Wow. Let me tell you something amazing. Here is my story…read more So I had the pleasure of meeting owner / operator Sheryl through some mutual friends. I was looking for a cake for a special occasion and I was pointed in the direction of Sweets by Sheryll. Sheryll was very personable, bubbly, intrigued and very inviting on what I was looking for. She was able to give me a few ideas and options that would best fit what I was exactly looking for. Sheryll, through the whole process was very in tune with letting me know the price, time of completion and time to pick up the cake. I was never left wondering when the masterpiece would be completed. It was a very smooth process. Now let's get to the cake. The cake was exactly, no no it was beyond what I was expecting. The cake was moist, tasteful bite after bite, sweet but not over powering and the final result of the exterior of the cake was epic!! The cake looked so real, that no one wanted to eat it, lol. Once the first cut happened and tasted, you couldn't fill the plates fast enough. The cake was for a work event. We definitely know who we will be going to for our next dessert/cake. Well done Sheryll! You definitely have the talent and skill to make any occasion a special one.

This cake was magnificent!! I had no idea what to order for a citrus-themed, tea party baby shower…read more After consulting with Sheryll, she came up with this wonderful lemon curd cake. The flavor was sweet, a bit tangy, moist, and looked beautiful. I am quite sure everyone at the event will be ordering from her for any occasion in the future.

This lovely place was kind enough to feed 13 hungry teachers today, and let me tell ya... I've…read morenever seen a group so silent while we were eating. Everyone was far too busy enjoying their food to talk! I don't usually choose ham, but I love pepper jelly, so I couldn't resist the ham and pepper jelly, grilled cheese, bacony delight. It was AMAZING. I had it on multigrain bread which was a great choice. This is a sandwich I'm going to crave, and I can't wait to be back in the area to check out some other items to go with this killer sandwich.

I'm not sure if my review posted. The chicken southwest wrap my husband ordered was phenomenal. The…read moreside salads were outstanding. My sandwich was a complete disaster. It was cold, not a melt although the cheese was melted. All I could taste was Dijon. The lemon berry cake was downright decadent! I cannot wait to return to get the wrap instead. Other than my sandwich, it was well worth the wait.

Amazing Brownie pops for our anniversary. My husband was not expecting to like them but said they…read morewere the best he ever had. She goes out of her way to make a great experience!

From the owner: We specialize in bringing smiles to our customers with our delicious sweet treats & exceptional…read morecustomer service.

Thank you Ms. Judy for a spectacular wedding cake ,such elegant design and delicious flavors our…read moreexpectations were met and we appreciated your work and effort to create such a memorable beautiful cake for our wedding day . Bless you always with sincere thanks the, Mendoza 's .

I thank Judy for adding the finishing touches to my son's memorable graduation party. With just a…read morebrief phone conversation and follow up text messages, Judy understood the concept (23 Jordan themed) and took off with her creativity. I sent an inspiration picture and when I tell you my mouth dropped to the floor when she sent me the finished product!! Completely blown away! The cake was definitely a highlight of the party. As if it couldn't get any better, the cake tasted just as good as it looked! Sooo many compliments. I would use Judy a thousand times again. Super smooth process from beginning to end. Thank you so much!!!

I had used this small bakery before... for my daughter's graduation in December . I called way to…read morelate and other bakeries I know would have turned me away... but no she fit me into her schedule.... just like this time. I just found out it was someone's birthday 2 days ago so I called Mrs Amelia again. she was so busy but again fit me in. I told her flavour and colours.... make it pretty... the flavour and moistness of these cakes are amazing. I would not email or reach out on face book ( maybe I should not say that...). I only say this because CALL and they will do anything they can to help you. she used to be an RN so she can read peoples voices and somehow their need for that perfect cake people will talk about months after eating. it's not a fancy place but her cakes if needed ARE! I saw pics of her work and the talent her and her husband turn out in these cakes is amazing.... so if your looking for a cake for a few or a 100 at a reasonable price.... I would say put this bakery in your contacts. thank you again for the perfect cake! I wish I could show pictures.... Idk how on yelp. So go to their website to have a look.... One last thing, since she was an RN if you're looking for a baker that knows allergy/ dietary needs regarding a cake.... This is the bakery you want. thank you T

