The cakes I purchased for my son's 1st birthday were perfect! We took in a photo of monster cakes I…read morefound on Pinterest. The cakes I received looked exactly like the photo & they tasted amazing. I was surprised to find the strawberry cake actually had real strawberry pieces inside. I received many compliments on the look & taste of the cake at my son's birthday party. If I could have a complaint, my only one would be price, because they were definitely out of my price range, had we not still had our tax money at the time we would not have been able to afford them. But, they were way overbooked with cakes & still squeezed ours in on only a week's notice so I was very appreciative of everything they did to get my cakes to us on time.

I sent Maggie several pictures of cakes I found on Pinterest with an explanation of what I liked…read moreabout each. She took that and created the perfect cake! Everything about this cake exceeded my expectations. It was gorgeous, moist, and flavorful. Everyone at my son's birthday party was impressed.

I had a change in schedule and was not able to make it to Murray, KY for my son's birthday. So, I…read morecalled The Cake Lady at 1:00 p.m. on Saturday afternoon for a special last minute request (they closed at 2:00 p.m.)... any chance they could deliver a cake! I was amazed and so happy - not only did they have an extra cake available, they decorated it and delivered it to him on campus the same day! That is going way above and beyond a customer's request. It's hard enough when your "child" is away at college and you miss his birthday for the first time but The Cake Lady truly made me not feel as bad! He was so surprised, and I could tell a little excited, too! : ) Thank you for amazing customer service - so hard to find these days! Tina W

From the owner: Proudly serving Western Kentucky since 2013…read more We specialize in custom order cakes, cupcakes and cookies offering a wide selection of desserts. Catering is available big or small.

Jan has been in business for 30 years. I grew up watching her make cake after cake. She spends…read morecountless hours perfecting her creations. I should know...I was the little girl years ago, napping under the table while she worked. I'm her daughter. I have watched her research creative projects to achieve the best results for brides. I've watched her sacrifice so much to make sure that things are perfect and the special day for her customer is perfect. She truly cares. She is truly talented. She is truly meticulous. As a bonus, I will give you the inside scoop....her kitchen is spotless. She always aces the health department eval. I am a germaphobe because of her. She takes cleanliness and health safety extremely seriously. You will be in good hands with her as your cake maker. Not only do her creations exhibit artistry that is unsurpassed, but everything tastes delicious. Her cake is a favorite among many people that I know. Her recipes are secret. She has learned the art and science of baking. It is her craft and she excels. She has countless flavors of cupcakes with the aroma and texture that will send your taste buds to another realm. If you want the best of the best, have Jan do it!

This local bakery is a great all around bakery. Very well priced and tasty treats. The only…read moredownfall is they don't offer gluten free products. Other than that, they are awesome. Staff are friendly and are always willing to help!

Some of the best donuts I've ever had. Friendly staff a must stop if in Greenville, KY.read more

Best bakery in Newburgh! Quality ingredients, delicious treats, always fresh. Pair that with…read moreoutstanding service and you have a fan for life!!!

Desserts here are absolutely amazing! They have done 2 special occasion cakes for us as well and…read moreeveryone LOVED them. Highly recommended if you are looking for a quick treat or need something for your event.

Emily is not only kind, but she is a true visionary when it comes to cakes and cookies! She is…read moreprofessional, Timely, and just all-around a great Businesswoman! We have ordered cookies from her for a housewarming gift, and didn't have a clue as to what to get. Well it was Emily to the rescue! She had the idea to do cookies in the shape of keys, and also a front door with a wreath on it!! Since I'm not very creative, she was able to just put it ALL together (even the colors!) for me just right off the bat!! They couldn't have been more adorable, and everyone loved their sugar cookies; I felt like the hero all night, and I didn't even do anything but buy them, haha! We'd also gotten a simple cake from Emily a couple years ago for my friend's first birthday party. It was only about 10 people, so my friend didn't want anything over-the-top; she just wanted a really small cake that would be cute for pics. My friend's dad had passed away right before this, and he was a fireman, so Emily created the perfect little cake, designed perfectly for her little guy. On top of that, it was chocolate and delicious!! We've also gotten her holiday cookies-- she sells out SUPER quickly, so make sure you place an order in time! We missed out one year because we waited until the last minute. They're the cutest things I've ever seen!! We will ALWAYS be patronizing Emily, and we feel lucky to have our "own dessert chef" from now on! (Haha, sounds silly, but Emily has made us feel like family! ) I'm going to come back to add pics / edit if I can.. I don't have them toward the front of my phone and it could take hours to find them, but I will eventually!! Thank you Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes- you've made our lives so much sweeter!!

Emily created a sweet table for my wedding this past year, August of 2015, and she did such an…read moreamazing job! She did my best friend's wedding as well, both themes very different, but both turned out amazing! She was such a pleasure to work with. We kept in touch throughout my planning process and she easily made adjustments, and worked with our budget! My sweet table consisted of customized sugar cookies, cake pops, and lemon bars, as well as other assorted candies to tie in with my pastel color theme (light blue, pale pink, and peach). She supplied everything! Cake stands, candy jars, scoopers etc! It turned out wonderful! My guests still rave about the cake pops! I highly recommend her!

