Bagel Time

Best barbq in town. We love the real country store vibe. The pastrami Reuben sandwich is our…read morefavorite item. Breakfast 24/7. Authentic made to order homemade food. Great casual going out evenings in a country location.

If you're a regular at the Edenville Deli, I wanted to show you true color of Debbie…read more I'd suggest giving it a miss. Debbie, the owner, responded to a request for a day off from the lady who works there. She's just a 17-year-old high school student, a minor. She's sometimes worked a 16-hour shift for Debbie and has never asked for a day off before. This kind of behavior and response is really concerning and seems a bit extreme. She's such a great kid, a very hard worker, and it's clear she's not going back to work there.

Smoked chicken nachos

See all

RAIN! RAIN! Customers are loving having a sandwich, a cold beer, and watching the rain come down.

Larry's Deli

2.8(27 reviews)

1.6 mi

I have been a patron for many years. Never a disappointed…read morevisit. Today I stopped on my way home for a sandwich. Yummy. Fair and reasonable price Well made Fresh meat and Kaiser roll Awesome Thank you for always being friendly and professional and accommodating service May be in an older builder yet bright and clean They accept cash and credit cards They also sell lottery tickets if that is your liking Strongly recommend

Stopped in for a couple sandwiches. The sandwiches were small but good. They had hot food…read moreavailable. I think I paid $18 for the 2 sandwiches on rolls.

Italian sub

See all

The Cracked Pot

4.9(9 reviews)

4.1 mi

Food was good and tasted made with love! Happy vibes in this, family- owned, local, hot spot.read more

My wife and I were in Warwick visiting a relative in a nursing home. He asked us to pick him up a…read moredeli sandwich for treat. We stopped by chance at The Cracked Pot. Everything was awesome. It is a classic Deli with a huge selection. My wife had a turkey Reuben. I had the all the way Smashburger and we picked up a chicken Parm sandwich on a roll for our relative. This place has a great selection and prepares all in a great presentation. Try it. You'll love it. PS we picked up two frozen soups which we had for lunch the next day. They were homemade, delicious and it made our life a little easier.

See all

Bellvale Market

3.8(37 reviews)

3.7 mi

Really nice quality overall. We love their lobster rolls…read moretho we were asked to order two because they had to make them up specially for us a bit out of season. It's not for the financially challenged. In Warwick I'd say the best fish in miles around here. Best place to purchase a picnic or special freshly made deli items in our town. Except for the venerable Quaker Creek way over on Pine Island.

This is a gem in the neighborhood. Like a good old Italian deli that offers a lot! If you don't…read morewant to cook, they have lots prepared food, as well as frozen to take home. It's also like the local meat and fish market. They carry a bunch of Italian brand food items from abroad. They also carry Jane's ice cream and other specialty items. Stop in and check out this tiny little market.

The Italian Crema we purchased from Bellvale Market

See all

Pine Island Market

5.0(1 review)

3.0 mi

Best sandwiches around. You can also get lottery tickets and scratch off, a few groceries, etc…read more Great service, can't say enough, wonderful family run it.

Country Grocery

4.7(6 reviews)

4.5 mi

Came upon this unassuming little deli/butcher and convenience store by chance in Greenwood Lake,…read morewhich I would've totally overlooked if not for Yelp. It was just the place to pick up a sandwich along the way. Look at this magnificent Italian combo sandwich I got for $12! The owner is very nice with a chill energy.

Nassim is a charming person and caters as if he was catering to a family member or best friend. He…read morehas quality meats, cold cuts, bread, and diners. He's well known for his hoagies. It's a little store that you can find almost anything you need and if it's not there he will order it for you for your next visit.

Deli case

Massive Italian combo sandwich

See all

Weekly special! Only $5.99 for fried chicken, fries, and 12oz soda!! Chicken is super tasty.

C & D's Old World Bagels

3.4(48 reviews)

1.6 mi

Put in an order got home opened home fries container and it looked like half eaten disgusting home…read morefries that they probably picked up from the garbage can . I was literally disgusted . Even top of container was dirty with oil . And also in America we don't put green peppers and red peppers in home fries got my money back and never again

Food was great, the bagels and wrap were filled with plenty of meat and cheese... not just bagel…read moreand barely any filling. The service was great, the girl at the counter really tried her best to make sure we were happy! A little warm inside but we still sat down and ate, tables outside would absolutely benefit them!

Home fries

Hometown taste with Old World Value

See all

Egg and cheese on a roll

Sunoco

4.0(9 reviews)

2.1 mi

This place is a ripoff. Their pumps are rigged to keep going when your tank is full spilling gas…read moreeverywhere. The attendant didn't care or do anything to help. He never came out to take care of the spilled gas and it was all over! Avoid this place!

