Mike Marshall is awesome to work with. He is also very patient. I was very upset with the rates & customer service I received from my prior insurance carrier when I contacted Compass Insurance Agency. Mike took the time with me to run many different scenarios to get the be best coverage. After seeing a significant amount in savings, I ended up switching my home, vehicles, ATV, & travel trailer over to Compass Insurance Agency. Customer service is awesome too! Thanks to Mallory. I needed something added to my policy & the info faxed over to my bank. It was done as quickly as possible. I definitely recommend checking out Compass Insurance Agency. read more

I cannot believe how fast and stress-free the insurance swapping process was with Compass Insurance Agency. In less than a day Brad Schaap was able to price out plans and successfully bundle mine and my fiance's auto insurance and our homeowners insurance for less than what we were paying before, all in time for me to head to the dealership and pick up my brand new car SAME DAY with no issues! Talk about raising the stakes, but Brad handled everything so efficiently. I highly recommend reaching out to Brad if you're interested in shopping for a new insurance plan. read more

We were recommended to Dan at Compass when we were in the process of buying a new car and shopping for a good insurance rate. Dan made a difficult time a lot easier with his responsiveness, willingness to answer questions, and taking the time to find out exactly what we needed. One of the best parts is he was even able to save us money, even with adding collision to our policy for the new car we are paying the same amount as we were for ONLY liability with our old company! Thank you to the whole Compass team for making the whole process easy and painless! read more

Compass Insurance was able to save us money and made sure to explain everything in our policy to us. They're great about answering any questions we have. I love working with them and their staff is so friendly. I was even able to persuade one of my friends to have them look at an insurance policy for her, and they saved money for her too! I would definitely recommend Compass to anyone who is shopping around for insurance. read more

Compass is the best agency I have worked with. Paul Middel was outstanding and helped me lock in some incredible rates. 15 minutes may save you 15 percent, but 30 minutes with Paul saved me over 40 percent!!! Now you tell me, who are you going to call? A little gecko, or one of the professional and knowledgable agents at Compass. I am confident that answer is clear. read more

Mike Marshall is phenomenal! He went above and beyond to find me the best rate to insure my new home and even got me a discount on my auto insurance! My realtor is one of the best in my area and sells a lot of homes. She was visibly shocked to see how low my rate was and how good my coverage was! Nobody else could compete! I highly recommend Compass Insurance Agency! read more

We've been with Compass for many years now. Casie Rustin is our agent. She has always found us the best rates and ensured we have the appropriate coverage for our home and auto policies, and that gives us peace of mind knowing we are protected. I've recommended Casie at Compass to family, friends and co-workers and all have been one hundred percent satisfied. read more

Overall good experience. Got to save some money on my car insurance and never felt pressured to make a decision (which is new for me when it comes to car insurance). I like the fact that Mark (the agent I spoke to) gave me an option on choosing which insurance company and policy I wanted to go with, while giving me his opinion on what he thought I needed. read more

Casie took my already good policies with another agent and rounded it out to get my home and auto with a single carrier, tweaked my coverage to get me more where I needed it (less if I didn't) and even saved me a couple bucks while she was at it. She knows her business well and I would highly recommended Compass through the Capable hands of Casie. read more

I am very pleased with the professionalism encountered in person or over the phone, especially with Casie Rustin. I have been experiencing health issues and because of her extraordinary customer service, I don't have to worry about my home or vehicles. I definitely send anyone with insurance needs, to Casie, and will continue to do so. read more

We called to shop our insurance and had wonderful service! Michelle was very professional and answered all my questions. Not only did we get the best rate and save over $100 a month, they continue to work and answer any questions along the way. I would recommend Compass Insurance to shop for anyone. They will not disappoint! read more

I am very happy with Compass Insurance Agency. My past experience dealing with Insurance Agencies has been a bit of a headache. Compass gave me great rates and made the process so easy. Jodi has always been super helpful! Anytime I need something, I shoot her an email and she is quick to take care of it! read more

We have been with Compass Insurance Agency for a couple years now, due mainly to the service we receive from Michelle. She found us the best rates, and is always available to give us quotes. She is prompt, skilled, and definitely a great agent to work with. Thanks Michelle and Compass! read more

I have had a pleasant experience with Wes Trimpe he also solved some of my insurance issues/ I had no tickets for 25 years/ never had a dui or mip and was on high risk for one accident and he got me back to a reasonable rate for insurance thanks again read more

I have been with compass insurance for many years now and what a great group of people . very helpful. casie my agent is very kind and helpful every time I call. Have to say she is awesome ... Such a great company would recommend them to everybody read more

I can honestly say that I enjoy the work that this insurance company gives out. I would recommend it to anyone. They are very knowledgable and very helpful. It was a great experience. I didn't feel like I was getting taken advantage of. 5 stars! read more

Jim Blaauw is a great agent and has saved us a lot of money on our policies. Compass has been wonderful to work with and always replies to any questions immediately. I would highly recommend giving Jim a chance to give you a quote! read more

I have had an amazing customer experience with compass. I had an issue with my roof, my rep explained the process to me, and we got a new roof very quickly. I recommend them to anyone looking for a hands on local touch for insurance. read more

Jim has been so great to work with! When I reached out to a number of companies for quotes, Jim promptly responded with much lower rates we were paying. We've also changed coverage and vehicles and he's made the switch over seemless. read more