This is a long 3-star review with some good and some bad. Note this review is intended only to cover the gym and pool areas, although they have other services such as day care, classes, etc. that I haven't and will probably never use.
I used to be a member at NYSC and recently felt the monthly fee wasn't worth the service (~$75/month), so I started looking into alternate, more-affordable gym solutions. Lo and behold, the Central Queens Y is equidistant to the NYSC from where I live and the fee is only ~$45/month per couple! This would be a $105 savings each month total between me and my better half, so after touring the place we decided to give it a try.
I've been a member of CQY for almost 8 weeks and have used the gym and pool facilities on average 3-4 times per week. Here are my collective thoughts.
Pros:
- inexpensive
- has a pool
- (very) basic gym equipment available
- parking lot for members
- most of the staff is very friendly and engaging, something you don't typically encounter at big box gyms, but maybe because this is more of a family/community atmosphere more than a gym
- sean at the pool is incredibly friendly, vicky at the pool is a good instructor
- they have a parking lot a block away
Neutral:
- this place shares a lot of jewish values and is closed at 4-ish on Friday afternoons and closed all day Saturdays
- has other classes and classrooms, but I haven't tried any of them
- the basketball court has open gym times, but i most likely won't play because it has a rubber floor which i dislike and always seems dusty, gets pretty crowded, and is relatively small. it seems like it's built more for grade schoolers than adults. but i'm glad to know there's a place where i can shoot around.
Cons:
There are two major cons here: one regarding bathroom/facility cleaning, and the other with signage/instructions for new members. Here's my full list:
- there is no towel service
- the body shop (aka weight room) is serviceable at best. while they have some new cardio equipment, it's a very small room with machines laid out one on top of the other. if you go during the day, there are a lot of seniors working out. the room feels so small that if there are more than 6 people working out at the same time, you'll feel like you're working out on top of one another, which can feel uncomfortable.
- the mens' bathroom looks relatively clean but honestly smells like they barely clean it. i loathe entering the facility because sometimes it just smells like a combination of mold and dirty feet/pits/ass. only once in the last two months have i walked in and it smelled like they actually mopped the floor with any sort of cleaning material. i have actually wondered how often they clean this room as i've NEVER seen anyone cleaning any part of the locker room
- in addition to the above, i once went on a monday morning (10am) and found no toilet paper in the bathroom stall. this is more evidence that they don't pay close enough attention to the locker room. even the urinals looks like they are barely cleaned, or cleaned sloppily.
- it seems they heavily rely on their regulars, and assume that everyone knows what's going on. for new members (me), this can be maddening. considering they have a schedule for each area that seems to change every hour which can be difficult to follow (men only, women only, co-ed, closed for classes, adult only, etc.). and you'd think they'd have the schedule posted somewhere, but the only place i've found it is online (not helpful when you're actually there and don't get great service).
- no one tells you some of the nuances of the place, like giving your ID to the person at the desk downstairs, and then they hawk you/yell at you when you don't give it to them; how was i supposed to know? nobody informed me...
- or the time i tried to enter at 7:30pm via the main doors and they were locked and i didn't know what was going on; a woman opened the door for me looking at me like I was crazy for not knowing i needed to use the back entrance after 7pm. Again, how was I supposed to know if no one told me or there aren't simple signs informing me to use the back?
Summary:
All in all, this is a decent Y. And again, the staff are mostly friendly. But beware: you do get what you pay for and as long as you're comfortable with their ever-changing schedule, nuanced rules, and not-so-clean facilities, this could be a good, affordable location for you to get in your workout. read more