I went with a friend to get a few things for a ski trip, having previously had work colleagues rave and go on about the savings and quality at Costco. Now, I do feel I can comment on all prices, savings and quality as at home I'm the primary shopper, cook and frequent Coles, IGA, Foodland and various local producers as well, and have done this for over 2 decades.
My first impression was it's big, the shopping trolleys are big, and all the offerings, be it the size of packaging or the size of actual prepared food items. They sell TV's and assorted electronics - I didn't have a great look but a TV very similar to the one I purchased 3 months ago was $800 more. If you were to find an item here that is cheaper than anywhere else than you can easily get your $60 membership back on one item alone but I bet places like The Good Guys would sell to you for the same. A 6 pack of WD40 worked out to about $2 less per can - WD40 does go on sale at Bunnings and I've previously picked it up for less. If you're someone who would go through that much then I guess you can save a little. I didn't see any 'bargains' in that section.
Fresh fruits and vegetables were ALL more expensive than my local fruit and veg shops at Ridleyton and Hindmarsh plus I would have to buy in large quantities. Tomatoes were three times the price, lemons and apples twice, potatoes slightly comparative etc. On top of that some looked a bit over-sized and water logged. While on this, capsicums and tomatoes (to name two only) naturally grow to a size - if you find them huge and heavy they've been made like that, generally have no flavour but lots of water retention and that's so you pay more and get less. I will mention something here that I felt whilst there and in any conversation I have had - people who rave on about Costco don't care as much about taste as they do about cost/quantity for reasons unknown - either they have not eaten quality or they've outgrown the need for it. You may disagree but that is obvious to me and I will touch on it again later.
The bakery section had cakes/pies a little cheaper than the Cheesecake shop and trays of a dozen muffins for $10. Again what stood out was portion sizes. No wonder we are getting fatter. The cakes were all larger than normal (perhaps good for kids parties) and the muffins at least twice the size of a regular muffin. I ended up tasting both and I have to say both were very disappointing. If I want to put a sugary tasteless baked product in my mouth to ensure I don't go hungry I will eat them. But if I want to eat something delicious, or with better and indeed known ingredients, then I will not buy here. I would rather buy a tray of muffins for $20 and love them. Unfortunately the people who can afford less are the ones who tend to carry more weight and also the ones who spend all their disposable income on fast food and will all shop here.
A trio of dips costs more than a regular supermarket and there's no great flavour choices but you get MORE in quantity. Soft drinks are cheap. Hot dog sausages, strangely, cost twice as much as Coles but the actual sizes would have been bigger. Ice creams come in bigger packs. There were only three choices for crackers and they came in large packs of three for hardly any savings. Why would I buy crackers with questionable ingredients that I wouldn't normally eat and buy, just because a place gives them to me in an extra large sizing for a nominal saving? Every pre-prepared product and packaging is bigger. A slab of a dozen baked beans cans was $12, and I can often buy them for that at my local, where the choice is far greater - Costco offers just one. I couldn't find any decent plain chocolate.
Finally, the best and the worst. I bought a large pack of strawberries for about $6.50 which worked out to just over three regular containers, often sold for $2-$3 each. They lasted for a few days and were quite fresh and nice. My kids love kettle chips and 500 gram bags sell for around $6. Given we don't pay more than $3 per bag normally that's a saving of about $2 over 500 grams. And the worst? $6.99 for a lovely super large roast chicken. I have never tasted anything so bland, tasteless, kind of metallic and gross, that also looked so bad. Upon opening the container I noticed the chicken was huge with very pronounced breast sections. Cutting into the rib cage I saw it was large, dry, the bones thinner than normal. Despite its size the chicken had no fat deposits, no fat under the skin, not even at the cavity exit. Given how it looked, its size and flavour, I have no doubt these chickens are fed and pumped with steroids and chemicals to not only make them grow extra large in a quicker time but to also make them less fatty. They taste disgusting and I have no interest in eating genetically modified birds and feeding them to my kids.
Adelaide is full of delicious food - don't shop at Costco. read more