I love any and all cake. My husband does not even like sweets. When we began the wedding planning…read moreprocess, we expected the cake to be icing on top of the event (no pun intended). Thanks to Amelia, however, both the process of selecting the cake and the end product became a highlight of our wedding: 1) Amelia's set up with different flavored cupcakes to try with various icings and fillings was brilliant. It was a favorite part of the planning stage, and helped land on a combo that we could not have come up with on our own. 2) A lot of wedding cakes are beautiful, but I rarely see guests get up to admire them. Amelia's talent and versatility re: design was such, however, that our cake ended up being a focal point during dinner, and was shared by so many different guests on social media after. Amelia was so wonderful working with us from a previous concept to tailor it to our venue, and it looked amazing. 3) Critically, the cake TASTED as amazing as it looked. It's normally a win to get a slice of wedding cake that isn't dried out. Our guests expressed to us that they took second slices offered with coffee, and, as a cake aficionado, I ate several more both after the wedding and for breakfast the next day. Even my husband who doesn't like sweets loved it. The only downside is that Amelia may have set the bar way too high, and he's not getting cake like that local to us any time soon. TLDR if you are getting married in the Jax area, or doing any event that can use a cake, I cannot recommend Cake Me to Paradise enough. Thank you so much Amelia from both of us!

Amazing shop! Not only do they have unique gifts, but food selection as well. From old alcohol…read morecandy to DIY beer bread, this place has plenty of interesting flavors. The bakery is my favorite part. They have a weekly flavor for cake & it's always amazing! Last week bourbon peach, this week chocolate Kahlúa!!!

To say that this is a "hidden gem" doesn't do this place justice. It's located next to Now and Then…read moreAntique Mall (another local gem) on College Drive in Orange Park. While Yum is a destination spot for baked goods and custom cakes, they also have a market that features a variety of treasures made by local vendors. Homemade bath and kitchen products are abundant, as well as jams and jellies, funny signage, clothing, and so much more. If you're in need of a creative and unique gift for any occasion, then Yum is the place to check out. Whether I've needed goodies for my days off or stocking up for a TV marathon night (Stranger Things 4 in one shot), YUM has always had me covered. I could sit here and tell you all of my favorite desserts, but then this review would turn into a novel. I will say that I leave there with at least two scrumptious cupcakes and several bars. Their 5 (or is it 6?) layer bar is outstanding and reminds me of the ones my Mom used to make for the holidays. It's like the one from the Eagle Condensed Milk can recipe, but so much better. If you see these in the dessert case, GET IT....or get 5, like me. They have a Facebook page, where they keep you up to date on upcoming sales and events, as they have loads of different products coming in from day to day. I love that everything is made from scratch and that they're supporting our thriving local community of artists. Yum a Southern Market is well worth the trip, whether you're in the neighborhood or from out of town. A big thank you to the owners and the staff for bringing us such a special place! One important thing to mention is that they are closed on Sundays and Mondays! Till next time, my fellow Yeeps, SUPPORT your local eats and businesses, and as always...SYOY!

I've ordered cupcakes a couple of times now and I will say that they are the most flavorful…read morecupcakes I've ever had. The chocolate cupcake with ganache I had was perfection. Then I tried a daiquiri coconut cake that a friend recommended and it is by far my new favorite! I also had a vanilla buttercream with lemon curd that was great. It wasn't the overly lemony taste that you might expect. On another occasion I ordered a flan for one of my kids' parties. I'm not a flan person because every flan I've ever had had an eggy taste with a rubbery type consistency. Just not my thing. I tried their flan and I've completely changed my mind. I didn't realize there was good and bad flan, lol. So five stars from me, and a loyal customer for all my future orders. You can't beat the flavor.

Great custom cakes and sweet treats!! Always excellent customer service and very fair pricing for…read morethe work involved. Every cake we have ever ordered was amazing and so delicious. A must call for cakes and sweets