this was my second time coming to Bagwell Mathis Automotive. I can not emphasize how happy I am with their services! Madison and Melissa are friendly and helpful and awesome! Bart, my new mechanic, was fast and thourough i went in with a leaking power steering fluid issue and requested a brakes check because the brakes just didn't feel right. I let them know that I will be traveling on Saturday and time was of the essence. My tundra was diagnosed in 20 min complete with a video and personal walk around to show me! From start to finish: in and out in 9 hours... had to wait for the rack and pinion til morning ! incredible! All work, including brakes and rotors at lightening speed! Thank you guys! Personal, Professional and Fair Pricing! THIS is how it's done!! Tracy Parris Client for Life read more

Very fair prices for my brakes. No wait time. Knowledgeable technicians. Gave us a ride home so we could leave the car. Friendly.

excellent service! great price for quality product and service! I will always buy my tires here going forward!

I took my Honda Pilot to Bagwell Mathis Automotive in Cumming, Georgia for tire rotation and balance. Just afterward there was a slight pull to the left. I took it back in to see if the balancing somehow caused the pull. I was told that to correct the pull I would need to spend $690.73 to replace the break pads and rotators and calipers. I was also told that the vehicle was unsafe to drive on a seven hour vacation that our family as planning. I got a second opinion from an auto repair shop that I've been using for years and trust completely. They told me that none of the work Bagwell quoted me needed to be done. They made a minor adjustment that corrected the pull at no cost to me. We drove this car on our vacation with no problems at all. Mr. Bagwell and Mathis spent decades building this business based on goodwill and integrity. Sadly, from my experience, these qualities have not been carried over by the new owner. Metz H. read more

Marty and his team of guys did an exceptional job taking care of my situation. He even stayed after closing to make sure I got back on the road the same day. Good attitudes, friendly service, honest assessments and someone I feel I can trust. read more

I have been here twice. First in 2021 for 4 new tires and alignment. I returned yesterday. My tire air pressure sensor kept going off. I went to Discount Tires to have the air pressure checked, and they said the air pressure was fine, but I needed to have the front two tires changed within the next month. This was quite confusing because they appeared to be in good condition. They said the interior of the tires was too worn. I went to Bagwell because I felt I trusted this business more. They suggested to re-align the tires to allow some more wear, and the tires had more than a month left. To add I had a tire added a few months ago at Discount Tires so It needed to be re-aligned. Bagwell was able to re-align, balance, and rotate in one hour, and I was a walk-in. The two men at the desk were very helpful and nice. Overall great customer service. I will return for future tires. My auto shop Corey's recommended this business to me. read more

Super friendly and fast... highly recommended!!! Worst situation: flat tire and spare tire broken, too. And now I'm back on the road.

We just moved to Cumming recently and found these guys on Yelp. They quickly fixed my tire which had a carriage bolt in it! Then I had them work on my brakes and test out my tire sensors to see if they were working properly. All in all, they help fix everything and turn my old rotors for future use. I highly recommend! Very friendly service and reasonable prices. I'll be taking my Jeep there later on to help with a caliper locking up. I'm very happy to find such a honest local small business in the area. read more

These guys are the best! I've picked up two nails in the past six months and both times they were able to repair the tire in minutes! I won't consider buying tires anywhere else! read more

Very happy with service and friendly environment. Guys working fast and neat. Definitely I'll comeback again!!

Awesome experience here. Had to get a flat tire replaced, and their quote came in way below other shops. They ordered the tire for me in the morning, it came in that afternoon and I was in and out really quickly. Will definitely be returning and referring business to them read more

I have been getting my tires from this place for the last 14 years there's no one better to have to deal with than the guys that work here it locally owned and are always honest about what they can do for you and never tac on extra "problems " just to get more out of you. They aren't always cheaper than the big name shops, sometimes they are but it's the hometown business that makes you wanna deal with them. They are fast and curtious and go the extra mile for you. read more

I got two new tires today. Service was very courteous. I called ahead, and they had the tires ready when I arrived. Installation was surprisingly quick. I'm very pleased. read more

My trusted and long-time mechanic at Corey's Auto Service in Cumming told me a month ago that it was time to start thinking about replacing the tires on my Old Man Mobile, a Ford Crown Vic. My mind reeled at the thought of waiting in a circus-like atmosphere as persons wanting to sell me more, more, more approached with the tag line, "Mr. George, let's step out here and go over a few things we recommend..." I am not picky about many things, but the mechanical condition of my vehicles is something I do care about deeply. That's why ONLY trustworthy Corey's handles all the maintenance and repairs, and, if they say all's well, then all's well. So, when a tire place tells me that now is a good time to back flush my transmission, etc., I make a sickly smile and say, "Definitely NO!" So, I asked Bruce, one of the owners of Corey's where he gets his tires. That's how I ended up at Bagwell and Mathis. I'd previously thought B&W was closed, because it appears empty from the street. Turns out you have to enter one of the two drives, and go to the 'rear' of the building to find the 'front'. This place has been in business since 1947 (and so have I), and the current orientation of the building is not the way it was in the beginning. However, savvy locals know that this is the place to go. I requested a quote from their website first, just to see what's up. They offer Michelin, BFG, Hankook, Toyo, Mastercraft and other manufacturer's lines. In my case, I previously had Michelins which had carried the OMM for 11 years and 75000 miles without a bobble. I wanted to have great dry and wet traction and long wear without the premium price for more Michelins. The only highway miles OMM sees are occasional jaunts down 400 or on 285 for a few miles or an annual run to Clayton. For extended trips, I rent a mini-van. Given all that, Tony quoted me $509.08 drive-out for 4 Mastercraft tires. What, no alignment? He said my existing tires wore true, so no need. I came in with my quote in hand and left 30 minutes later, riding my new treads. Outstanding!!!! read more

Hands down THE BEST tire place in Cumming! Our family has been going here for years for tires, rotate / balance / alignment. These are good guys who don't try to upsell you. And they have ALWAYS comes in cheaper than the discount tire places! The tires here are good and not the 2nds that you will find in the discount places. We trust them, they are honest, and service is quick but professional. Don't waste money at the discount places. Go to Bagwell & Mathis. read more

I have been doing business with these guys since 1975---hands down, the best in the business---over the years, many of my friends & co-workers started going there also---never any problems or issues---I now live in FL and when I need tires, I will make the 300 mile trip to see them just for that reason---David Hawkins read more

I had been taking all of my vehicles here for several years without any real incident and then today - 8/23/13 - someone who was changing out the tires on my car stole the flash drive that was plugged in to my cd player! The flash drive was not that expensive or anything but had sentimental value and about 4 GB of my favorite music stored on it - which I listened to every time that I get into the car - so I know for a fact that it was there when I arrived and was gone after I left. I didn't notice that it was missing until shortly after I had left and then I called the manager to report it.. He immediately became defensive and denied the fact that there was any possibility that any of his employees would have stolen it! He didn't even bother to ask me anything about the flash drive or how I knew that it had to be someone there that took it - all he said was that there was no way it could ever happen.. So, not only did someone steal my personal property, but the manager - who had been more than happy receiving my business - refused to even look into the incident for himself and claimed that it didn't occur!! So, if you do decide to take your business here, I would at least make sure that all of your personal belongings are removed FIRST!! read more