Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 191 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    baked - Pizza

    baked

    4.7(154 reviews)
    10.2 mi
    $

    This was flagged as one of the best pizza places in all of Illinois so it's been on my to try list…read morefor a while. Located on Seminary Street, cute shops surround and on street parking available. Unassuming from the outside and purely historic, refurbished, recycled everything inside. Jazz and classic rock was playing on a record player. Staff was lovely and helpful with questions. Order at the counter and take a seat. Glasses are chilled, no ice. Canned sodas, water, alcoholic beverages available. Pizza has 4 sizes, specials and make your own. Sandwiches, salads. I chose the goat cheese and herb pizza and it was sooooo good. Chewy yet crunchy, the crust is perfection. Takes 20-30 minutes when not just. Worth the wait. Will definitely come back when we are in the area.

    I believe that my search for the BEST PIZZA in the world (outside of Italy) has ended…read more "BAKED PIZZA" in Galesburg, Illinois (you read correctly, ILLINOIS!) serves an unbelievable pie. I had a five hour layover between Amtrak journeys (Southwest Chief and California Zephyr) so wanted to have best possible nosh in this Abraham-Lincoln-Slept-Here town within walking distance from the train depot. Thanks to Google Maps, Baked Pizza was top on the list. Sadly, they are closed on Sundays - my scheduled stop in Galesburg. So, I went to another local pizza place. That was an unfortunate disappointment. But, say hallelujah!, my return trip was on a Wednesday, so Baked Pizza was my highest priority. And color me grateful to Google Maps! Fortunately, I found this little hole-in-the-wall without difficulty. I entered into a brick sided wonderland. It must have been a white rabbit that led me there. I could not believe my otherworldly experience. I was greeted by the most cordial of greeter, Estefania. She was ever so patient and accommodating with my hearing disability. Baked Pizza was off to a great start! I took my time deciding which of the Lewis Carroll's fantasy pizzas to choose while I sipped their Two Hearted IPA. The Herbs and Goat Cheese was the winner. And what a winner it is! Dominated by basil, the herbs are fresh and wonderful. The mozzarella are geniusly complimented by the gentle goat cheese. And the herbs! Youd think that you were in Provence! Finally, and not at all leastly, the garlic oil is a finishing touch without equal. I admit that I dismissed the garlic oil as an advertising gimmick. Nay, I say! This seemingly add-on is essential. It is a must for the definive crispy crust! IMO, there is no equal. So, the next time you're within 500 mile if Galesburg Illinois, try Baked Pizza. You won't be sorry.

    Photos
    baked
    baked - There aren't words good enough to describe the flavors. Ty so much Baked! What took me so long to try you???

    There aren't words good enough to describe the flavors. Ty so much Baked! What took me so long to try you???

    baked - A delicious collection of albums....played during dinner.

    See all

    A delicious collection of albums....played during dinner.

    Alfano's Pizza - Pete Alfano's Pizzeria

    Alfano's Pizza

    4.4(14 reviews)
    9.9 mi
    $$

    Homecooked and delicious. Family friendly and affordable. Did I say delicious yet? Prices are…read moreaffordable

    We've settled on and made peace with their original thinnest crust pizza. With the right toppings…read moreand eaten HOT, we've come to enjoy it. We're from Chicago. Nothing in Central Illinois compares to Chicago pizza........we've accepted that. Alfano's other pizzas, crusts, are just mediocre. We've also started to order the breadsticks, tho they could use more flavor like an "Aurelio's Pizza" breadsticks. I prefer a creamy garlic salad dressing for dipping the breadsticks. Alfano's does not serve one and all I could find in Central Illinois grocery stores that came close was a Wishbone creamy Italian. We've given up on the garlic bread, just too dried out, brittle and they won't add extra butter or garlic. Found out that their garlic bread is pre-made, then frozen, then thawed.........which explains the dissatisfaction. Yet, most of their other ingredients on their other food/pizzas, seem very fresh. All that said, it's nice that they deliver to the lake at Oak Run, $8 delivery charge and then we tip $5 on top of that. They've delivered in all weather, very much appreciated. And finally, everyone working there has always been very kind and efficient. We've never eaten at the restaurant itself. They've never messed up our credit card bill or gotten our order wrong. We're lucky they're there and that they will deliver.

    Photos
    Alfano's Pizza
    Alfano's Pizza - They make pizzas any shape that's requested!

    They make pizzas any shape that's requested!

    Alfano's Pizza - Pasta by the tray. Comes with an order of breadsticks

    See all

    Pasta by the tray. Comes with an order of breadsticks

    The Pizza House - 16" sausage pizza

    The Pizza House

    3.8(51 reviews)
    10.1 mi
    $

    Food-5 Me and my friend asked our hotel receptionist what…read moreher favorite pizza place is in Galesburg. She said it's hands down The Pizza House. After she said that a hotel guest in the lobby also chimed in and said the same thing. I love a good thin crust pizza with some crispiness on the crust, but not burnt. This was definitely one of the best pizzas that I've had in years. The sauce was good, there was a good proportionate amount of cheese, and that crust was perfect. We also got the house sampler and there was not one appetizer included in that sampler that I didn't like. Everything was made fresh and came out hot. Service-5 The service here was exceptional. Our server was very attentive and always came back at the right time to refill my drink. The kitchen staff was on point, and the owner was very welcoming and polite. You could tell that they actually care about their place of business. Ambiance-5 I loved the feel of this restaurant. It felt very old school in the best way. They definitely keep up on the cleaning, and are able to create a friendly atmosphere. Overall-5 Would I go back to this pizza place? 100% yes! This is going to be my go to pizza place anytime I'm in Galesburg. Everything about The Pizza House was exceptional. If you have not tried this pizza spot you are missing out big time, especially if you are like me and love a good thin crispy pizza.

    Great thin crust pizza!! The Pepperoni and Ham are our two favorites!! The Sandwiches are also…read moregreat!! Great service!!

    Photos
    The Pizza House - Pizza House

    Pizza House

    The Pizza House - Cold beer

    Cold beer

    The Pizza House - The pizza house party pizza 30" of yumminess.

    See all

    The pizza house party pizza 30" of yumminess.

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...