Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Butter and Herb

    5.0 (1 review)

    Butter and Herb Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Butter and Herb

    Recommended Reviews - Butter and Herb

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Butter and Herb

    Tony's on the Lake - 8 oz tenderloin medium rare with cognac gnocchi. Do it...do it.

    Tony's on the Lake

    4.0(340 reviews)
    24.1 mi
    •$$$

    Number one... Make a reservation. This place packs up quickly…read more I think you can ask for a window table also in advance. The atmosphere is nice. I liked my meal, but my husband wasn't a fan. My husband had the Cajun or jambalaya type. Salmon dish. It's been about a month since we ate there and I don't remember what I had... But I did like it. Before you order, I would recommend reading reviews on menu items and make your choice from there... But I will still give this place five stars because it's a great place to have lunch or dinner with friends based on the atmosphere. And the service was good.& front of house ... A+

    The food here is really delicious! We came here for the first time in August 2025 ( I will attach…read morephotos from then compared to August 2026 ) It is expensive and the portions are small. You can't beat the views though and the cocktails are really good as well. However, compared to our experience in August 2025, which was a 10/10 this time was personally a 6/10 for these reasons: We ordered the shrimp cocktail just like last year and noticed there was one less shrimp (4 instead of 5) We also ordered the halibut with risotto just like last year and the portion was notably smaller with both the fish and risotto this year compared to 1 year ago. Our friend who also ordered the halibut mentioned hers was a bit dry. although I did not notice that on my dish when I ordered the same. Our waiter was nice enough and we didn't go without, but he wasn't that personable and also gave us a real dirty look when we paid after he looked at what we tipped which was very strange. I wouldn't say this years trip here was a disappointment but it was different compared to 1 year ago for these reasons.

    Photos
    Tony's on the Lake
    Tony's on the Lake - 8 oz tenderloin medium rare with cognac gnocchi.  Do it ... Do it.

    8 oz tenderloin medium rare with cognac gnocchi. Do it ... Do it.

    Tony's on the Lake - Newly updated beautiful dining room!

    See all

    Newly updated beautiful dining room!

    Tomato Street - Jalapeno Bacon and Chicken Lunch Sandwich

    Tomato Street

    3.9(342 reviews)
    28.2 mi
    •$$

    My kids absolutely love tomato street…read more It is, without question, their favorite restaurant. So for that, tomato Street gets an extra star over what I would give them. To be fair, tomato street is really kid friendly. They have kids menus, a great kids menu, the tables are all covered in parchment paper, and they bring crayons to the table and the kids can just go crazy. They also stamp the kids menus on to the table. The service is always good at tomato street. The people who work here always friendly. No complaints there. There's a large parking lot on the other side of the building from appleway. No complaints there either. My problem with tomato street is that Italian restaurants are known for their large portion size. This is not the case at tomato street. These portions are so small, when I got my entree, I honestly asked if I had accidentally ordered off of the lunch menu for the lunch portion. But no, that's just how big the portions are at tomato street. And by big I mean small. And does this come with a reduction in price? No it does not. The prices are a little higher than what I would call average, and again, the portion size is very small. The food is good. The service is good. The place has a good ambience. But the reason it gets four stars is because my kids love it.

    Updated 8.29.26: My roommate chose this place to have his birthday dinner. We made reservations for…read more3 people at 6p and when we arrived we were greeted and sat immediately. Mike was our server and took out drink order promptly and returned with yummy garlic bread. We ordered 2 appetizers: the cheesy artichoke dip and the oven baked bollas. The dip was thick and creamy and the bread it came with was toasted and had grated Parmesan on it. My roommate loves the bollas and this time was no different. For my entree, I got the Seafood Manicotti, my roommate got his favorite Twice Baked Spaghetti, and his mom created her own pasta: angel hair pasta with marinara and grilled chicken. The Seafood Manicotti was delicious and flavorful. The creamy Alfredo sauce had perfect texture and the herb filling combined with the seafood gave it layers of goodness. My roommate and his mom, both enjoyed their entrees and had enough to take home for a second meal. Tomato Street doesn't sing happy birthday, however they gave my roommate a complimentary Chocolate Lush dessert, which was nice. I got the Creme Brulee and his mom went with the Tiramisu. Mike accidentally brought me Grandma's Bread Pudding but corrected his mistake. So I ended up with 2 desserts and both were excellent. Birthday celebration was a success, Mike was a great server, and everyone was happy with all the food.

    Photos
    Tomato Street
    Tomato Street - Creamy Cheesy Artichoke Dip

    Creamy Cheesy Artichoke Dip

    Tomato Street

    See all

    Butter and Herb - italian - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...