Athena's food is consistently great. Besides a chicken platter for 2 sandwiches today. Chicken salad and egg salad. Massive and delicious. You can't go wrong with Athena. Also can place your order online and designate what time you want to pick up. Very convenient. Highly recommend read more

I was looking forward to trying this place because it appears to have been in business awhile with good ratings. Nice, cozy, casual place. Seems to have a lot of regulars dropping by for carry-out orders. Service was excellent - very nice people. Reasonable prices, but portions are fairly small. Ordered the "best chicken in town", - the chickens are very small, and the 1/4 chicken breast I had was noticeably dry. The seasonings and flavor are very good though. But I have much better from any Peruvian chicken place. Had the zucchini in tomato sauce as one side an it was outstanding. Pasta salad was average. Pita bread seemed dry. Hummus was very good. Potatoes had great flavor but also a little dry. Rice pudding dessert was very tasty. Overall I was disappointed because I had hoped this might become a go-to spot for me to hit regularly but unfortunately I cannot imagine a scenario where I'd make the effort to go back. read more

A great local, no-frills spot with tender rotisserie chicken and a menu of Greek/Mediterranean options. Had the 1/2 chicken with Greek potatoes and green beans. The pita was a bit dry for my liking, but the potatoes had that amazing lemony flavor I love from Greek restaurants. I'd probably get hummus next time to have a "sauce"/dip option for the chicken. I'll definitely have to try their chicken and rice (avgolemono) soup and the dolmades on my next visit! A lot of locals and take out orders, and the staff seemed to know many of the regulars which is always great to see. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - 1/2 chicken with Greek potatoes and green beans - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

Came here for a lunch with coworkers and was pleasantly surprised. I had never been here before or even heard of it but it was pretty decent. I ordered a chicken gyro wrap and they stuffed it to the brim! The flavor of the chicken was great, the pita was soft and fluffy, and the toppings (especially the sauce) were really good. You order at the register and then they call your name/number once your order is ready. The food was ready quickly and the staff was nice. There is a ton of seating inside and even at peak lunch time, there was a lot of availability. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Chicken Gyro - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

Ive been eating at Athena Chicken for nearly 30 years. I just love this place. It's a simple, casual Greek restaurant slinging rotisserie chicken seven days a week. The restaurant space is filled with pictures of local friends, families, and events, combined with Greek landscapes and spaces. Order at the counter, listen for your number, and grab your delicious chicken. The staff is always happy to serve and help the newbies decide on what's best. They have all the classics - gyros, Greek salad with potato salad, and rotisserie chicken platters. The sides are my favorite like the roasted potatoes or pasta salad. My go-to order is the half chicken platter, potatoes, and green beans. Pro tip - The kabob special of Wednesdays is the best deal, but you gotta get there quick! It tends to run out. read more

See all

Five stars for flavor, price and speed! I love coming to grab a quick lunch at Athena's and have frequented it for the last decade or so. The BBQ chicken Pita and the zesty feta chicken pita are my go-tos! I also love their Mediterranean salad and regular gyros as well. I also just love how affordable and quick this is for lunch and super filling. I will comment that The service is not what stands out here - after all it is a walk up counter to order so my interactions are limited. As far as the ambiance goes, this isn't that kind of place and will feel a little chaotic; But this is exactly what I expect out of this type of restaurant. The lunch line can get quite long, they're hollering out order numbers and dine-in is a paper plate and plastic. So set expectations accordingly. Looking forward to my next lunch here. YUM! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Zesty Feta With Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

I have not been to Athena's in a SUPER long time (like 25 years) and I really don't know why because we used to come here all the time! The food js just as good as I remember ... and my palate has grown up a bit so things I would not try before I was excited to try now. Like the rice wrapped in grape leaves. The pita with hummus was excellent! The olives are soaked in wine and you can taste that delicious wine let me tell you. Soooooo good. The kids meal is a great size and my ten year old DEVOURS every bite. The chicken just falls apart it's so tender and perfectly seasoned. The Greek salad is big and the interesting thing about is the smear of potato salad on the bottom. I like that. I will be running back to Athena way sooner than 25 years I can tell you that. (Also what a great testimony to be around for so long... you know that food is good) read more

