Been going to these guys recently to buy silver bullion. Glad this place is around. Cool staff, easy in and out transactions and no BS. Def recommend stopping by if your a silver stacker in Westchester. read more

This is a "Grab and Melt" shop. They'll take your precious heirloom and just burn it. This is what they're known for, so they "might" give you a slightly better offer than the local jeweler for a melt, but it depends on their mood at the moment - They might low ball you too if they're having a bad day or month. It's one of those shops I'll check in with before I go to Cos Cobb, who ALWAYS outbids them and they're way way way friendlier than the unpleasant people at Coin Exchange. Do your homework. There are better places than this. read more

Rude and obnoxious was the response I received asking a few questions, they were so busy, they couldn't answer a few dumb questions.!? I took my business elsewhere. read more

Quick and professional. Sold some gold here and was satisfied. Percentage of spot not as competitive as others I've been to in NYC or Connecticut read more

With silver prices soaring, my wife and I just had to bring in the sterling silver set her mom bought her when she was 18. In 1965. Of course we went to other highly-rated shops in the area, but Coin Exchange offered TEN PER CENT MORE than the other dealers. In the end, we didn't sell the silver: the sentimental value outweighs...literally...the money we could get for it. But if silver hits a THOUSAND DOLLARS an ounce (maybe next month?) we'll be back (Sentimentality has its limits) read more

Very dishonest people. I was offered $615 for a 10k gold class ring 20g. I knew it was worth more. I drove 20 minutes to Cos Cobb, CT and sold the ring of $820. A difference of $205 for 40 minutes of my time a a little gas. Well worth it. Do NOT do business with the Coin Exchange if you want honest pricing. read more

Everything people have posted about this place is true! Top notch! I went in today with a bunch of jewelry that I just never wear. I worked with Mike who was friendly & honest. I was expecting to just get price estimates but was thrilled when he offered to buy around 2/3 of what I brought for a great price! Now I've got room in my jewelry box again and an envelope of cash in my bag yay!!! Thx Mike! Will definitely be back read more

I have dealt with this business for over a year. They have proven to be fair, accurate and efficient. Scott and Mike know their market and can quickly evaluate unusual items. Some items I felt were valuable really were not and some items I felt were of little value were of much more worth than my estimate. This business, in my opinion, is honest and reliable. read more

A very honest and respectable place to have your gold , coins , jewelry appraised , purchased and sold , etc. I made a quick visit into a hour visit as I had the kind gentleman look at my old coins and the total value is not enough to purchase the los Angeles rams and lakers but I was mildly surprised they were worth anything .The coin exchange gentleman told me a little history on my coins and recommended to hold on to them as the value may rise over time . No pressure to buy , no pressure to sell , and his honestly was good enough for me to purchase a watch and gold coin for a little future investment project . I would highly recommend coin exchange to buy and sell your bling , coins , etc. Will be back to have a few other gathering dust trinkets in the near future . read more

Went in to buy junk silver the guy was grumpy not helpful at all . Got vibe that if you know anything they don't want to deal with you . How you think they afford that fancy building. read more

Coin Exchange had good reviews so I called. The gentlemen Scott who I spoke with on the phone seemed like someone you would want to work with so I went to the shop. I did not know the precious value of all of the coins I brought to him but I must say my husband and I felt confident we were not being ripped off. He was professional and patient. They also purchase jewelry ---- that may be my next task to undertake. Upon arrival I learned that Scott Finkel is one of the partners at the shop. They made it easy with two very heavy boxes of coins......they have a cart and a ramp! Philomena read more

I wanted to sell some gold items. The transaction was very professional, fair and quick.

A really great experience. The staff is professional and knowledgeable. Everything is very straight forward and no reason to question their quotes. I found my whole transaction to be just what I was looking for and would continue to do business with them in the near future. read more

Jason was very nice , highly knowledgeable and gave great pricing . Highly recommended!

Amazing place with a great friendly staff! they really gave me the best prices around to sell my silver and gold to them! They also have a great selection of coins I will definitely be returning asap!!!! read more

If you are looking to exchange / sell coins in the Westchester Area, this business provides a fair quote. If you are looking to sell any type of jewelry, I highly recommend that you do your homework first. Although, I wasn't ready to part with a couple pieces , the quote given by Coin Exchange was significantly less than what I was quoted ( 82 % less ) by a gemologist a few weeks later. I recognize that they are a business and in most cases , people need to immediately dispose of items, but if you are not in a rush to sell , please do some research. Finally, the staff is friendly and helpful. read more

This is by FAR the BEST place I have ever done business at. They pay more than ANY other place I have ever been to. pleasure doing business with them every time I've been there read more

Honest and thoroughly reliable. Great selection of both graded coins and junk silver alike. Recommended! read more

Michael was so easy to work with. He was extremely knowledgeable, efficient and courteous.

Easy to work with, very professional and excellnt prices paid. Highly recommend this establishment.

Wonderful guys at Coin Exchange. Looked at my collection, explained why certain coins had a greater value and provided me with a fair market price. Educated me at the same time. Highly recommended. read more

Worst customer service. Felt like I was an impostor trying to sell counterfeit coins and jewelry. No greeting or even a smile.

