Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Canoe Island Lodge

    2.8 (9 reviews)
    PriceyHotels

    Services - Canoe Island Lodge

    Hotels

    Canoe Island Lodge Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Canoe Island Lodge

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Amanda J.

    Majestic location and incredible staff makes for a wonderful vacation!! We had incredible sails, boat tours through gorgeous Lake George and loved our time on the beach at the private Canoe Island. Every member of the staff was welcoming and accommodating, always smiling and happy to make our stay enjoyable. Special thank you to Joe for seeming to masterfully coordinate everything that we needed and to Nora for taking care of our every request (no small feat with a few celiacs in the family) while we enjoyed the delicious breakfasts and dinners. The only way our 7 year old would leave is if we promised to come back next year - a promise we are happy to keep!

    Canoe Island Lodge on Lake George

    See all

    2 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 2
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Shawn S.
    176
    19
    13

    3 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 3
    Love this 0
    Oh no 2

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Dan M.
    85
    18
    5

    9 years ago

    Great family oriented "resort" where you can do anything from lay in the sun to canoe across the lake and with great fun and food included.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    17 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Canoe Island Lodge

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 1,012 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Melody Manor Resort

    Melody Manor Resort

    (21 reviews)

    $$

    This hotel is fabulous!…read more First and foremost - it could not be better for small children. The lake area is in a shallow cove and my kids were literally able to run out for a few minutes and still be up to their knees. There are plenty of kayaks and paddle boats to take out, and a small sandy beach area for the kids to play. There's also a pool on the property, but the lake area was great so we never even went. Rooms are a little older, but they are clean and spacious. The property is pretty small, so everything is an easy walk. There's also plenty of parking onsite. The location is also prime in Bolton and it's just a two minute drive up to all the shops and restaurants. The owners were super sweet and friendly and helped us out a few times when we were locked out of our room. Overall, this is a really nice family run hotel in Bolton and the location on the lake can't be beat. There are definitely cosmetic upgrades that could be made, but like many other hotels in the area it's a little old school. Looking forward to coming back - we had a great time here.

    We stayed at Melody Manor Sept 11- 17th and overall had a very pleasant experience. While the room…read morefeels a bit outdated, the beautiful grounds and serene lake views more than make up for it. Or room was clean, quiet, and the bed was very comfortable, which made for a truly relaxing stay.We especially appreciated the little touches, like coffee and donuts in the morning, which added to the welcoming atmosphere. If you're looking for a peaceful getaway with lovely scenery and a calm environment, this is a wonderful place to stay.

    Holiday Inn Resort Lake George - Adirondack Area - Lobby

    Holiday Inn Resort Lake George - Adirondack Area

    (89 reviews)

    $$

    We have been coming every winter for the past six years and have made some terrific memories here…read more There is so much I genuinely like about this place. The location is convenient and feels like part of our ritual now. The staff are almost uniformly kind and welcoming to our kids and us. They remember us, greet us cheerfully and make this feel like a home base. The outdoor hot tub was a particularly welcome amenity on this past brutally cold weekend and it helped us warm up a chill that seemed to go straight to our bones after time outside on the lake. It really is one of those few places that feels like a welcome retreat no matter the weather. If there weren't any flaws, this would be a much easier review to write. But there are flaws, and they are things that should have been tended to long ago. The rooms have definitely seen better days. Many of our dresser drawers barely opened. The refrigerator was hardly cool. Furniture had visible damage and some of the electrical outlets were non-functional or battered to the points that plugs fell right out f them. These are not deal breaking in isolation but taken together they left us feeling that the room was tired and poorly maintained. A little thoughtful maintenance or investment here could go a long way and make the rooms feel a lot more comfortable. Another disappointment this year was the breakfast buffet at TRs Restaurant. In years past it was a highlight and something our kids looked forward to to prepare for a cold morning out. This visit, the quality seemed to have declined and the selection felt smaller. The restaurant itself still has a lovely lake view and a cozy fireplace, and the service was still friendly and attentive, but the breakfast spread did not live up to our memories. So I find myself landing on a three star rating. If you take this place for what it can still be, it is a wonderful family resort with great staff and some truly nice amenities. But right now the condition of the rooms and some of the public areas combined with the breakfast experience hold it back from being the much stronger destination I know it can be. Here is hoping that ownership puts some money back into the property so it can recapture its full potential.

