My tribe and I are always trying to find a good pizza place for dinner. So far, we've been to Brooklyn Pizza three times in the past month. Yes, it's that good but let me break it down for you from our POV. The place's decor can use a pick me up, but this has nothing to do with the food. With so many windows, the area still seems a bit dark--just my opinion. The booths are a great size where six people can fit, but the seats weren't clean and had a lot of crumbs. However, the waitstaff and cashier were super friendly and answered questions we had. Now let's get to the food! Since we've been there several times so far, I will write this review collectively of our experiences. The first time we ordered take-out, and they screwed up one of our orders. I placed a call and informed the manager of the order mixup. The manager apologized and told me the next time I come in to order, and it will be replaced for free. We've tried the wings, and it was delicious. Bacon and pepperoni on pizza are big winners with my tribe. Thin crust and cheesy a big hit with the tribe. Everyone gave it a thumbs up! I prefer a pasta dish, and my favorite is the penne vodka with chicken. My other favorite is a white slice with tomatoes. YUMMY! Looking forward to going back soon and trying new dishes!! read more

Convenient and a good family quality pizza. I go there 2 times a month and like the place but when I want high quality pizza I drive further and pay more for a more authentic Italian pizza that is a real treat. read more

Sauce used on pizza has become overpowering over the years. Crust is good, but overall flavor has become repulsive. I don't know what has happened. read more

Ordered delivery via Door Dash. All went well and pricing was fair. First time trying their pizza and would order again. Nice sauce, thicker crust that was chewy, savory pepperoni. Even tasted well the next day both cold and re-warmed. Stored their phone number in my "Give 'em a Whirl" meter's memory bank. Try 'em! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Decent pie - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

Staff is rude for no reason the food is cold most of the time I use to love this place before i started getting attitude for no reason

Authentic NY Pizza at its finest! Great atmosphere and super friendly staff. Always fully staffed which leads me to believe it's a great place to work. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pep & Jalp. Only way to go!! - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

Wow! Had no idea this place was that good!! The meat lovers pizza was enormous and we also ordered a gluten free pizza which was delicious, and its hard to find a good GF pizza! Prices are super reasonable for what you get and service was good! read more

See all

Very good! Ordered at the counter and then the team delivers to your table. Team was very pleasant and polite. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Chicken Roll - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

See all

Horrible service. Stopped in on a Friday night with my elderly parents. We were in line to order and saw a table open so we grabbed it so my parents could sit down. Right after we sat down, we were rudely told by Felicia we could not sit there. When I asked why, she stated because there was another party that had already ordered so they got the table! I was shocked! We abandoned the table assuming we could find another one. When we went to place our order, the cashier asked if we had a table. I explained we did but were told we had to leave. She said we could only place our order to go since we didn't have a table secured! Seriously?! We placed our order to go and we're lucky enough to find a table as our pizza came out. Needless to say we will not return. read more

Being a former New Yorker my multiple dealings with Brooklyn Pizza have been very good I must say. It's not a white table cloth establishment, but in my opinion their offerings are better than most. Their pizza is pretty good it doesn't look or taste like a piece of cardboard, with ketchup and cheese from Harris Teeter dairy Dept. on it (Not a crack on HT just offering a visual on cheese in a zip lock bag). Enjoy! read more

Stopped for lunch, I had a Sicilian slice & salad. They had several lunch specials to consider. I like they sell by slice. The pizza was very good, the service was awesome and they had a good crowd. We will definitely return read more

The worst Chicken Parm that I have eaten ever. They actually use frozen chicken patties for the chicken parm. Completely unacceptable! Nasty! read more

Solid pizza, chicken rolls, and other Brooklyn pizza parlor favorites right in Wesley Chapel. The line was steady but moving quickly on Friday night and this place has tons of seating for a neighborhood pizza parlor. Roughly 12 options for slices plus chicken rolls, stuffed pizzas, calzones, wings, and pin wheels (eager to order some next time). Service is quick and most items come out in 10 minutes or less. Good local spot to grab a slice or two along with a brew. read more

See all

This happened 6 months ago but never posted here. We have not been back and continue to inform people of this and tell them never to support this business. ACCESS ISSUE Brooklyn Pizza in Waxhaw/Matthews NC I've been here numerous times with my service dogs and not once have I had an access issue until today. I attempted to educate to be returned with excuse after excuse, I'm still seated and being served but they're doing it with major attitude. Do better Brooklyn Pizza, why only after my years of coming here are you starting this up. Not a way to treat your disabled customers. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

We visit Brooklyn Pizza often. I have no idea why they have a three star review at this time...we always enjoy our pizza, wether we take it home or eat in. We have enjoyed the Brooklyn Bridge every visit. We have also tried the fettuccine Alfredo, garlic knots, a calzone, and the Baked Ziti. All were excellent. We find the staff to be helpful and kind. This is the only pizza I crave. We will definitely continue visiting and enjoying their food! read more

