick to make comments or hold conversations with each other while customers are waiting.

Look at the difference between the advertised one and what I got. Also had to wait 20 minutes even though I ordered an hour ahead of time still had to wait. read more

Crumbl - Evansville - Maple bacon cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

I first tried Crumbl cookie a cpl years back when I was visiting my Colorado home, I just happen upon them, I was impressed with the overall experience, cleanliness and courtesy of the employees read more

We bought the Churro, Orange Roll, Mint Chocolate Chip, and Turtle cookies. The Orange and Churro were warm cookies and the Mint and Turtle were cold cookies. The cookies were quite large and very sweet. My favorite was the Orange Roll-it had a light citrus flavor, not overbearing. It was also more of a bread consistency than a cookie. The Churro tasted more like a cinnamon fragrance than a flavor to me. The Mint had very little flavor. The Turtle was a bit hard and extremely rich chocolate flavor-too much for me. We paid around $15 for the 4 cookies. Probably would not have a craving to go here again. read more

Delicious cookies, wish there were more holiday theme based cookies. The service is fast.

I was just here and there were quite a few people in store so a girl told me I could order at the counter. When they brought me my order and showed it to me it was wrong and I told them I had ordered something else. The girl then told another guy to go get the right cookies. I told him I was standing over here when I said the order so that way they knew I was ordering at the counter instead of the app and would give me the correct order. The guy then said "there's no need for you to yell at us." I wasn't trying to yell I was trying to make sure that they could hear me because the shop was very crowded and loud, and they had already given me the wrong cookies previously. Was not pleased with this guy's rude remarks. One star for this visit. read more

What's not to like? The place is clean and white! The smell when walking in indicates that what is in those pink boxes are the best cookies and they are! The ice cream is just as good! read more

Love these cookies!! Visiting from out of town and was super happy to find my favorite place! I got to share them with my family and they all loved them. We couldn't decide which flavor was best! All 5 stars! I see a habit forming. read more

The cookies were falling apart. Way too expensive for the products. Too sweet. The icing on the sugar cookie that was piped on was gross. Don't waste your money here. read more

Crumble cookie gave me a number to call to try and make it right but the number was fake

The cookies are good... the help is less than deserving of minimum wage. There are a few stars, but they are overshadowed by the Chads :(

would leave 0 stars if I could. they fr told us it would be a 10 minute wait. and we proceeded to wait for 10 minutes and she calls our name and says they are out of the cookie after we paid when they clearly were not out. read more

I have wanted to try this place out since it first opened but every time I went by the line was out the door. Finally decided to order ahead and do curb side pickup this morning all because this week they have a cornbread cookie. I ended up ordering all four of this week's featured cookies.....Churro, Cornbread, Chocolate Crunch and Original with peanut butter M&M's. I didn't have to wait long to get my order given it was around 9:30 on a Monday morning. I tried a little of each once I got home. The Churro tasted very much like a Snickerdoodle and I like snickerdoodles. But churros are a different thing so this one missed the mark for me. The Chocolate Crunch looked similar to a no bake cookie except with Rice Krispies but was very sticky. It was very chocolatey for sure. The original was just OK. Now to the one I specifically went there for.... The Cornbread cookie. It was also just OK. None of these cookies make me want to return to Crumbl. Especially not for almost $3 a piece. They are big cookies so maybe that's not unreasonable but I don't think I will go back. read more