Was in the neighborhood and thought we would give it a try. It was a solid bar. Good drinks and decent beer list. Love the eclectic wall art. Wish it was quieter, but it's 9 PM on a Saturday night....what do you expect ? :). Definitely worth the trip here again. read more

Normally, I do not go into Burnhearts just to have a drink but when I am with friends and we head over there, a few things come to mind: - dark and chill bar area - free shuffleboard - a tasty beer selection Sold. Not sure why I do not go there more often. read more

The vibe of this place is great and gets 6 stars. The drinks are what you'd expect from a milwaukee bar... nothing too inventive at this place. I've been here twice and have enjoyed both visits. The bartender (granted it was a weekday night) could have been more secretive about not knowing how to make the cocktails on the menu. She kept on referring back to a laminated piece of paper to check on ingredients. Better than getting a bad tasting drink, right? read more

I love this place with all of my heart. Some of the best drinks in the city with some of the best staff on the planet. If you haven't been or are looking for a reason to go; this is it! Cheers and enjoy. read more

Burnhearts has a really low key cool vibe. The bar is electrically decorated, has dark lighting, and is a great place to chill out and have a drink. There is a food truck regularly parked outside and it is a short walk off of KK Avenue. The beer and liquor selection is huge! read more

Great place to hang out in Bay View. The Bartenders ROCK, they're always friendly and very knowledgeable on their HUGE beer selection. Great drink prices. Burnhearts has a Great atmosphere!! It's has more of an intimate setting in the front of the bar with dimmer lighting. I Highly recommend Burnhearts. read more

I came here for a friend's birthday on a Saturday night. Selection of drinks and beer was great and people were alright. It was crowded and seating for a group our size was difficult, but hey it worked out that we all found a little cozy spot. It's a chill place to hang out. Perhaps the beer selection is really what you come for, but I must have missed something in the element of the atmosphere. Could've been the night, so I will give it another try. Bar tender recognized teachers (my friend and I) which was awesome, so I felt in good company being around decent people who have a decent respect for decent people :) read more

Man, Burnhearts. In a town full of really solid bars, you are by far my favorite. You know that guy that's always screaming "Freebird!" at concerts because he's just so into that song and Lynyrd Skynyrd that he doesn't care what anyone else thinks about it? I'm kinda like that with Burnhearts. Even if Burnhearts gets over exposed and people stop thinking it's cool, I'm still totally going to dig it. Thirty years from now I wanna be that guy that goes into other bars and screams out "Burnhearts!" We're gonna sit around a table and talk about the good times we had there. "Hey, you guys remember when we had those super solid drinks at Burnhearts?" to which the question is "Which time?". EVERYTIME is super solid. I wanna be that old guy in the retirement home rocking the Burnhearts trucker hat in the summer, and the Burnhearts beanie in the winter. I'll tell my grand kids about the ridiculous tap list and the lust-worthy bottle list. The bourbon barrel brandy old fashioneds. The brandy slushes. I'll be nostalgic of all of the Mittenfests and Pabst Street Parties. I'll think back on the great bartenders. I want to be like "Freebird!" guy. I don't care what you think about it, I love it. Two Chainz wants to be buried in a Gucchi store. Bury me in Burnhearts. read more

My friends and I came in here Tuesday night while taking a mini-vacation in Milwaukee. We all work in various aspects of the restaurant industry and wanted to get away. After some guests left from the middle of the bar, we stepped up and waited patiently to grab a drink. The bartender continued to bounce from left to right but completely ignored us. She never even acknowledged our presence really. We waited for more than 10 minutes and finally decided to leave. Apparently, this bar is just for the regular crowd. read more

It's tough to go against the grain sometimes but with Burnhearts I must be missing something. Perhaps this is a place people like because other people like. Or perhaps I don't appreciate it. But Burnhearts was nothing special at all to me. The bartender wasn't friendly. The place is small and divey, and there's nothing too unique about it. They do have a solid draft beer list, but the drinks aren't all that cheap, especially for Bay View. I paid $12.50 for two drinks, on a Wednesday, in Bay View. The music selection (perhaps it was just that night) was loud and intruding. I can understand and dig the whole not having at TV thing, so people can talk to eachother and have conversation rather than distraction. I get it. But the loud music made it hard to do that. I didn't check out the back which I heard can be cool, perhaps I should have, but it didn't seem to be "open". When reading the reviews of this place, perhaps I've missed something. But I didn't feel welcome at this bar, I felt like I shouldn't be there. I'll take my business elsewhere, but to everyone who loves Burnhearts - you can have my spot. read more