See all

I'm shocked I've never rated Athena. It's an old-time Winter-Park-area staple and it deserves its slot. Been there over the years and eaten many a good lunch--(delicious chicken, stuffed grape leaves, spanakopita). Today I had the special which was grilled tilapia with olive oil and garlic and I will say that it was probably the best tilapia i've ever had and I was not expecting that. My friend didn't like the "texture" of the potatoes so I ate all of hers in addition to mine. They are not like the roast potatoes you get everywhere else--they have lemon and they grow on you until you dream about them at night. Trust me on this. Is their baklava great? No. But that little carrot cake thing was delicious and the coffee was quite decent! This is basically a diner--seating inside and out, casual and easy. Great place to have in town. read more

Yummy! I had a quarter chicken, potatoes, and rice. Wish I would've taken a picture, but was too hungry

I've known about this restaurant for years. They advertise themselves as the Best Chicken in Town. I finally decided to stop in for lunch with some coworkers. The dining space is a little small but obviously popular because it was packed. I was impressed right away with the menu options and variety they offered. I asked the employee working the counter what the most popular options were. Based on her feedback i choose the quarter chicken, roasted potatoes, and green beans. The food was good at a good price. I left feeling satisfied and health conscious. My coworkers all got wraps or pitas and were all equally impressed and satisfied. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

I love this food! Always fresh and delicious. The staff is always warm and welcoming. And the dining room is practically a Maitland museum. I get here about as often as I physically can. read more

See all

I was so hungry I don't get to take a pic of the food but it was magnificent. Probably one of the best value meals for what you can get in Maitland. I almost want to gate keep this place it's just that good, but wouldn't want to be rude to my fellow yelpers! I tried the quarter chicken with potato salad. The chicken itself was so juicy, not overly salty tasting by any means which you might typically get in a rotisserie chicken form. Crispy skin. Chefs kiss. My only regret is not getting the half chicken so I could have more! read more

After a long day, I was heading home and craving some good rotisserie chicken. Of course, I had to stop at Athena Chicken--the best in town! Their rotisserie chicken is always juicy, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. It was exactly what I needed for a quick, satisfying meal. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Outside - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

See all

I ordered from Athena Roasted Chicken because I've heard great reviews. The order was a good temperature when delivered and I was impressed with the amount of food that I recieved -- great value! Everything was delicious, except for the chicken, which was dry. I added the chicken to a soup though and it was delicious. Would definitely order again! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

I've wanted to try this spot for months so I finally got the chance over the weekend. The vibe wasn't what I expected at all! I was thinking more new- school Greek food with a rotisserie twist, but found it to be southern old-school with a confused mixture of good food. The chicken gyro was good. Although the seasoning on the grilled chicken wasn't the best. However, the lamb gyro was really good. It hit the spot. The hummus on the side was fresh and tasted good, but I'm not sure the $2-3 up charge was worth the small scoop. We definitely want to try the rotisserie chicken next time. Hopefully the service is also better next time. read more

I love athenas. When I say I love this place, I'm not kidding. I used to work next door and would frequent the establishment 2-3x per week because their dark 1/4 chicken was cheap, but also delicious. Now, I deliberately drive over because I have a taste for it and am never disappointed. Everytime I pop in, it's usually during lunch. Their establishment is busy and bustling with people both sitting inside to eat and ordering take-out. I've had the 1/4 dark chicken almost everytime and the seasoning is to die for. The hummus is freshly made and the pita is warmed as well. The rice pudding reminds me of childhood and if it's available, It's always a to go for me. I look forward to continuing to support this place for years to come! read more

