Cancel
Open app
Search
Sign Up
Log In
Nearby
Bookmarks
Start a Project
Add a Business on Yelp
It's easier on the Yelp app
Continue
Stay on browser
Add Review
Call
Directions
Website
More like Casey's
Dinner
Breakfast
Burgers
Pizza Delivery
Start your review...
Get app
14 years ago
Everything you need, courteous employees and great pizza
101 N Lake St
Lake Mills, IA 50450
(641) 450-2085
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.caseys.com
Full menu
Hours
What time does Casey's open?
Casey's opens at 4:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
What time does Casey's close?
Casey's closes at 11:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
Mon-Sun 4:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Does Casey's take credit cards?
Yes, Casey's takes credit cards.
Does Casey's have catering options?
No, Casey's does not have catering options.
Does Casey's serve alcohol?
Yes, Casey's serves alcohol.
Does Casey's have outdoor seating?
No, Casey's does not have outdoor seating options.
Does Casey's have parking?
Yes, Casey's has parking options.
Does Casey's have free WiFi?
Yes, Casey's has free WiFi.
Get access to customer & competitor insights.
Chicken and Fish are very good. Only thing missing is a side dish along with the fries. I would…read moresuggest a coleslaw of some kind and a slice of marbled rye... that's a fish fry! I just don't like a meal without some sort of veggie included.
I absolutely LOVE this place. I actually created this yelp account just so I could give them a…read moregreat review. I've only ever done the buffet but it is my favorite place to go for supper. The pizza & chicken are awesome! They have real mashed potatoes, crispy deep fried fish on fridays & a taco bar with real taco meat & not that nasty meat paste you find at most buffets that offer tacos. They also have chicken nuggets & french fries on the buffet which to my suprise both look & taste alot like Mcdonalds. They have a cherry & blue raspberry slushie machine, an ice cream machine & TVs at every table. The staff is SUPER friendly & the resturant is always very clean. Like I said, I... LOVE... THIS... PLACE!!!
Pizza Ranch's buffet offers a variety of pizzas. If you don't see your favorite, you can request it and they'll make it for you!
See all
Crispy Ranch Chicken is offered on the buffet and can be ordered for takeout or delivery.
I've come here once or twice a week for the past six months. The place is fine, but the checkout…read moreperson seems to always change. The last time I was there, someone wore a politically dividing shirt. Not just a political shirt, but one intended to cause division. I have never and would never wear a shirt like this to a job. It's unprofessional because it reflects on the management themselves. There are two or three other gas stations in town. I can get my gas and pizza elsewhere and I intend to. Leave your political shirts at home or in your free time. Never wear one as an employee.
Probably some of The Best Fried Chicken in The Area, and the sides are absolutely delicious, from…read morepizza to Sandwiches, Everything from here is top Notch, the Employees here are very helpful and Nice, This is a definite must try, have never had a bad experience here ever!!
Terrible experience, waited for an hour for food. Then we left and the waitress asked for the…read moremoney to pay for our sodas... Will not be back
We stopped in at noon today--09/3/20--to get sandwiches for lunch while driving back home...We are…read morelocal. My husband walked in and ordered a steak sandwich. The older woman taking his order said, in a less than professional voice and snotty attitude, "well, what do you want it on, my hand?" Excuse me, is that the way to treat your customers?? She needs to be repremanded. We sincerely hope the manager reads this post.
on our way to the restaurant we saw a giant (9-ish ft?) snake in a yard next to an apartment…read morebuilding which was so unique for this town and the whole family enjoyed! the food is always amazing and if an employee makes a mistake they willingly change/make you a new sandwich no hassle!! love how there is always good music playing, and the temperature is always accordingly set which is super nice if it is so hot and you would like to get a sub and cool off! we go to subway so much and have never been let down!!
