This place is an absolute GEM. It's always clean . The owner is always front and center. Most of…read moreall the staff is helpful and personable. Great selection of wine. They've upgraded the whiskey selection and are competing with the surrounding businesses. I'll spend my time and money in a great establishment over some of the other stores nearby, anytime. Highly recommend this place if you're looking for options and staff that knows your name.

the best winer in the wold, i'm like . I highly recommend .. on this site, everything is available…read moreand complete, all premium drinks whose quality is guaranteed.d...

My first visit in years to Commack Liquors. It was apparent to me once I entered the stores that…read morethe ownership had changed. Also, I did not recall that they had such narrow aisles. There were three people working in the store and two of them were at the sales counter. Not once while I was in their store did anyone ask me if I needed any assistance. I was searching for a specific Scotch and did not realize that behind the counter they also had another section of scotch. So one would say the store has plenty of inventory, but not necessarily organized the way one could find it easily.

Just ran in to this store on my way home from work. Woman at register was on the phone on a call…read moreon speakerphone. Didn't say a word to me. No hello, no thank you, no have a nice day! Just carried on with her conversation. Awful service and quite dirty. Go elsewhere if you can

Very helpful and great selections. Prices for holidays were…read moreexcellent If you need help in selecting the type or cost of a bottle of wine the service is great

Bought a bottle, went to the store for pickup and the owner…read morerefused to give me what i paid for saying they don't carry that bottle. Meanwhile it's on the shelves at a higher price so he didn't honor the price i bought it for already, cancelled the order and effectively walked away. if that's your kind of customer service youll love this place!

Like the owner's attitude, he's very forward with the customer and helpful honestly I don't know…read morewhy people are hating on him. Was looking for single malt he recommended spice tree, for the price it's not to bad

Whoever gave this place more than 1 star must be their family or friends. This place does not…read moredeserve any stars, I wish I could give zero! Very rude and very disrespectful! I was being treated like a thief for taking a picture of an expensive bottle that was locked in a glass!

I travel extensively for work, which means I've stepped foot in countless bottle shops across the…read morecountry. I recently revisited this location under its new ownership, and the difference is night and day. They are truly changing the game. The IPA selection is world-class, featuring everything from fresh, local hazy cans to hard-to-find West Coast doubles. It's clear the new team has a curated eye for quality and freshness. What really set the experience apart, though, was the service. The person working was incredibly pleasant and accommodating, helping me navigate the new arrivals and ensuring I found exactly what I was looking for. It's rare to find that level of genuine hospitality and product knowledge combined. If you're a craft beer enthusiast or just passing through town, do yourself a favor and stop in. The new era of this store is polished, professional, and easily one of the best spots I've found on the road. I'll definitely be making this a permanent stop on my travel circuit!

Had not been here in years. Stopped in to get a cold seltzer. Young bearded person behind the…read morecounter couldn't even say hello.

Small selection but carries most of average brands. Fairly…read morepriced merchandise . Parking is easy and location is ok

Store hours need to be updated. Drove here for nothing it was closed and needed some Tekilaread more

The best part about Jai's is it's 4 doors away from Trader Joe's in Commack. Other than that, it is…read morevery basic and the owners are very rude and unfriendly. Very disappointing when you need wine guidance and they are very unwilling to help. Just okay on the wine selection and prices are more than my local wine stores in Huntington but less than NYC.

The owner is as mean as mean can be. Have a question in the store? Grumbles and points, If you…read morecall with a question he'll give you a quick answer and hang up on you before you can get another question in. And if you try calling back, he wont pick up! Speaks terrible english. Thought I got someone from a third world country when I called. Take your money elsewhere.

AVOID AT ALL COST PRICE GOUGING Pros- NONE…read moreCons: PRICE Short review... they rip you off harder than a gas station. I was picking up Truly for a party. 2 12 packs cost 45 bucks. So were talking more than 2 dollars a truly? I was disgusted by the price and inquired, he told me "every guy is coming in looking for these, so yeah that is the price." So this place admits to price gouging. DONT GO HERE AND DONT SUPPORT THIS BS PRACTICE. If you're in the area go literally anywhere else for your beverage.

They just lost a number of customers as I work in the area and have told all of my coworkers that…read morethis business has caved into the pressure to "pick a side" regarding if black lives matter or not. This company has declared in store and over the phone in so many words that they do not matter. There are other beverage distributors that sell Montauk beverages that our company will be utilizing moving forward.

So glad they were open on Christmas and a tiny detour off the LIE. Super friendly staff greeted me…read moreand the selection had everything I needed. Thank you!

Beginning to think this is a scam business. Placed an order for delivery on April 19 and ever since…read morethey all I got is them saying it shipped, even though UPS tracking number shows they never got the package from them. Still no package and now not answering the phone.