I read an article online that many Okies consider Casey's to be the best pizza in the state. So we were excited to try it since there are none in our neck of the woods. Let me tell you, I don't know what they been smokin'. Because I disliked everything about it. Flavor reminded me of frozen grocery store pizza meets a cheap local pizza with processed ingredients.
We had fresh slices of pepperoni just out of the oven. It was super greasy on top, pepperoni was bland, in fact all ingredients tasted low quality and lacked flavor. Slice was thin, cheese thin, crust very chewy and also, thin. Not soft like classic style, not crispy like modern or dyi, somewhere in between. Just disappointing. My five dollar joint up the road is better. Yet a 12" pepperoni here is $11. Go anywhere else.
...Though for a fill-up or drink, this gas station and convenience store feel new-ish and clean. read more