BEST of Lake Mills, Iowa Restaurants near Casey's
Restaurants in Lake Mills, IA
Donuts in Lake Mills, IA
Dinner in Lake Mills, IA
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich in Lake Mills, IA
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Lake Mills, IA
Pizza Specials in Lake Mills, IA
Breakfast in Lake Mills, IA
Restaurants Open Now in Lake Mills, IA
Delivery in Lake Mills, IA
Breakfast Burrito in Lake Mills, IA
24 Hour Restaurant in Lake Mills, IA
Takeout in Lake Mills, IA
Ice Cream in Lake Mills, IA
Pizza Delivery in Lake Mills, IA
Lunch in Lake Mills, IA
Burgers in Lake Mills, IA
Breakfast & Brunch in Lake Mills, IA
Wraps in Lake Mills, IA
Restaurants Open Late in Lake Mills, IA
Pizza Takeout in Lake Mills, IA
Barbeque in Lake Mills, IA
Sandwiches in Lake Mills, IA
Thin Crust Pizza in Lake Mills, IA
Pizza and Wings in Lake Mills, IA
Bars
Best Pasta Restaurants to Try in Lake Mills, Iowa
Best Rooftop Restaurant Experiences in Lake Mills, Iowa
Best Smoothie Spots and Cafes in Lake Mills, Iowa
Best Wood Fired Pizza Available in Lake Mills, Iowa
Browse Italian Restaurants With Great Reviews in Lake Mills, Iowa
Crispy French Fries Favorites in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover Authentic Italian in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover Coffee & Tea Options in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover Hip New Restaurants to Try in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover Monday Night Specials in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover New American in Lake Mills, Iowa for Great Dining
Discover Popular Sports Bars in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover the Best Boba Drinks in Lake Mills, Iowa
Discover the Best Breweries in Lake Mills, Iowa Today
Enjoy Authentic Mexican Cuisine in Lake Mills, Iowa
Enjoy Delicious Food Trucks All Over Lake Mills, Iowa
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Lake Mills, Iowa
Explore Late Night Food Choices in Lake Mills, Iowa
Explore Pizza Restaurants Near Lake Mills, Iowa
Explore Top Breakfast Restaurants in Lake Mills, Iowa
Explore Top Buffet Options in Lake Mills, Iowa
Explore the Best Food Options in Lake Mills, Iowa
Find Popular Pubs to Visit in Lake Mills, Iowa
Find the Best Caesar Salad in Lake Mills, Iowa
Find the Best Cafes in Lake Mills, Iowa for Every Taste
Great Diners to Visit in Lake Mills, Iowa
Have Fun Bowling in Lake Mills, Iowa
Highly Rated Steakhouses Around Lake Mills, Iowa
Order the Best Deep Dish Pizza in Lake Mills, Iowa
Popular Things to Do in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top Breakfast Sandwich Places in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top Chicken Sandwich Spots in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top Gluten Free Pizza Spots in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top Rated Seafood Dishes in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top Restaurants With Private Party Rooms in Lake Mills, Iowa
Top-Rated Spaghetti Dishes to Try in Lake Mills, Iowa
Try Pizza by the Slice Near Lake Mills, Iowa
Try the Best Banh Mi Sandwiches in Lake Mills, Iowa
Visit Popular Coffee Shops in Lake Mills, Iowa
Where to Get Delicious Pancakes in Lake Mills, Iowa
Bakeries near Casey's
Juice Bars & Smoothies near Casey's
Mothers Day Brunch near Casey's
Things to do in Lake Mills
Casey's General Store
Articles by date
This place was right next to our hotel that we were staying at while our Winnebago is being…read morerepaired. Many of the restaurants here in town are closed on Mondays, so we were glad there was a spot open and this place had pretty good reviews. We would've popped for the pizza because it looked amazing, but neither of us can eat such thick crust pizza anymore and not regret it so we went for the Mexican options My husband ordered the super chicken burrito, which basically has two big scoops of chicken and fillings and he said it was very good I just went for a small taco salad with chicken to keep it late tonight. For a small taco salad, there was a lot of food in that bowl. I think most of the town was here tonight ordering up pizza, lol so if you can eat pizza, I would go for that The bill was very reasonable at $17 total before tip. Very kind servers - pinball machine and really interesting decor It's worth a stop if you're coming thru here.
Stopped in with wife for something to eat and left very happy. We had soft and hard shell tacos…read moreplus some soft drinks. Very good and for a very reasonable price. Restaurant was spotless and the presumed owner was very nice. It is a fun environment and I definitely see a great place to hang out with friends.
Stopped here while road tripping, and the pizza was delicious! We got the truffle fries as well…read morebut thought they would be fries and not roasted potatoes but I think we just misread the menu. They have a good happy hour selection, and our waitress was amazing!
"Cento Woodfired Pizza in New Richmond is a gem! Cozy…read moreatmosphere, friendly staff, and absolutely delicious pizza with that perfect wood-fired flavor. The pepperoni was spot-on and the crust had just the right balance of crisp and chew. I'd definitely come back - but I'm from AZ .
For a truck stop this place is pretty cool! A good size food court with three different options to…read morechoose from and they can go across the way to the SKOL Tavern. We didn't get a chance to try that up, but it looks pretty dang cool! The staff are friendly and keep the place clean. Not bad.
