Brought both cars in a 2 spans due to my personal scheduling conflicts. Quick response to my…read moreinquiry. They are friendly and courteous team. Definitely recommend the shop and will use them in the future.

GREAT SHOP! Got my car tinted here, such a great experience! From beginning to end Kurt and Eric…read morewere so helpful and explained everything, also took a lot shorter than I expected and came out so clean. Will definitely be coming here for more! Great pricing with unmatched quality! All of the staff were extremely friendly and knowledgeable too. Waiting in the showroom was super nice, I was given complimentary water and coffee while waiting as well, definitely recommend!

Always my favorite and best mechanic! Top notch work and repairs to my CR-V. Very trustworthy.read more

I brought my vehicle here for a minor thing. The mechanic came out, repaired it in two mins and…read moredidn't even charge me. A week later i had a separate issue, more major. Dropped it off, within a couple of hours I got a call back and the gentleman told me exactly what was wrong and how much it would cost. Very reasonable. He told me it would be ready the next day. Sure enough my vehicle was ready before noon. Check out was quick and easy and they went over the work done and answered my questions. What blew me away was they washed my car and did the small touches like air freshener. The next day I got a phone call from them just to make sure everything was running right. Amazing. It feels awesome because now i have a mechanic I can trust and will take care of my vehicle right. Do the right thing and make an appointment and you will be good to go.

It's difficult to find an auto shop that you can trust and that won't try to rip you off. East…read moreSetauket Auto is different than the rest. Been taking my old beater work Honda here for years and they have been reliable, friendly and most importantly- honest. They've done all my basic maintenance, usually just brake pad, battery, inspection related. Always done in a relatively timely fashion for a fair price. Never once tried to upsell me on extra work in order to pass inspection. My most recent encounter with them, which is what really motivated me to leave this review, was especially appreciated. I don't know much about cars, but there was something a little stiff with my steering, and I thought maybe the power steering or some belt was going. Took it into East Setauket Auto and asked them to take a look at it and let me know what needed to be done. They could've told me numerous things and hit me with some multi hundred dollar charges, but instead they looked at it and honestly told me nothing was wrong with it and no work needed to be done so I picked my car up no charge. That type of honesty is priceless and will recommend this auto shop to everyone who needs one. Great people here. On top of all that the place just looks cool- convenient location in a nice area- retro, old school style office and shop, feels like going back in time in a good way.

They recently moved to 616 Main Street in Port Jefferson, I am happy to say that the same great…read moreservice is being provided at the new location behind the USA gas station. No matter the model or type of car, they have always done a great job for me at a reasonable price! Wish this family owned business the best at their new location!

This was the best experience I have ever had with getting maintenance for my car. Mark's customer…read moreservice skills are outstanding. They did a video of the work that was done on my car so I could see the work they did. They finished early and completed everything on my list. The cost was very reasonable and certainly better than I expected. My car is a 1998 model with 153,000 miles on it. They could have easily added something to the bill, but that is not the way this place does business. I can't recommend them highly enough.

George is terrific, Had to get a quick weld on my exhaust…read more. got me in and out...did not overcharge me like some other shops on Rt.112 wanted to do..

This place is excellent! This shop can handle any automotive repair or problem. They don't…read morecherry-pick what they want to repair like some shop do. They usually have three or four full-time A class technicians while other shops most of the time have only one. Excellent place if you have a problem that no one wants to help you including dealerships. One time I had a problem in 2014 with my fathers 2012 Toyota Rav4. The break pedal was soft with engine off and felt weak. I went to two Toyota dealerships since the car had a warranty and they said it was normal while I knew that there was a problem. I finally went to Middle Country Automotive. They confirmed that a break pedal can not be soft with engine off and diagnosed the problem to be ABS pump probably needed bleeding since it was probably not done at the factory. They connected the diagnostic computer and activated the ABS solenoids to bleed the trapped air in the pump. After 15 minutes the brake pedal was nice and firm. I filed a complain at NHTSA and I think it triggered a recall that Toyota hid under some other problem with the ABS pump. At Toyota dealership when I went for the recall the dealership techs only connected the computer the same way the Middle Country Automotive techs did!

They dropped my gas tank to fix a leak and put the gas tank on too tight. Which prevented the evap…read morevalve from opening and I wasn't able to fill up my gas tank. I took it back and they lowered the tank slightly so the valve could open. Not long after my check engine light came on and codes P0442 and P0446 popped up. The mechanic admitted they put the gas tank on too tight, which led to the solenoid malfunction. They offered to fix it for $500! I don't recommend anyone take their vehicle here. They have a pattern of creating more problems for their customers than solving them.

My car started to overheat out front, Will helped me push it in and diagnosed it almost instantly…read more It was later in the day on a Saturday, he called me Monday morning that it was ready. Fast and reliable. Thanks again!

Very great service and very nice people. cars go in get fixed properly and are out. well deserved 5…read morestars. They are very thorough, and know what they're doing and how to do it.

I went with a friend who recommended them. We drove up and Artie took my car in immediately. My ac…read morehad been blowing warm air, so I was worried that it was the compressor= very expensive. Artie did a few tests, told me immediately it wasn't and just need a charge of freon. 10 minutes later, I was done and charged me very little, and even recommended a windshield place, because I had a very large crack. Delgado Glass In turn gave me a great deal on my windshield. Thank you Artie, I will be back, and Artie is the owner!

I first learned of Artie's shop from my son in 2013 as he said he was fair and had great prices…read more My son had purchased an old Toyota and and needed to make sure it was in top shape for his 8 hour drive back to college. Since I've referred my daughters car, mother's car, and a friends car. I take both of my cars. He is fast with diagnosis, completion and has decent prices. He will let you know if something else should be repaired, but will also indicate whether it's an immediate need or not.

I've know Mike for almost 20 years and he's been fixing cars as long as I've known him. Does great…read morework at fair and reasonable prices. I highly recommend him.

I was driving out an hour from My house to an appointment in…read moreEast Setauket. when my engine shield started to fall off and drag . Luckily I pulled into Smitty's garage and he got his guys to quickly hoist it up,remove it and place in my car trunk to explain To my service shop back home. All done under 15 Min, at no cost. Just a great owner and great experience. "Salt of the earth" . I would switch to this garage if I lived closer.

Smitty's Garage for the win!…read more My Corvette place was jammed up with work, they couldn't squeeze me in before my trip to Carlisle. A few car guys on social media said to try Smitty's garage. I went to garage and spoke with Will. I told him this Corvette is my baby, treat it with love. I was traveling and he said leave it with us, I have a good Chevy mechanic. I came back, the valve cover gaskets were installed and I was road worthy. Mind you, his shop is busy with summer auto problems, I'm thankful he was able to get me zoomin'. The big question is, why do they get 5 stars? When they changed the valve cover gaskets, they took the time to clean off the residue oil that splattered out. It's that attention to detail that gets noticed. I need a steering part, he said he'd order it but haven't heard back. I'm typing this review from the Port Jeff ferry, we're all busy! I'll hit him up when I return, I would use this garage again because they did a great job on my Chevy