Cute little restaurant with lots of seats. We were in the…read morelocation to drop off our boy at college and this little town loves their pizza. There were so many pizza joints so we had to try a couple. This spot was very clean, friendly and fairly quick. After we ordered we saw a sign hidden away pointing out specials which was a little disappointing since we were not told about the specials while we were ordering. Pizzas and cheese bread had a great taste. Good, crispy crust and a flavorful pizza sauce.

We were driving through, and I was thrilled to find a pizza place that had gluten free crust! Crust…read morewas crispy and it was loaded with toppings. Great service and the restaurant was very clean. We were also impressed with the staff's immediate consideration to accommodate our son's, with a disability, needs and making him feel comfortable without us even needing to ask. Love that!!

I definitely recommend this pizza. We thought it was very tasty - we got the Hawaiian, hand tossed,…read moreand it was delicious. They even have dairy free cheese for the dairy allergies. The only reason I had to take a star is that we cannot recommend dining in and want to give that heads up to fellow travelers. We were stopping through town on our way to see family and thought it would be easier to dine in with our toddler than taking it back to our air b n b. It was small but there were a handful of tables set up for dining in so we thought it would work ok. But when we came in and asked about dining in we were given a bugged-eyed look and they echoed, "dine in?!" But they said sure and pick a seat. It takes a bit to make me uncomfortable and doubt a person but this was not welcoming. We sat down and when our 2 year old wanted our menu, we asked for a second one and got an attitude from the same person again. At that point I threw in the towel. I can't enjoy my meal with someone questioning every single thing we did or said, especially with an unpredictable toddler. So we put in our order and left. My husband had to go back to get it. So just a fair warning to other families to be prepared for a possibly awkward dine-in experience. They also do not have high chairs - they do have booster seats but they do not buckle down. We for sure would order here again but would plan to carry-out only.

The pizza is amazing. My husband prefers xtra thin crust but once he tried the square pizza he…read moresold. The staff is friendly and the tables clean. Be sure you get the butter crust

This is my favorite restaurant in the region. Don't miss the steak. It's really fantastic…read more Also, it's just a friendly and comfortable place that everyone loves. I almost always get the very robust Cobb salad. Lots of people love the fried chicken and the pizza, but there's really something for everyone on the menu. Don't miss cheese curds dipped in ranch dressing-- Iowa classic!

Four of came here for lunch. We came early which was good because it filled up quickly. And had one…read morevery large party. But service did not suffer. I got a burger and it was good and came as I ordered it.

Fast efficient staff; good smells throughout the dining area. Duchess Pizza was easily shared…read morebetween two along with a sizable side salad.

Pizza is fantastic. Onion rings are small for $8.50 and pretty generic. Will be back for pizza.read more

Everyone is very friendly, polite, always there to greet everyone walking in the doorread more

Ok casey's is the best pizza in town! Watch for the deals…read moreand now they have an app with deals that are way lower priced at times Now on to the pizza! Hamburger onion is always a win for me! Yea they do load it up as well! Nice bake on the crust. I call in and pick it up. 20 to 30 min on time. Easy to get in to this location. Small place but good pizza!

I love Pagliai's pizza. The beef, mushroom, and red onion pizza is my favorite and their homemade…read moreliquid gold ranch is exceptional. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone passing through Grinnell, Iowa.

We'd heard of this pizza spot since we arrived to Grinnell, so naturally we had to try it…read more Immediately greeted as we walked in the door and loved that we could see all the chefs in the kitchen right then and there. It was busy but not so much that we didn't get sat right away. Our server was also busy so someone else took our drink order - and then gave us menus. We ended up ordering the meatballs, a salad, and a classic pie, and walked out also with a cool vintage looking Pagliai's tee! The meatballs were large, came with two, and really flavorful. The sauce was classic tomato but not basic, you could taste the aromatics and that was so good. Basic salad but really delicious runny ranch to go with it, which I loved. I dipped the crust from my pizza in it and it was just so good! For the pie we split it in half - half with meats and the other half with special. The crust was thin and also seasoned nicely and couldn't say enough about how delicious the cheese was. It was so gooey and thick - it made the pizza so incredibly good. Besides our server taking us on due to the prior one being too busy, the vibes inside were chill and casual, music was good and the atmosphere was pleasant. Everyone behind the pizza counter had smiles and acknowledged you. Was a real delight. Everywhere in Grinnell folks rave about Pagliai's and we understand why. We'll definitely have to come back!

Order thru the app and they say 30 minutes, I show up and I have to wait 20 min or longer…read more Terrible service!!!!!

Terrible service. Waited over a hour to pick up a pizza that was cold when we picked it up. Ignore…read morethe time on your app. It's pointless. And they are rude on top of it. Staff is terrible.

Little hometown hero business has to be the best pizza in Iowa. They're always so quick to refill…read moreyour drinks and it's not a bad price for the family.

Service was super friendly. Loved the welcoming atmosphere too. Pizza was great. Crust was crispy…read moreon the bottom which we love. Good selection of beers on tap. Definitely going back. Worth the drive from Ankeny!

Great calzones, pizza, and spaghetti. Very nice people in good customer service. The restaurant is…read moreclean and casual.

Well to start the pizza is still amazing. But my gripe is lazy people. First off the waitress…read morenamed Jenny was the best ever. She was friendly and fast and knew her job well. Then the other 3 was lazy. One came in while we was there her name is Nikki. All she did was talk talk and talk some more. OK if she was to man the register then do it but when not busy then clean something. The front windows for instance they need cleaned. Then the red head came in she wore a pink shirts saying Nanas Army. She started eating as soonas she got there and was still eating when we left. No work just eating. Then one other was there and all she was doing was talking and talking . Goodness there are lots of things to keep busy with. So suggestion tell the lazy people get to work and shut your traps . .. Jenny was doing all the work ....