Ordered a 3 tier wedding cake. The bottom and top layers of the cake were supposed to be butter…read morepecan with pecans in the cake and in the cream cheese icing that was between the cake layers. The middle layer was to be chocolate with the same cream cheese icing with pecans. The outside of the entire cake was to be done using cream cheese icing. The rosettes on the bottom layer were to be done in royal blue. The second layer had the simple royal blue ribbon we had given her to use for the color preparation. The top layer was supposed to be polka dots using the royal blue color. The cakes were set up on tiers and she was to use white roses between the 2 spaces and a couple on the top layer. So, the cake turned out all butter pecan with no added pecans in the cake or in the icing that was between the layers. The rosettes were play-doh blue and looked like an amateur had made them. The top layer had what appeared to be a little darker blue color, but looked like candy dots pressed into the frosting. Finally, the white roses that were to decorate between the layers were fake. They looked like the cheapest she could find, or maybe she pulled them out of an old vase from her home. She was supposed to set up the cake and was given another $20 to do so. She left the plastic wrap on the entire cake. Guests arrived to see that mess. I contacted her via PM on her business FB page. She assured me that this is what was ordered. I told her that me, and the the bride and groom were all there when it was ordered and I am certain she was told all of the above "supposed to be," information. She stated that that was not true. I told her to review her order and then get back with me. About 20 minutes later, she sent me a picture of some order form that she must have just rewritten. She said that that was the original order form. This just proved to me that she is a dishonest person. At that point, I knew there was no reasoning with her. If she is willing to rewrite a cake order, then that was that. In my opinion, she should have accepted and owned up to the fact that she did not make the cake correctly and that it looked very generic. We paid $324 for something we could have gotten at Wal-Mart for half of the cost and it probably would have been made correctly and been prettier. I thought that she should have stepped up and apologized and offered something to make up for it, i.e.: make a birthday cake in the future for free or refunded us half the cost of the cake. She didn't even try to make us happy. I don't think she is an upstanding business woman. I think her business is good for cakes that you would normally buy in a grocery store and she does have great cupcakes, but for something formal, I would never order from her again and I would definitely never recommend her to anyone. P.S. I rated her a 3 star because the cake tasted really good.

Ordered a 3 tier wedding cake. The bottom and top layers of the cake were supposed to be butter…read morepecan with pecans in the cake and in the cream cheese icing that was between the cake layers. The middle layer was to be chocolate with the same cream cheese icing with pecans. The outside of the entire cake was to be done using cream cheese icing. The rosettes on the bottom layer were to be done in royal blue. The second layer had the simple royal blue ribbon we had given her to use for the color preparation. The top layer was supposed to be polka dots using the royal blue color. The cakes were set up on tiers and she was to use white roses between the 2 spaces and a couple on the top layer. So, the cake turned out all butter pecan with no added pecans in the cake or in the icing that was between the layers. The rosettes were play-doh blue and looked like an amateur had made them. The top layer had what appeared to be a little darker blue color, but looked like candy dots pressed into the frosting. Finally, the white roses that were to decorate between the layers were fake. They looked like the cheapest she could find, or maybe she pulled them out of an old vase from her home. She was supposed to set up the cake and was given another $20 to do so. She left the plastic wrap on the entire cake. Guests arrived to see that mess. I contacted her via PM on her business FB page. She assured me that this is what was ordered. I told her that me, and the the bride and groom were all there when it was ordered and I am certain she was told all of the above "supposed to be," information. She stated that that was not true. I told her to review her order and then get back with me. About 20 minutes later, she sent me a picture of some order form that she must have just rewritten. She said that that was the original order form. This just proved to me that she is a dishonest person. At that point, I knew there was no reasoning with her. If she is willing to rewrite a cake order, then that was that. In my opinion, she should have accepted and owned up to the fact that she did not make the cake correctly and that it looked very generic. We paid $324 for something we could have gotten at Wal-Mart for half of the cost and it probably would have been made correctly and been prettier. I thought that she should have stepped up and apologized and offered something to make up for it, i.e.: make a birthday cake in the future for free or refunded us half the cost of the cake. She didn't even try to make us happy. I don't think she is an upstanding business woman. I think her business is good for cakes that you would normally buy in a grocery store and she does have great cupcakes, but for something formal, I would never order from her again and I would definitely never recommend her to anyone.

Unsafe structures in the kids play area with zero accountability or care from the owner herself…read moreafter my child got injured. Very cute aesthetically, very poor functionality as a safe play for littles. Poor morals around not caring and trying to shift blame as to why a child. Do not take your kids here if you're looking for a place they can run around and play safely, I would go elsewhere.

I got a mocha there, it was good but also tasted a bit more like a latte, the chocolate was not…read moreobvious. What surprised me most and why I gave the lower review score was the price of the specialty lattes for the month. Two different sizes, the cheapest smallest one on the menu was $7 and the largest most expensive was $10.50. That's literally insane. The most expensive one does come with a mini macaroon on top so I assume they are very fancy lattes, but still. No way I'm paying for that.

Working with Sarah Roberts was super easy and she has a pretty simple process to get your orders…read morein. She does not have any limits to what she can create. For our wedding, we ordered 70 parfaits in 4 assorted flavors that were absolutely phenomenal. She even created some for us prior to the wedding for us to have a tasting of what to expect. We booked with her a year in advanced, and we found this to be ideal to plan ahead. All parfaits were ready at the time she said they were going to be. She does deliver for a fee, but we opted to have someone pick them up instead since it didn't make sense to us to have it delivered. Everyone's needs are different. What we ordered and the quality of the product matched. She was really nice to allow us to pay over time for our items instead of one installment as well. She works with you and understands that everyone has different needs. If I ever have a need to use her again, there is no question about it - I will definitely be reaching out.

I contacted Sarah to make a 90th birthday cake for my mom. I was able to send her a link to the…read morerose gold party decorations that I ordered off of Amazon and she was able to make the cake match perfectly. She actually made two cakes...one was the number nine and the other was the number zero. We selected chocolate and white for the flavors. Let me tell you, it turned out amazing and my mom was so surprised she cried. Everyone said it was the most delicious cake they had ever tasted. You won't be disappointed if you order from Sarah! I'd give her a rating of 10 if I could.