I was really excited to eat at CRUDO (yes, I'm obsessed with Somebody Feed Phil and he had totally sold me on this being an incredible and special meal in Oaxaca), but I was a little underwhelmed by the experience.
The space is nice (although it has moved since Phil eat there, so don't expect that same space). And the service was good (similar to other omakase experiences I've had, where the servers check in with you about drinks throughout the meal); everyone was friendly.
Unfortunately, I wasn't wowed by the food. I was so excited to try "omakase oaxaqueño," which is a concept that sounds like a dream. But none of our courses were very memorable. I had to look back at my photos to remember what we had. There was a baby corn nigiri that was probably my favorite bite, but otherwise even my own photos aren't really jogging my memory (unusual for me). There's also the fact that the omakase is only 8 or 9 courses (I can't remember exactly, and I don't think I took a picture of every single one). (FYI if you haven't had omakase before, it translates to "I'll leave it up to you." You don't order, the chefs select what they serve you based on the freshness of ingredients and their preferences. It's usually several courses/pieces of sushi - from 12-20+ - as well as a dessert or two.)
Then there was the payment. If you get anything from this review, remember this - THEY ONLY TAKE CASH. (They say cash or bank transfer, but what on earth is a bank transfer?) Now, in general, you should carry cash with you in Oaxaca (lots of places only take cash). But I guess I was remembering our fancy meals out in Mexico City earlier this year (I know, I know; Oaxaca is different) and didn't anticipate needing cash. They sent me a Whatsapp message 1-2 hours before our reservation reminding us, which was good, because otherwise I definitely wouldn't have thought to run by a bank ATM before the meal.
The value isn't horrible. I think the meal was about $80pp (without any drinks). That's close to what you might pay for some omakase experiences in NYC (lots that are less than $125, but you might have fewer pieces/courses). It was more that it was so few courses. I was still pretty hungry when I left, so we had a little late night snack food after. (Eater recommended it for "Dinner 2" on a single evening, which I thought was crazy, but now I see why!) We probably spent $100-120 pp after having a little sake and adding tip. Which is pretty expensive to still be hungry after you leave.
Overall, it was a cool experience, but I appreciated the concept more than I appreciated the food or the experience. Still, if it's your thing, give it a try (I wouldn't insist any of my friends going to Oaxaca eat here though)! And have cash ready and don't come too hungry! read more