    Sixteen years. Same weekend. Same place. Same friends. Super…read moreBowl weekend in Lake George has become a tradition we wouldn't trade for anything. What started as a simple trip turned into something much bigger a weekend that's about reconnecting, laughing, catching up, and picking up right where we left off every year. By the time the Super Bowl rolls around, it feels less like a trip and more like a reunion. The first week of Winter Carnival just makes it better. The ice bar, great food and drinks, the energy around the resort and town it all sets the tone for an unforgettable winter weekend. A huge part of why this works year after year is the people who make the place feel like home. Courtney, the general manager, keeps everything running smoothly and consistently she sets the standard. Tyler and Nicole at the bar are always a big part of the weekend, and Becca and Tonya at the front desk make arrivals feel easy and welcoming every single time. Even in the heart of winter, the place is always spotless thanks to Keisha and her housekeeping crew something we appreciate more than most people realize. Sixteen straight Super Bowl weekends, countless memories, and friendships that keep growing. Some traditions just stick because they're done right. Can't wait to see everyone again at the Holiday Inn Resort Lake George. Already counting down.

    Courtyard by Marriott Lake George

    Courtyard by Marriott Lake George

    (90 reviews)

    $$

    We stayed here for a conference in October. The hotel itself is very nice, there is a parking…read moregarage in the back which is convenient. The staff was friendly as well. We stayed in a room with 2 queen beds, it was very spacious and clean. There was only two draws to put our clothes so we each only got one. The shower was big, but the water pressure wasn't great. Overall, it was a nice experience and I would recommend staying here. Also there is a roof top which is very nice and has a view of the lack and mountais. You definitely need to check it out.

    I spent Columbus Day weekend gazing out over the lake from a balcony that made me feel briefly like…read morean aristocrat who had misplaced his crown. The room had two king beds, a small miracle for a man accustomed to one, and the soundproofing was a triumph of human engineering. Even with Oktoberfest raging below, once the balcony door was closed the silence was so complete that I could almost hear my own thoughts apologizing for existing. The hotel sits right on Canada Street, which is the main artery of Lake George's little heart. Shepard Park is practically across the street, full of families, music, and the particular chaos of people on vacation trying to have a perfect time. The staff managed to stay cheerful through it all, smiling with the kind of sincerity that must come from good training or good souls. Parking was a game of Tetris, but I was grateful for the garage. Once my car was wedged in, I had no reason to drive again. Everything that mattered was within walking distance. The rooftop terrace deserves a poem, though I am too lazy to write one. The lake spread out below, blue and calm, and for a few minutes I believed in peace on earth. There is no hot tub, which feels like a crime against nature. The patio outside the pool almost begs for one. Imagine sitting there in January, snow falling into the water, steam rising like forgiveness. The restaurant did not thrill me, and the prices made my wallet flinch. Still, it was a fine stay, the kind that makes you feel momentarily better about the human race before the bill arrives to remind you of reality. Four stars. A lovely place, too expensive for what it is, but worth remembering all the same.

    The Sagamore - You can clearly see the handcuff is in locked position.

    The Sagamore

    (374 reviews)

    $$$$

    What a stunning location. The views are stunning. The atmosphere was perfect and just a wonderful…read moreplace.

    I've heard about The Sagamore Resort for years and was excited to finally experience it this past…read moreweekend. Everyone I mentioned it to raved about how wonderful it is, so we arrived with high expectations and lots of anticipation. At check-in we were given a list of activities, which all looked fun -- though we later learned most didn't begin until the following day. Not a big issue, just something to be aware of if you're arriving for a short stay. We stayed in the Hermitage Lodge, and the layout of the room was actually very nice -- a downstairs kitchenette and small living area, with a beautiful loft upstairs featuring a king bed. The only drawback was having just one bathroom. Unfortunately, shortly after arriving, we noticed several ants -- first on the bed in the loft, then in the bathroom, and later in other areas of the room. Given the cold winter weather, it was surprising. We chose to mention it to the front desk the next day. They kindly offered to move us and provided a $70 credit, which we appreciated. Since we only had one night left, we decided not to relocate. At the room rate, we had hoped for a bit more in terms of condition upon arrival. We enjoyed lunch at Caldwell's and dinner at Mr. Brown's Pub, and later at La Bella Vita -- all pleasant experiences (I've reviewed those separately). The property itself is truly beautiful. In the winter, however, many of the scheduled activities and amenities seemed primarily geared toward families with young children. That's perfectly fine -- I've raised two boys, I get it -- but it wasn't quite the "grand" weekend experience we had envisioned. I can absolutely imagine that in the summer, with the stunning views of Lake George and the full range of offerings, this resort feels magical. In the winter, while still lovely, it didn't fully match our expectations for the price point. Overall, it's a beautiful property with kind staff and great dining -- just perhaps better suited to families or a summertime stay.