Here is where I turn into a blubbering fool. I absolutely love this place. I am as beer nerdy as beer nerds come, and they always have something on tap that makes me a bit giddy. It was a lovely afternoon and after a hike, a friend and I decided it was beer thirty. As is the norm with Burnie's, one of their taps made me give myself a high five. Three Floyds Zombie Dust. This stuff is beyond good. The bartender (I believe his name was Christian?) was an affable fellow and knew his stuff. I'm a little nervous that I'll be moving within walking distance, because this is the kind of place I could find myself way too often. Great beer, great tunes and their prices are incredibly reasonable. As much as I love Palm Tavern, this is the best bar in Bay View. read more

Great selection of craft beer, some mixed drinks, great service, packed many nights a week, hosts many beer tapings and special events. Great music too. read more

If you love trying new beers while sporting your favorite plaid button-down (and I know I unashamedly do), this place is for you! Low lit, comfortable, and woodsy. I find myself expecting to see the Brawny guy smoking a pipe outside. Often it's just a thin pale dude smoking American Spirits, but I'm sure he can lift a Lincoln Log. Parking isn't hard to find--always a plus when you're coming from another neighborhood. Or Canada. Did I mention the beers? Only a few minor setbacks: it's always too warm in there, and I find myself sweating like a hipster on a unicycle. The bar is super hard to get an order in because patrons tend to flock (especially if you're short a soft-spoken). Prepare to squeeze uncomfortably or take a tall, loud friend. And the clientele is around mid to late twenties with millennial indie music, so if you're looking for a quiet conversation, especially on a weekend (other than texting across the table to each other), this might not be the place. read more

They have so many beer selections!!! I love the vibe of this place. From the moment I walked in I felt right at home. It is a bit dark inside with just the right amount of lighting. First thing you see is all the different beers on tap. They have a pool table and a shuffle board in the back with a bunch of quaint little booths to enjoy the relaxing environment. read more

Terrible service. Waited 25 minutes sitting at the front of the bar and didn't get served. Bartender (male) continuously skipped over customers who had been sitting waiting for new customers who had just arrived. Ended up leaving due to no service. read more

This place has multiple things going for it....It's in Bay View, it's on a corner in the middle of a neighborhood, amazing craft beer list. These are all things that are important to me in a local watering hole. I don't get here nearly enough, but it never disappoints and always makes for an awesome last Sunday night hurrah before Monday. This is one of those Milwaukee bars you must get to, don't over look it. read more

My guy and I went to Milwaukee for the weekend and so we wanted a cool dive bar just like the ones in Chicago (home) and we stumbled upon Burnhearts! It felt just like home and we loved that. It was cozy, dark and intimate. A great beer selection and the employees were awesome. Definitely coming back whenever we're back in town. read more

This place is definitely a Bay View top 3! Atmosphere is awesome, drink choices are plentiful and they've got one hell of a beer selection. Highly recommended!! read more

The best selection of Coopers I've seen outside Australia. Worth the visit for that alone!!!! Recommend the Coopers Lager.

Why is this bar so good? I'm not exactly sure, but it is. I visited during a recent trip to Wisconsin. It's kind of a divey little hut, with colorful Christmas lights and nooks and crannies, plus classic 60's furniture and a shuffleboard table. Cool enough, right? Except that the beer selection is what puts it off the charts. They have rotating taps of carefully selected beers. Last time I was there they had New Glarus Enigma on tap! Whoa! Overall, this place rocks. I'll definitely be back. read more

Let's start with I am only giving this place two stars because of the stellar beer selection. Otherwise I would give it a zero for the fact that when trying to order an old fashioned, which by the way, we were told they make really good ones here, the bartender basically told us in a roundabout way that we were delusional to even think that she would take the time to make us a drink because they were just too busy. I'm sorry, I have lived in Wisconsin all of my life, and no matter what bar I have been to, whatever you order, if the bar has it in stock the bartender will make it, no matter how busy they are. Clearly they don't need the business so I will gladly not patronize that establishment again. read more