Got the #4 turkey provolone and the chipotle chicken cheese, both giants. Really enjoyed these to…read morego. Restaurant was clean. Staff was friendly, no problems.
We made a quick lunch stop at this Jersey Mike's location during a recent road trip. It was…read moreconveniently located right off of I-90, so the family pointed it out right away. Our stop was on a Saturday mid-afternoon. The store was clean and the workers were friendly. The order taker / bread cutter / meat slicer was friendly and engaging. He got us started on the right foot. Then the next employee, putting the rest of the sandwich together, took this visit downhill for us. She, despite asking us each what ingredients we wanted / didn't want, managed to mess up several of our sandwiches. For example - I ask for "easy mayo" on my sandwich. Later i was wiping off gobs of mayo that were oozing from my sandwich. One of my daughters always gets a ham & cheese, plain with just pickles and oil. She even said, "no vinegar, please." The girl still drenched her sandwich in oil and vinegar. Another member of my group asks for easy vinegar...boom, soaked in vinegar! For the most part, we just rolled with the sandwich errors. The "easy vinegar" person tried their sandwich but later elected to go back for a remake. I love Jersey Mike's, but in today's world with everything being so expensive, you've got to make sure that the customer is getting what they ask for. With 5 people in our group and only 1 or 2 getting what they asked for, the score for this location takes a hit. Not bad...good location, clean store, friendly employees. Also, not good with the lack of paying attention by the sandwich maker. Maybe if I'm ever passing through Albert Lea, MN again, I'll give this place another shot!?
1910 Fresh has been a go-to place for lunch when we're out and about in Albert Lea. We usually get…read moreeither the fish or shrimp tacos. Neither are on the menu anymore. There is a vegetarian menu on the far right side of the board, but it's very bean and rice heavy. Ugh! They've lost a couple of regulars with that me up change. And, because we're usually with a couple others when out and about, they've lost them too. Guess it'll be the King, Taco King, from now on.
Don't let the exterior scare you away as this place makes everything from scratch. It is located…read moreright by a gas station but there is ample seating inside. They have an extensive menu of tacos, enchiladas, etc. all of our food was good and you can order ahead. We would go back.
I went here and I ended up eating with a roach on my seat. The food was good besides the unwanted…read morevisitor.
Food & service is amazing. The restaurant is brightly painted with beautiful pictures and a nice…read morebig open room.
Best Mexican place in Albert Lea best food best service . All of my food and service was on pointread more
Great service tasty food served hot with a pleasant plate view. Reasonable prices and nice decor.read more
Great service & good food. I love their double patty melt, deep fried skinned fries, fried okra &…read morethe funnel fries.
My step dad was very excited to go here, specifically just for their whiting fish. I saw that mac…read moreand cheese was on the menu, so I thought it would be a safe bet. Wait time wasn't long for the food, maybe 10 min. My Mac looked pretty, but was some of the less good Mac I've had. The noodles were undercooked, chicken was overcooked. Not very good portions. I wasn't too impressed with my mac at all. Would not get again. My mom hated the soup, it was way too thick, was more of a chowder type base. She only took a few bites of it. My step dad loved his sandwich though.
Great food great service never one problem always at the top of there game when anyone walks…read morein........
Qdoba is basically Pancheros or Chipotle only with an unpronounceable name. Is the Q silent? Is the…read mored pronounced like a u? Is it like Worcestershire sauce and the name is pronounced completely differently from how any reasonably intelligent person would expect? Truly, a mystery for the ages. As a business traveler, eating healthy on the road can be challenging. A burrito here isn't the healthiest thing, but by comparison to the Pizza Ranch directly behind this place, it's like gobbling Dexatrim. If you have never been to any of these types of places, it follows the "point and shuffle" format where you move along a cafeteria style ingredient bar and point at everything you want in your burrito or other dish. Service is quite fast, as the server needs only to slop a spoonful of each ingredient on your tortilla or into a dish. I saved the best for last: the amenities! This place has electrical outlets! Glorious 120 volt AC electricity! As a professional on the road for work, this is a luxury that I rarely get to enjoy when dining and working. My laptop has one of the most power hungry GPUs known to mankind: the ravenous RTX 5000, which eats battery life like Pac-Man eats dots. When it's time to get some work done after eating, having electrical power right at my table makes my life less stressful. I can focus on my work and not be stressed out about how long my battery will last. This place is awesome.
they have employees who don't pay attention snd are very unclean, I told them I want it steak and…read moresurely enough once it was delivered it was pieces of just chicken fat barely done