Normally would never eat "gas station grub" but I was starving and pressed for time... I went in…read moreand figured it was a good sign they were so busy. Ordered a turkey BLT on a wrap...figured it was a safe bet. 2 hours later I was doubled over...puking and diarrhea. No more gas station grub for me

Four Brother's Pizzeria

3.7(55 reviews)

4.7 mi

This is our go-to place when in Greenwood Lake. We usually order heros. Both the meatball and the…read morechicken parm are excellent. Nice size hero. Have ordered individual slices all have been good. Today ordered the sausage, broccoli rabe and fettuccinie in garlic and oil. It was excellent. Good quality sweet sausage, tender broccoli rabe (generous amount) in a flavorful oil sauce. Fettuccinie was light and tasted like fresh pasta. Ordered a medium sized Margherita pizza. LOTS of cheese (too much for my taste), but...it was way toooo salty. I couldn't eat it. My husband likes salt so taking it home. He agreed tooo salty. Mentioned it to the waitress and she said they use a different tomato sauce for the Margherita. Maybe that was it. Never had that problem with their regular pizza slices. Just a heads up. Garlic bread was tasty. Lovely outdoor area to enjoy. Beautiful flowers and plants. Very pleasant to sit outside.

Hit or miss. One night the margherita pizza was the bomb and the next night ordering the hero…read moresandwich was terrible along with the soggy fries. Their pizza sauce is great.. I'd say stick with that and you'll be happy! Easy pickup and friendly service.

Pepperoni Roll. Burnt. Again.

Pepperoni Roll. Burnt.

See all

Chicken Marsala and Chicken Francese slices.

G's Warwick Diner

3.1(141 reviews)

1.8 mi

We ended up stopping in here for lunch on a whim and we're glad we did. The food was tasty and the…read moreatmosphere was very "local diner"... casual and comfortable. We enjoyed our lunch very much and it was a good start to visiting this town we had never been to.

We were having trouble finding food in town (everywhere is small or needs reservations) and we…read morefound the diner. Food was delicious and came out fast. I had lox benedict with home fries and a cold brew. This diner doesn't look like your average diner, it fits the cozy town. The booths are comfortable, but not too spacious. Our group of 6 got a big space so they can accommodate that if you need it. Service was great, the food came out fast but the actual servers were not around much (when they were around they did a great job and made sure everyone was happy) I can't blame them though, it is so busy (and that's a good sign). I do recommend they check on the bathrooms better, It was dirty and there was no toilet paper.

Breakfast!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Monica M.

0

20

0

9 years ago

Best bagels around! Coffee is delicious too!

Bagel Time - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Bagel Time also viewed

Jessie's Bagels

3.1

(57 reviews)

Strange. Very strange. Two times in a row…read more Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a roll and the Taylor ham burned to a crisp. How is that possible?

Flavor is there but the quality is poor. All the sandwiches only had 1 egg and 1 piece of meat. I…read morethink I speak for most consumers when I say we want a sandwich that is filling. When compared to other bagel shops, this one does not perform close enough to make me want to come back. Charge an extra dollar and put more meat on them things! Such a beautifully renovated building with such potential if only the food was more appealing and filling. Staff was great, very pleasant!

Bagel Town Cafe

3.6

(46 reviews)

Not fancy but the food's the best! Delicious bagels, bialys. Cold cuts. Staff is helpful and…read morefriendly. Drive thru also! Love it!

Recently the bagels ( baker dozen) I bought were chewy and tough as if the bagels were stale. I'm…read morehoping the owner corrects this issue quickly as it was very disappointing. Perhaps he should sample the bagels before selling them!

Pine Island Bagel and Deli

3.7

(3 reviews)

delicious bagels, they added some more breakfast options which are so yum!! wrap options available…read morefor gluten free people which is really helpful

Came for a quick bagel on the go. Woman taking my order was very rude while helping me and went…read moreinto the next guest before I finished. I don't think they make their bagels here. There was a vat of premade bacon sitting behind the counter. The place is relatively clean with places to sit but no customer-accessible garbage cans inside the establishment aside from the bathroom? Will not be returning due to the staff.

The Bagel Corner & Cafe

4.5

(135 reviews)

The food was delicious, the service was excellent! The…read morepeople behind the counter and in the kitchen are the very nicest you can meet and make such food. I highly recommend stopping in.

Good bagel breakfast options look and taste good not expensive attentive staff quick serviceread more

Goldberg Famous Bagels

3.4

(38 reviews)

Bagels are great. Staff is welcoming and friendly. Best…read morebagels around. Just ordered 7 dozen to bring down to GA. Order was made fresh and ready in time.

Great service, food was fresh and delivered fast. I was surprised when I saw that my order was…read moreexactly what I stated to the dude who took my order and didn't write anything down. Checked off all of the boxes so I consider that a score. So much so that I'm typing up a delicious review as I destroy my breakfast that I ordered

Q&S Convenience Food Store

3.3

(8 reviews)

Great service and food. I've never been disappointed. Ordered everything from breakfast sandwiches…read moreto subs and burritos. They even have the cheapest tobacco and tubes.

I stop here every morning for a sandwich and every drink .. and sometimes on the way home for some…read morefries or a sandwich. The people are ALWAYS so kind and make nice conversation. They also have fair prices which says a lot considering all other surrounding spots are wayyyy overpriced. Not newly renovated on the inside but still clean and functioning.. High recommend !!