Pizza is always good but the three times I've gone inside to eat, my servers have been less than friendly. They've seemed uninterested when you're placing your order and once, mid order, a girl turned around to say to a coworker "remind me to tell you something" and then turned back to me and said "oh, sorry. What did you ask for?" If you're craving their pizza, get takeout. read more

These days, it seems that prices keep going up and somehow the quality goes down. I got a Greek salad with chicken to go today and I wouldn't feed it to my dog. The cold refrigerated chicken looks gray and mealy, the lettuce is wilted and nearly bad, they put rock hard crumbled Parmesan cheese instead of feta, cherry tomatoes were almost rotten. If I were in the restaurant I would've thrown this across the room aiming for the idiot that made it. Totally done with this ripoff restaurant. It's a crime they call themselves "Brooklyn Pizza" There's alternatives folks, go someplace else. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Garbage. - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

At first I hesitated about going because of some of the negative reviews but we had such a great experience I wanted to leave a review. It is a 'quick service' style restaurant so you can quickly set the expectation that this is casual dining. We ordered a regular and a gluten free pizza, a venetian salad and a kids chicken tenders. The regular pizza had a light, crispy crust and a delicious flavor. The kids meal and salad were both very good. The gluten free pizza was not my favorite but it did taste good. Just not as good as the regular pizza or as good as some other gluten free pizza's I've had. The service was wonderful. Right away they were available to take my order, the food came out quickly and they came by a few times to check on us. We were very happy and will definitely be back. read more

Horrible service. Horrible food. The manager Felicia was rude and argumentative. The food was barely warm. It was under cooked and the calamari was rubbery. I will never eat here again. Don't waste your time or money eating here. read more

This is the only half-decent pizza place in the Wesley Chapel area; otherwise, they would get a 1. The toppings are good, for sure, but the pizza is always floppy and undercooked. The audacity of this place to charge $30 for a pizza with three toppings makes me want to drive across town for something better. Average pizza with an obnoxious price tag. read more

Meatball sub was good. They tasted good. One thing with the south is they can't nail to rolls. Other than that overall good.

Great NYC style place-always busy and the amount of carry out is phenomenal. Love the pizza and Im from Chicago so I am picky about my pizza. Love the varieties and you can get different slices and try a lot of different types. They have lunch special pizza, salad and drink soup specials too-Italian wedding soup! Pasta is good, flavorful sauce-the sausage and pepper are fantastic. Large Store front with outdoor seating. Pleny of parking. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Lunch pizza-Buffalo checked and white-delish! - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina

We ordered and picked up a Brooklyn 16" Pizza with 2 toppings Sat. evening. The service was good, pizza ready on time, but the pizza was terrible. The crust was tough as leather and the cheese had a texture of rubber without much taste. The toppings were $4.00 each for banana peppers and onion. So with a $3 tip this pizza cost $29.00 and not fit to eat. read more

Comes very close to actual NY pizza. Recommend this place for pizza although they have other delicious options on their menu. Our favorite pizza spot. read more

Average pizza. Calzones were barely cooked. Disappointing...at best. Just not what I was thinking it would be.

My favorite so far. Their chicken parmesan was amazing. The sauce was perfect. We got thecoffee of Angel hair pasta which many places do not offer. It is my husbands favorite. I like how they give you to go cups from the start. I had cheese tortellini Alfredo which was amazing. Their Alfredo sauce is delicious. The first time I had a calzone. This was very tough/hard/crispy but still good. I asked for a side of Alfredo and they have me a huge bowl. Great for dipping the bread in. Overall, we are planning on going back. One of our favorites. read more

See all

I rarely leave reviews but.... If you like calzones, don't ever order a calzone from here. We've been eating here since they opened, and previously their calzones were to die for. Tonight, I received a pre-prepared calzone shell that had been sliced in half, had maybe a pinch of cheese, and the toppings requested. When I pointed out that there was no cheese, I was told that I needed to pay an extra fee for the cheese. They claimed they've never changed cooks or rules and the calzones have always been this way. I probably won't come back, and I sure as heck won't ever order a "calzone". read more

hello fellow yelpers, So for a little backstory, I ate at this place one day in the fall. Later that night I had food poisoning. Anyways, I went back! No food poisoning so fat although I did feel some "gurgles" in my stomach. The workers were pretty rude. I say thank you or Have a nice day and no "Of course" or "You too"?? The pizza was okay until you were about 2/3 done with it. After that, it tasted like cardboard which was not enjoyable. The Dr. Pepper tasted so sugary and didn't even have fizz to it. Normally I would end this with a "never coming back again" but that would be a lie. I'll update you if any food was poisoned. EDIT: here I am switching from sitting on the toilet to laying on the bathroom floor at 11:00 at night. The cramps are horrible. NEVER come here. I know I said what I said but fuck this place, fuck their workers, and FUCK their food. read more

