We had a bit of time to kill on our way to Siena from Florence so we stopped here on our way to the…read morecastle located right above this restaurant. We actually didn't know we'd end up finding this gem. I originally thought we would park our car at the bottom and hike up to the castle, but as it turns out you can park up there. So before going up, we had a meal here. What a great find. Such a gem. Truly. As we weren't that hungry, we just had their house red and 2 plates of pasta. I knew I was going to love Siena after that first bite. Wow. Seriously the best I'd had. Even the bacon tasted better. Their dishes were so simple, but the taste was out of this world. Even the house red was out of this world. Viva Italia.

The host at our bed & breakfast (who happens to be an extraordinary chef and lifelong local to the…read morearea) suggested this place and it did not disappoint! Delicious food. Try the sampler, so you can taste 3 different pastas. We ordered whatever the waitress recommended. Amatriciana was our favorite, but they were all excellent (others were Cacio Pepe and Wild Boar Ragu). This place is no fuss, simple high quality food. Even the Parmesan cheese on our table was excellent (which I suppose is no surprise in Italy!)

Stopped here since it had a decent crowd and the food the customers were enjoying looked good…read more The outdoor seating was great and had a nice view of the church and the coming and going of the tourists. I had a spritz and a sandwich. The spritz was good and the sandwich was decent. Service was solid and it was a good experience overall.

Service the best! Food amazing. We are here 3 times in one week just because of the friendly…read moreservice and good food. Great location right across from the church so you could see everything. The Two sisters that own this have the best personality. We live in California so we don't live close but if we did we would go back.

Excellent cocktail list, traditional San Francisco inspired speakeasy. Hidden gem. Extremely rare…read moreand unexpected in Tuscan wine country. Thank you for giving us spirit drinkers something to look forward to in Tuscany while our wives prance through vineyards.

Fantastic service, great wine selection, delicious pecorino. The view can't be beat, either. A…read moresuper find in sleepy Pienza.

We've been very fortunate to have been able to travel to Tuscany on a number of occasions. Pienza…read moreand Il Casello have become regular stops for us. We always have a drink before dinner (usually at nearby Latte di Luna), sitting outside, taking in the view of the incomparable Val D'Orcia and talking to the friendly patrons of the bar. Staff is hospitable and the memories are indelible.

An all around amazing place. Extremely friendly and helpful staff/service. The food was top notch…read moreand you can watch the chef work her magic if seated outside. We split the Fiorentina steak for our main course and it was heavenly. The chef's attention to detail on all dishes was excellent and the house Chianti was delicious to top it all off. Highly recommend this place if you're nearby, it's not to be missed!

Small osteria in town. Service is excellent. Food is fresh and good. German beer on tap and a full…read morebar. And coffee of course. You cannot go wrong with this quaint little place. They have gluten free options and were very accommodating. Stop in for a bite on the patio.

Glad we found this hidden gem. Great place! Ambiance, price, and food. The sandwich bread is…read moreclassic rustic. Delicious

Nice place. Great views in and on balcony if you can get out there (2 tables). Nothing fancy solid…read morebar. Bartender super nice and helpful !

This restaurant is incredible! Great food! Every dish was an incredible dining experience, even…read morefried chicken. We have been six times in the last year. Lunch and dinner are wonderful.. Their service is attentive, very professional. And ...they have a great wine list. This is a local favorite so make a reservation! High energy and great music. Do not pass up your chance for a great dining experience!!

Wonderful food last night. Terrific team work together to provide a great experience. Love the Jazz…read moreposters and art here and throughout the town.

I was desperate and needed to eat something other than pasta and pizza! I walked by this place and…read moreordered the fries and burger. If you're American, don't expect a normal burger. It has all the components that goes in a burger but it doesn't exactly taste like what we would expect. The service was spectacular and they give you ICE! The coke cans are larger then everything I've gotten in the past 9days! They give you a can with 500ml! Overall it was a fine experience and i really needed something other than pasta.

We searched out a laundromat to wash clothes and spied this tiny hideaway right across the street…read more Super friendly owner served us very good Chianti while we did the wash. The interior is gorgeous with a barrel vaults brick ceiling and a hidden wine cave below (you can view it through a glass floor). Bonus points if you can find the oversized unicorn Chianti bottle!