Bagel Train

4.2

(245 reviews)

Excellent bagels! (As mentioned by other folks, consider on-street parking to avoid the crowded…read moreparking lot)

I saw it on a side of the road, unassuming looking, but kids were hungry, and me too. So went for…read moreit. The crowd inside made me suspect its gonna be good. Bagels looked giant and had larger variety than any other place outside nyc. I got Philly cheese steak, and kids got chicken cutlet deluxe. My sandwich is good, lacking seasoning as in salt n pepper but I ve notice lately all places stopped seasoning unless you specifically ask for it. Maybe if you're over 40 they automatically withheld salt? French fries are bit on a soft side and greasy. Overall great place, if I ever pass by here again I d try their bagels for sure. P.s. Just tried jids chicken cutlet, its to die for. So good. Soggy salad is forgiven for how tender n moist it is.

The Bagel Tree North

3.1

(23 reviews)

Man, this is why I love traveling so much! We are in NJ/NY this weekend and I have been…read moreanticipating the coffee and bagels. Despite our best efforts in NC, it just isn't the same. As luck would have it, right next door to our motel was The Bagel Tree. Upon entering, you are immediately hit with the overwhelming aromas of steaming bagels and really good coffee. If you weren't that hungry or thirsty before, you are now. There is a plethora of bagels to choose from ("Would you say I have a plethora of bagels?" "Oh yes El Guapo, you have a plethora"...haha, damn that was a good movie...) I decided to go for the tried and true bedrock of the bagel world, an Everything Bagel. A sausage egg and cheese everything bagel sandwich to be more precise. Absolutely delicious. Couldn't be any more of what I wanted. Bagel just completely crusted with toppings! And using whatever North Eastern magic, just about every speck of them stays on the bagel while you eat it! Utterly fascinating and enjoyable. Sausage was probably the same pre-made, frozen disc every place uses, eggs were actually real and cooked on a flat top, the cheese was some non-descript version of Kraft singles that was all melty and gooey - again, exactly everything you could want out of a bagel sandwich. The coffee was Lacas brand. Never heard of it before now, but it was really good. I am, admittedly, a bit of a coffee snob. I have the good fortune to have spent quite a bit of time in Europe and I have been to Central & South America a dozen times, so I feel like I have enough worldly coffee experience to express an educated opinion: Lacas Coffee, pretty darn good. And it's self serve at The Bagel Tree, so you can personalize it however you want! Awesome The service was fine. I'm a tourist, not a regular, so I can't say whether or not it's improved or declined. There were about 8 dudes from a tree service company already in the store when I rolled in, and it took less than 6min to order, get my coffee and then walk out with my bagel. I'm not complaining. I'm really looking forward to trying other bagel shops in the area, especially ones in NY, but if I was only able to go to The Bagel Tree this trip, I wouldn't be disappointed at all. If you're ever in the area, give it a try!

This place as gone down hill. This time upon getting to the front door I was met with a miserable…read morewoman who before saying hello or anything said "you can not come in with that dog" I explained he was a service animal and she then replied "you can't come in with the dog" I repeated he was a service animal and she then asked me for documents. which is not allowed to be requested. I typically do have his card but had been traveling and didn't have it. This woman was rude out of the gate and broke many ADA laws... educate yourself. you cannot ask for any documents, ID cards, certificates, training records, or a special vest for a service dog none of that is required or requestable under federal law. If it's not obvious what the dog does (e.g., it's not visibly guiding someone or pulling a wheelchair), staff are limited to asking just two questions: (1) is the dog a service animal required because of a disability, and (2) what task has it been trained to perform. They cannot ask about the person's diagnosis or disability itself. get it together it is 2026

Cafe e Dolci

4.2

(119 reviews)

Took my boyfriend here for his birthday breakfast and we enjoyed very bit of it! The food was hot…read moreand flavorful, everything was made quick and the service was super nice! The ambiance in here is so relaxing, they even had a cute little fire place and book shelf! We didn't get to see but it also looked like they had a second floor! I'm also very picky with my coffee and it was made to perfection I didn't need to add any extra sugar, plus they had free water. It was such a phenomenal first time experience and we both thoroughly can't wait to come again!

A busy cafe on a cuteeeeee little main street with friendly baristas (and dog friendly). A great…read morespot! I love that they have a couple of tables outside even though there isn't too much space. The beautiful day that it was, it was nice to be able to sit for a bit before continuing on the walk. There are plenty of tables inside, and even looked like there was an upstairs. I got a latte and my fiance grabbed just a hot black coffee. My latte was delicious! Perfectly hot and strong. Unfortunately the black coffee came out pretty cold. Things happen and I am very sure it would have been no big deal to go in and ask the very nice baristas for a new cup, but we were already on our way. Not a big deal and I'm positive it was just a one off. A lovely space that we'll venture back to on our next trip through Warwick.

The Naked Bagel

3.9

(111 reviews)