I'd like to say that this is the best 2 person bakery around…read more I recently had a chocolate covered bacon cupcake from this bakery. I had never heard of this and the assistant talked me into it. Let me say. If you haven't tried it, you should. This was the best, moist, delicious cupcake that I have ever eaten. I'm also impressed with this bakery because these 2 women do so much as though they have a full staff and it's only the 2 of them. There maybe someone to help out every now and then, but think about it. Put yourself in their shoes. For anyone to give these 2 ladies a bad review it's really being a coward. They work off of pictures that you submit to their email. They get it so close to perfect...to do this, they do not go home at quitting time..... They do whatever it takes including work all through the night to get out- your orders and no other bakery will do that. These women have a heart of gold, if you let them know before leaving the shop that you want something changed with your order, they will do it. My hat goes off to these 2 amazing, hard working ladies. You want to complain- come on try it- do what they do.....I dare you........ let's see if you want to pull an all nighter. Best of luck ladies fit doing an amazing job!

I wasn't familiar with this business until just the other night. I was a casino dealer for an 80th…read morebirthday party. The cake was beautiful! It was a sheet cake designed to look like a beach scene with graham cracker crumbled sand, little shells and starfish, a palm tree, and a cute little chair. Beauty aside, it is the tastiest cake I have had in ages! I will definitely order a cake from here if I have a special occasion that needs a cake.

Service is great and store has do many unique, nice gifts. Cakes and desserts are always pretty…read moreand great tasting.

Amazing! Gorgeous yummy cakes and wonderful customer service!…read more Thanks Katie for making a special occasion even better! We will tell all of our friends about your fantastic shop!

My wife doesn't like too much sweetness. Looking at the…read moretopping on the cupcakes scared me, looks really sweet!!! But one taste and I was hooked!!! This place is by far the best cake I've tasted in Tallahassee!!! My words are not enough, so I will give just one word, one acronym: OMG!!!!! Photo of the red velvet cheese cake. LOL. Oops.

Loved this place ! The owner was cheerful and happy to answer questions. I got the 6 pack of…read moreregulars (They have MASSIVE Jumbo's). Every cupcake looked amazing and tasted better. Can't wait to go back :)

Great price Great service…read more Great vibes 10/10 recommend for a sweet treat after a rough exam...not speaking from experience of course

I love coming here, the drinks are always so good and well made. The staff are always super sweet…read moreand nice to interact with and the tables are so cutesy and nice to just sit down and relax. It's nice to have a place to sit down and unwind. This large cup was just about $7-$8. And honestly, it's definitely worth it. ^u^

It's the only location here in Tallahassee, Florida. Normally their cookies look really good and…read morethey always taste excellent. I'm not knocking the quality of the cookie at all. They are amazing tasting. Normally they do pretty good with presentation, last week with the mine craft ones. They were spectacular. The presentation this week was horrible. The icing looked bad .. it is supposed to be coded more on the zebra cakes all the way around and it was just on top. The strawberry one was supposed to have white chocolate on the bottom and it did not. The oatmeal cream pies were squished. I'm going to include pictures. Like I said the store is amazing. The people are always nice. The quality of the item taste on point. Just this week's presentation was not very good at all. My husband did say they seem to be very rushed and busy.

Great loved the cookie what more could you ask for beside 10 dollar cookies and stuff like thatread more

This review is only about their Cake Pops. As far as I know they do not have a permanent sales…read morelocation and I have never seen their truck at any event I have been to. I have had their Cake Pops twice at exhibit opening events at the Florida Historic Capitol Museum and they have been a delicious highlight. They are like a big tootsie roll pop with a delicious soft cake interior and a firm, tasty icing outside. I do not remember the flavors the first time I tried them, but this last time they had red velvet, chocolate and birthday cake and they were all so good. It may be a good thing for me that they are not readily available as I could become seriously addicted to them.

What an amazing experience!!! I called at 1 pm today and talked to Andi May and explained to her…read morehow my daughter's 21st Birthday Cake got canceled and just wanted something there for her party...(I am 5 hours away).... Not only did she make and delivery, within 3 hours , 21 delicious and beautifully decorated Cake Pops... she went out of her way and personalized the box with the theme I told her about.... I can't say enough about what a wonderful experience I had... Would highly recommend to anyone!!!!....She even sent me a pic of the Birthday Girl!!!

I've had multiple cakes and cupcakes from Baked Expectations and they never disappoint…read more Janel did my graduation cake it was a spice cake with an icing that tasted like eggnog. Everyone enjoyed this cake I have recommended her to many friends and co-workers. I ended up freezing slices and they were still fresh and froze well over the next 3 months I had it. Do not wait last minute to contact her she is always busy with orders!

This bakery is amazing. I ordered a speciality cake and cake pops for my daughter's 21st birthday…read moreand it was a HUGE hit! Not only did the specialty cake come out exactly as I asked, it was delicious and the cake pops were unique and equally as delicious. I will be ordering every year from here.

This was a nice treat! They have puddings, custards, banana breads, and cookies. I opted for a…read morechunky monkey banana pudding custard which was delicious and had biscotti biscuit pieces and it was delicious! The service was great and if you are a student or health care employee you get a 10 percent discount. The ambiance is cute and chill. Perfect for a date night, family outing, or to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings. I liked that they have several size options. I had the 3 oz which was perfect for me! I would visit them again if I am in town.

Cute new place in town! Service was quick and staff was willing to converse with us. We didn't get…read moreany baked goods but the puddings were delicious. The puddings are chilled and creamy, which I much prefer to regular ice cream. The lighting and furniture arrangements made for a welcoming experience. We'll be sure to visit again.