Just moved here and I was at the grocery store and ask what the best pizza place was. Someone said this place and I am starting to think it was a prank. Pizza was pretty bad and it tasted like the dough wasn't cooked all the way. read more

We've had BP over the years since they opened here and it's always hit and miss. Sometimes it has enough toppings and is cooked enough, other times it's just a doughy mess with skimpy toppings. We took a six month break from ordering their pizza and decided to give it another try. Again, an undercooked, floppy, doughy mess. Sauce tasted watered down, cheese was tasteless... Kids got garlic knots that were not cooked enough and the dipping sauce was water. Done with it. At one time it was pretty decent, but not anymore. On the search for good pizza again. read more

We have been ordering pizza from Brooklyn Pizza since they opened. It was our favorite local pizza and what we judged other pizzerias by. We would try others while traveling and wished they were even close to Brooklyn Pizza. Sadly, they have changed their cheese blend and now it's probably our least favorite pizza. We have tried it on two separate occasions with the same unappetizing results. It was good while it lasted, but we are beginning our search for another good, local NY style pizza joint. A sad goodbye to an old favorite. read more

Really great pizza and i love pizza i come here with my son named Brooklyn and order from here because the box says Brooklyn but this pizza is the best for miles and miles don't think twice just try it read more

You're 700 miles from Brooklyn, so it won't taste like you're on 86th Street. But it's good pizza and Italian dishes. The meatballs are really good! read more

Best pizza in Charlotte. Period. Great lunch specials, too. Everything we've had from here has been great, from pizza, calzones, Stromboli's to cheese steaks. read more

Ashley doesn't belong in the food industry. Love this place and the food is always good. I tried a piece of hamburger pizza. The ground beef was hard and I didn't enjoy it. Was mocked that it was only "$3" dollars for a slice and typically don't refund or exchange pizza. I was enraged to be treated like I was nothing. Some people don't have more money to spend. Customer is always right. I didn't enjoy the pizza and now I had a horrible experience with customer service . It's not rocket science and they make enough money. Full house. Won't be coming back to this location. Straight embarrassing read more

Last time here. Wife and I ordered different things. Calzone and baked ziti. Calzone came out first and was brought to table. Twenty (2-0) minutes later, wife got her baled ziti. The calzone was marginal at best. Was hoping for a large Italian style calzone...not the size of a paper plate folded in half. As for the ziti...tasted like a microwaved dinner. It had been a few years since we visited, I have to say, this will be the last. read more

Not what it used to be. The food is now not that great in tandem with price increase make this place a less likely occurrence for me every month. Wings are dry, salad is frosty, pizza is greasy (and not in the good way). Service is mediocre at best. Go take your business elsewhere. read more

This is probably the worst pizza I've ever had. I grew up in the north and after living all over the south for 8 years now I've realized that finding good pizza down here is pretty hard. I definitely dont believe anyone that works here is from Brooklyn or has even ever been to New York The crust is AWFUL. It's super chewy and tough. It's like what I would imagine eating cardboard would be like. It was bad. Next, their sausage is so unbelievable tasteless if someone would have blindfolded me and asked me what it was I would have guessed it was unseasoned ground chicken. I would have never guessed sausage. The last issue on this trash pizza is the sauce. They barely put any on. I'm not someone that likes a saucy pizza but I like to be able to at least taste it and know it's there. This was like we had asked for no sauce, they put it on because they forgot, and then scraped it off and hoped we wouldnt notice that sauce had once been on it. The cheese might be good but it's hard to tell since it's surrounded by garbage. We just moved here and my husband wanted pizza so he picked this place. We wont be back. **as I finished typing this my husband walked into the room and said "man that crust was just super chewy, like my jaw hurts! And the rest was just ehhh" this coming from a guy that loves pretty much all pizza and has said even bad pizza is good pizza. This was terrible Try somewhere else We will be. read more

This is a nice little popular pizza parlor in town everyone is friendly and its a very busy family restaurant. We tried their special ,large pizza, baked ziti and garlic knots all very good,NY Style. Everything is homemade and handmade pizzas.You order at the counter and they deliver it to your table.They also have beer and wine available. read more

See all

First time there and ordered 2 Sicilian slices. Bad idea. Looks like it was made 12 hours ago and was cold and tasted like it was made 12 hours ago. Asked to speak to the manager and Mario the cook or owner came out and started arguing that the food is not made fresh but just warmed up and that was that. The. Box the pizza went in would probably taste better. Cheese was already aging on the slice. Fool me once. Lousy customer service matches food. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Parlor - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, North Carolina