    Stone Gate Resort - Double Queen Hotel Room

    Stone Gate Resort

    (18 reviews)

    This place is great for families. Pool, beach, fitness room, soccer field, basketball court, fire…read morepits, etc. The short proximity to the deli is another bonus. Staff is super friendly and accommodating. The owners are consistently maintaining and updating the resort. They care about this place and their guests! We have rented a cabin 4 different summers and have zero interest staying anywhere else in the Lake George area. My only ask is more love for the fitness center, maybe a smith machine and some heavier dumbbells? To be clear, that's not a negative comment, I'm just being needy. Haha. See you guys next LG vacation!

    In our experience at this resort I can honestly say that it was a pleasant stay . We stood in a…read morefamily suite hotel side . My first thought while entering the room was very positive. Throughout the study went noticed a couple of minor flaws . Bathroom doors were hard to open and close ( woke up other family members during the night ) . Fridge/ freezer seemed to be on every saver during the night and early morning ( semi melting ice , ice cream etc in freezer ) . Lights in room are limited & dimmed , not much light within the whole room. Amenities on this property were great . Plenty of sports and well equipped . Staff were helpful , respectful & hard working . Lake & sandy beach area was kept clean & organized. There's a bit of a drop hike to get to the lake BUT they offer complimentary golf cart service to & from.

    Flamingo Resort On Lake George - Flamingo Resort Beach at Sunrise.

    Flamingo Resort On Lake George

    (22 reviews)

    Flamingo Resort has been a part of my life for the past 14 summers, and I can honestly say it holds…read morea special place in my heart. From the beginning, under the original owners, this resort became more than just a vacation spot, it became part of our family tradition. The original owners were truly remarkable people who poured their hearts into the resort, treating guests like family. Their warmth, hospitality, and understanding of what made this place special set the tone for everything we've come to love. Now under new ownership, I know there have been mixed reviews, but let's be honest, everyone starts somewhere. Chris, the new owner, listens, takes suggestions seriously, and is clearly making an effort to modernize the resort while honoring its legacy. Change is never easy, especially when emotions and memories run deep, but I see the intention behind it and truly appreciate the effort. The rooms have been revamped with clean floors and refreshed spaces, and housekeeping comes every two days, which works perfectly. And if you ever need something... just ask! The staff is accommodating and always willing to help. What keeps us/me coming back year after year? It's the community of regular guests who've become our "summer neighbors." That sense of connection and tradition is still very much alive. Chris understands how much we loved the previous owners and respects that legacy, while also bringing a new chapter to Flamingo Resort. Change takes time, but the heart of Flamingo is still beating strong. And for me that's reason enough to keep coming back.

    Enjoyed our stay. Had a few issues but Chris was very receptive and worked hard to rectify our…read moreproblems. Thank you

    The Inn at Erlowest

    The Inn at Erlowest

    (50 reviews)

    $$$

    Loved it there. The townhouses are a little dated but I didn't mind it at all. We loved seeing the…read moreminnie ha ha go by. We saw a groundhog on the grounds along with chipmunks.

    2.5 stars: Underwhelming food, nice people, pretty venue…read more Vibe: Big stone detail building right on the water, we were a party of 12 seated in a private room, fancy older house vibe. Service: One server for our party, she was nice but a little oddly for a server she didn't know what ginger ale was and wasn't sure if they had decaf. Our food came out with a pretty big gap between plates, I was finished with mine by the time another in our party got hers. I will say they were very gracious seeing as we were a half hour late. Food: Pretty underwhelming, you could get similar or better food at your local diner. Menu is somewhat limited as well especially for sides and drinks. I got the french toast, it wasn't very moist at all, uninteresting flavor, the strawberry garnish was dried up on the inside so must have been left out for a while, bacon was fine, maple syrup was good. I had a few bites of the omelette which was good and home fries which were on the dry side and without much flavor. Value: It wasn't too expensive thankfully despite being marketed as a 'fine dining experience' I'd say value was about even with the low quality food, french toast was $11. Overall definitely would not recommend, you could get better food at a diner or cafe.

    Canoe Island Lodge - hotels - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...