My mom, my two young sons, and I had reserved a room for September 12th - 17th, 2011, and after staying at several hotels on our trip out to South Dakota, and having to pack, unpack, unload and reload our luggage, were very happy to check into our little home away from home for the week.
Upon checking into the hotel on September 12, 2011, the woman who checked us in said that there was a note that I had requested fresh bedding, and that all of the linens had been changed. Happy with the friendly welcome, we unloaded our luggage from our vehicle, and "move in" to our room. The room was clean and nicely decorated, and the pool area seemed nice.
We got up early the next morning to get ready and have breakfast before heading to Hill City for our 10am reservations on the 1880 Train. As I was getting ready, my mom knocked on the bathroom door, and told me that I wouldn't believe what she'd just found in her bed as she was making it. Very upset, she laid a yellow fingernail on the bathroom counter that appeared to have come from an elderly person! She was sick to her stomach to think that she'd slept in a bed with bedding with a dirty fingernail in it that didn't belong to her, me or my sons! While I finished getting ready, she put the fingernail in a tissue and went to the front desk. Fifteen to twenty minutes later, she came back to the room extremely upset wanting me to go back to the front desk with her because the lady she spoke to didn't believe that she'd actually found a fingernail in her bed!
We went back to the front desk where we spoke to the same lady my mom had spoken to a few minutes earlier, with the initials CMB who claimed to be the manager. I have NEVER been treated so rudely and with such crassness in my life, let alone by someone claiming to be the manager of a large hotel in a popular vacation destination! We were careful to very quietly and nicely explain what had happened, careful to keep our voices down and to stop discussing our problem when other hotel guest came to the desk. She stood there with her arms crossed the entire time not responding to us with more than a nod of her head from time to time until she had the audacity to tell us that not only did she NOT believe that we had found a fingernail in one of the beds, but then insinuating that we had PLANTED the fingernail there in order to get a free night's stay! How dare she! My mom and I are good, honest, Christian women who had both saved up and planned for this vacation for MONTHS! Neither of us like to complain and avoid confrontation at all costs, but we had EVER right to bring this to the hotel's attention! Silly as it felt at the time, my mom and I both held out or hands for her to see that neither of us had a broken nail nor did the yellowed fingernail look anything like ours. My mom asked her several times how the hotel intended to make things right, to which CMB responded that although she was the manager, she had personally changed the bedding herself the previous day, and that the hotel wasn't going to fall for our little scam! When I told her that we weren't saying that the bedding hadn't been changed, and that perhaps the housekeeper had broken a nail while changing the sheets or that maybe the nail got snagged to the sheets during laundering, she told me that none of that was possible, and then once again insinuated that WE put the fingernail there to get a free night.
My mom was crying by this time, and I was getting very angry not only at the accusations this lady was making and that my mom was upset, but by the complete and utter disrespectful and rude way that she was addressing us and handling this matter. When I asked her if there was another manager on duty, she just stared at me and wouldn't reply. I told her that what it came down to was that it WASN'T our fingernail that we found in the hotel's bed, and that was a problem, to which she replied, and I quote, "If you're finished now, I have things to do." I'd had it by this time, and announced that although we'd planned to stay for the next 4 nights, we'd be checking out immediately, and I'd be contacting corporate headquarters to tell them what had happened and how she was treating us. Her response, "That's fine." No apology, no asking if there was anything she could do to make us stay, nothing! Not ONCE during either my or my mom's conversation with this lady did she make ANY sort of an apology or ANY attempt to resolve the issue! Ridiculous! read more