A good experience all around jason was knowledgeable and honest friendly , not pushy would definitely recommend read more

Had some old silver coins to offload and these guys were great, best price to be gotten. Friendly and courteous. thanks so much, will definitely return!! read more

I went to the Coin Exchange based on the great reviews to sell some jewelry I no longer used. Scott was very professional and made me an offer. I left without selling my jewelry to see if I could get a better offer elsewhere. I went to my jewelry store where I thought I would get a fair if not better offer. Not only did this not happen there, but also they were trying to tell my my 18k pieces were not 18k and I knew they were. I went to a third gold buyer, and there too, I was not given the pricing that I was given at the Coin Exchange, however they did verify my 18k gold once again. When I went back to the Coin Exchange, although Scott was not there, Mike helped me, verified my jewelry again by testing it in their cool machine. He honored Scott's pricing, and throughout the process was extremely professional and amicable. I left there knowing that I received the best available pricing, and enjoyed the seamless process. I would highly recommend this store to anyone looking to be treated with respect and professionalism while also being offered the best pricing available for your precious pieces. read more

I came in to buy some silver coins. The transaction was fairly quick and easy. The prices were below what I had seen online by a couple of dollars which was nice. read more

The store I used in the past was closed for the holidays. I decided to try "Coin Exchange". I called ahead to see if appointments were necessary which they are not. I asked a few questions and was delighted to hear they take gold, silver and coins. One stop exchange which I loved. Jason who assisted me was warm, professional and very knowledgeable. He gave me the value information of my merchandise without any pressure to sell. I am very pleased with my visit and highly recommend Coin Exchange. read more

I stopped by today to scrap some of moms gold...with Mom in tow. Mike was professional, patient, thorough, friendly and gave me/Mom a very fair scrap price. These guys know their trade. Very impressive. This was my second time in (the first time I dealt with Scott the owner). Both experiences were overwhelmingly positive. They use a thermal gun for the gold so you're not waiting around while they're splashing acid. Best scrap prices in town but they're also expert in fine estate/antique jewelry and coins. Highly recommended. Great experience. Thank you. read more

Great experience. I visited Coin Exchange to sell some junk silver change. Mike helped me and was very patient and answered every question I asked. Very pleasant to do business with and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for coin experts. read more

Had no idea what to expect when I walked into this place. But, I was pleasantly surprised. The person that I worked with explained everything, why certain coins had more value that others, and gave me a full quote for everything with any sort of pressure. I would recommend this place to anyone looking to sell coins! read more

BIG CROOKS, they over charge you for thier items and really under appraise what you have to sell. BIG CROOKS!!

I had a great experience with the staff of Coin Exchange. I came into the store to sell some scrap gold after visiting a few other local shops. They gave me a much better price than anyone else in the area, and they were very nice and easy to deal with. I will definitely be back in the future! read more

Had a very nice experience working with Mike! Had two watches that were left to me and he took his time evaluating both. Came back to me with a fair offer and the transaction was smooth. Mike was a pleasure to work with. read more

Excellent service, I got a quote over the phone that was reasonable and once I went to the store I was given a more than fair price. No hassle or haggling. Difficult to find honesty in this field. They were outstanding... Would definitely recommend. read more

This was my first time and the service was excellent. I live out of town and didn't want to take the items back home with me. Everyone was friendly and I received a fair value for the the silver items I was selling. Definitely will be back the next time I am in town. read more

I visited this store a few weeks ago to find out if my old coins were worth anything. I was greeted by a friendly guy that took his time explaining to me what he buys and about the store. I was impressed by their knowledge and also their patience. They bought some old stamps and most other stamp dealers wouldn't even take them from me. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking to get rid of their stuff. read more

I will never order from Coin Exchange again, I never received my item that they charged me for, and they refuse to refund my money. They blame it on the postal carrier ( tracking indicated delivered) but it did not come to my address, I have no idea where the item went, now I am out 59.00, never again... read more

The short version: Easy to deal with, best prices polite, and efficient -- I couldn't recommend Coin Exchange enough. I had a small gold bar that I wanted to sell but had no idea how to go about it. I'm in Westchester, so I checked with some local jewelers, called up a few places in the city, and then tried Coin Exchange. They offered the best price with the most fair rate, by far. They explained the process and voiila, in and out in minutes (granted, this is not the most complicated of exchanges, but I didn't know that). Bottom line: use Coin Exchange, you'll be happy you did. read more

Scott was fabulous!! He was friendly and knowledgeable. I had taken my 22k gold to sell at another jewelry and they told me my gold was only 18k so I left the store and went to the Coin Exchange. Scott placed my items into a high tech device and within a few seconds let me know my gold was 22K as I knew. He offered me a more than fair price for the gold. I highly recommend Scott and will be back very soon!! read more

I have done business here for about 8 years, buying and selling. Very polite, and honest; usually get a better price than APMEX or Provident metals, two of the largest online dealers. I find the staff there to be knowledgeable and not pushy. I usually make purchases from here about 10-15 times a year, and sell or trade with them 1-2 times a year read more