I like this bar enough. Situated in an easy to find location, plenty of tap options and friendly/efficient bartenders. I make a point to head to most of their block parties. I wish they'd put more effort into the food options, but Classic Slice is awesome in my book. The music is insanely loud, felt bad for my poor dogs sensitive ears, but I suppose that's to be expected. Strange collection of people, all pretty friendly. read more

Burnhearts will always have a special place in my own heart. This is a style of bar that exemplifies Milwaukee: a lower converted to a bar that is dimly lit with christmas lights and funky bar decor including red glowing anatomical hearts. This place has its own funky character, with wonderful wall art and a boob-tastic collection of classic pin-ups near the bathrooms. Aside from the general atmosphere I love the expansive collection of regional microbrews, both bottles and taps, and great music selection, mostly contemporary indie rock. They occasionally have CD release parties (Animal Collective is the one I attended) here hosted by the Wisconsin specific indie-blog Muzzle of Bees and they often have a guy DJing in the corner. Lastly, it's my favorite shuffle-puck spot in the city. Definitely my favorite bar here! read more

Great atmosphere, with silly and interesting things all over the walls. I don't drink beer, but have been told there's a fantastic selection. The cocktails are unusual, interesting, and damn tasty (as well as strong!). Obviously you should go here. read more

You guyyyyyys!!! I got engaged at Burnhearts and it's the cutest sorry ever. We LOVE this bar.

Burnhearts never fails to reinforce why it's my favorite bar in the city. It combines a FANTASTIC beer selection, some of the friendliest bartenders in Milwaukee, quirky and colorful regulars and a great spirit selection at stellar prices. Did I mention shuffleboard, jenga and soul music? With a constantly rotating selection of local and intriguing tap beers and an atmosphere that never quits, Burnhearts is easily one of the bar gems of the city read more

Burnhearts if my favorite corner bar in Bay View. It's cozy and the beer selection is great.

I love this place! I find the best beers in town here and I always have new ones to try. Really great ambiance and music to boot! I always suggest checking this place out when people come in from out of town! read more

This place is great! I came here for a happy hour not knowing what to expect and was floored by the awesome beer selection and atmosphere. A truly great place to lounge. read more

Always a fun time. Live DJs and the staff is always nice. Pool table & shuffleboard are always fun. Plus, they have board games if u really wanna nerd out. Great beer selection with LOTS of new beers on tap every time I go. Lots of seasonal brews too. read more

This bar=my fave. Check them out on Instagram.... We've snagged quite the beer deals that way and find out all the select taps they be tappin. I highly recommend checking out their mystery bomber night. read more

Absolutely loved this place. Great beer selection, awesome vibe and such a wide variety of music. Off the beaten path and wonderful. COME HERE! read more

Great beer list, not a fan of the smoke but that will change later in the year. But friendly staff very comfortable place.

Best life coaches in MKE! They do what they do and do it well... bartenders are all fun and knowledgeable about the liquids they slang... The cocktail menu is always on point... and, i think i'm going to go get a beer after writing this review... read more

Great bar and even better bartender. Katie is definitely a keeper. Will be back many time more...

My favorite bar in Bay View! They have cool, considerate bartenders, and an awesome, always rotating, beer selection. They have dope cocktails too! read more

Cool spot for a craft beer, good music, and a cool vibe. AMong other songs, we got to chill out to Dead Prez and Ice Cube. No problem there. read more

Great Bayview people watching, kick ass DJs, cheap beers - what more do you want? I used to DJ here and they'd feed me PBR and Powers shots. Hard to beat. read more

I really like burnhearts. Good music, people and atmosphere. I always find myself looking at the texture of the hair of the girl in the art piece on the back wall. And they have shuffleboard!! With a chalkboard to make up funny team names and keep track of how many times you crush your opponents. I love the patio in the summer too. Good for bayview people watching and bumping into friends. read more

One of my favorite haunts in Milwaukee with a top-notch craft beer selection (both bottled and draft) and ultra-friendly (and rather pretty) staff. Feels more like a beautiful worn-in coffeehouse than a bar...in a very good way. Drink specials all the time too. read more