Sent our six year old and almost-4 year old to camp for a week -- three half days and two full days. I was really excited about this camp, but really ended up being incredibly let down.
If you think of this simply as a good day care option or good, basic outdoor camp experience, I'd give it five stars. But that would assume basic day care or basic outdoor camp prices. As a special, themed camp intended to be developmentally and educationally thoughtful (at prices reflective of that) 2 stars, tops.
First of all, the art projects were shockingly uninspired. (See the photos I posted of ALL of the projects for the week.) They just weren't thoughtful or inspired in any way. There are so many art projects they could have created that better utilized their nature findings. They could have helped kids better select items for their mobiles--which was the best project of the week--items that would actually last! They had tiny, wild daisies on some of them, which of course wilt in a half a day. And then TWO of the projects were inside-out tape bracelets -- one of which had the same little daisies and grass on them. The materials they provided were cheap and not natural (tape, synthetic pipe cleaners, etc). For the prices they charge, they should supplement the found materials with high quality art materials.
Pedagogically, it was also a disappointment, full of missed opportunities for teaching (about nature, materials, art, community). When our 4 year old was a bit shy and a little nervous about separation the first few days, not one adult got down on his level and tried to connect with him to help with the separation. Not one. On the third day, I specifically had to ask an adult to try to ease the transition, simply by trying to connect with him before expecting him to say goodbye and turn around an head off to the woods. (It wasn't that hard -- just very mild shyness and very mild anxiety about saying goodbye and going off with new adults and kids!) They didn't even make a point to tell the kids their names until I asked! Plus, it wasn't the same adult leading their group every single day. Also, for the half day camp, my six year old was grouped with exclusively three and four year olds; there were other older kids in different groups, but they seemed totally inattentive to trying to mix up the ages of the kids. It seemed like they just put kids into groups simply as they arrived. I asked about this and for subsequent days, they put an older child in the group so she would have a peer. So odd.
For comparison: my kids also attended the Parks + Creation Coyote Camp this summer. That camp was obviously staffed by people with a passion for young people and an understanding and knowledge of early childhood development. They had a clear rhythm to the day, started and ended every day with a circle time, the adults got down on the kids level, looked them in the eyes, and talked to them constantly (I never once saw this with the Caring Creatives camp!). The adults at Caring Creatives seemed fun and nice, to be sure, but they didn't seem like the knowledgable, passionate child educators I had hoped (and expected, at their price!!). They seemed much less experienced, with less knowledge about childhood development and pedagogy. Also, at the Parks + Creation camp, the kids came home having eaten their lunches every single day. This is very telling: at Parks + Creation, the teachers sit with the kids, eat their "growing food," commune over the meal (and snack), encourage them to eat, etc. But the following week, at Caring Creatives camp, my kids were coming home with their lunches barely eaten. My six year old said they just sat at lunchtime to eat, and kids were able to get up and play when they felt "done," which for a young child isn't really appropriate. As a result, they didn't eat much. As another comparison, they came home from the Parks and Creation camp happily dirty every day. Both camps were in the Presidio, and in the P&C camp, they got full of dirt and sand and mud, and were happily exhausted from endless hiking every day. But at the Caring Creatives camp, they hiked FAR less, and got FAR less dirty. Personally, for a nature camp in the Presidio, I want my kids digging in the dirt, getting their fingernails full of soil, connecting with nature physically. But at Caring Creatives, they sit on plastic tarps and somehow manage to come home with surprisingly clean fingernails and clothes.
I realize at this point I may sound like a shill for Parks plus Creation. I am not; in fact, I don't even live in SF (just visiting for the summer). It's just that their camps sounded like they would be very similar (with similarly high prices!). I actually had hoped the the Caring Creatives camp would be even better -- like Parks and Creation plus an amazing art piece added. Not so. In my six year old's words: "It was pretty fun, but we did WAY more in P+C. You can just recycle my projects." read more