I almost don't want to post this because I'd love to keep it a secret, but Athena's Roasted Chicken is a true hidden gem in Orlando! Especially if you like soup like me! The chicken is perfectly seasoned with crispy skin and super juicy inside. You can taste the quality and care in every bite. The sides are just as good and feel homemade, not like an afterthought. Portions are generous but back to the soup! Yum! The chicken lemon soup will heal your soul. It's low key, no hype, just really solid food. If you know, you know. I'll definitely be back. read more

Chicken was delicious. Hummus and tabouli so so fresh!! Quick - reasonable price. Can't wait to eat my Greek salad. It looks amazing too! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

We did to-go and they prepared our order so quickly. We ordered two lamb gyros and everything about it was amazing.

Athena is a staple around Maitland. Classic locally owned Greek restaurant with a great chicken meal. I got the roasted chicken and a couple sides my 1st time. They have the chicken ready to go, so it makes coming for lunch a breeze. My last visit, I had the chicken Gyro and I loved that. Hot, fresh and authentic. You know it's going to be a good place when 90% of the restaurant is over the age of 60 directly after opening, you know that crowd is picky and won't eat just anywhere ;). Service was fast and efficient, you order a the counter and pick it up at the counter. I will continue to come back here!! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

We saw this restaurant when checking out the nearby Lazy Moon Pizza. This restaurant is more like a deli in that it only offers counter service and has no waitstaff. A lot of people seem to be ordering food from here for delivery because we saw a steady stream of pickups while we dined in. The food was meh at best and nothing anyone in our party would go back again for. The mousaka was not very well seasoned and tasted like reheated two-day old leftovers. The gyro was ok but there was little meat to salad" ratio. A far better option is the Mediterranean deli on Fairbanks. The roast chicken was ok, the Greek potatoes were not great and the zucchini with tomatoes was also ok. The feta dip with grilled pita was the highlight of our dinner but not worth returning for. read more

See all

The whole "best chicken" statement might be very accurate. It's definitely up there in flavor and taste and texture of rotisserie chicken. Quick service, I only got chicken and a side of pita so I cannot comment on the other items on the menu but everything looked good. Overall no lies were told in the comments about the chicken. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Entrance - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

See all

We had Athena Roasted Chicken catered for a work event and it was deeeelicious! If it weren't for this being catered for our lunch, I would've never got to try Athena's and I would've been missing out. We had a sandwich platter with a variety of sandwiches (cut in quarters), another platter with tabouli, hummus, feta, olives, and another one of spanakopita. This was my first time having spanakopita and my life is forever changed. Also, I'd like to thank the ethnic platter for single-handedly changing my mind about olives. I used to think I didn't like them but not I know, I love kalamata olives!! All the food was so filling yet light and also full of flavor. So grateful we had this to fuel us for a full day of work! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Spinach Pie - Spanakapita - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

See all

We catered in Athena ahead of a work event and WOW! We got a platter of different quarter cut sandwiches, pickles, a platter of hummus & pita with olives and feta, and a platter of spanakopita. The spanakopita was some of the best I've ever had - so flaky and buttery, but still light too! The chicken salad and egg salad sammies were delish, I didn't try the turkey/cheese one (or maybe it was ham? Not too sure!) The hummus and pita were delicious and I kept going back for more. This was the perfect lunch to pick at throughout the afternoon and everything was super super yummy! If it was that good as a bulk catered order, I can only imagine how tasty it is dining in! read more

Delicious Mediterranean food. Really enjoyed the gyro salad. Lots of options if you need gluten or dairy free. Chicken, gyro meat, many salads, dolmades are all GF. If you have dietary restrictions, definitely recommend. Prices are great too! read more

I have been to this plaza before, but didn't even know this was here until seeing it recently on Yelp! It's very unassuming, the inside isn't fancy but definitely gives a family-owned vibe. I loved seeing the family pictures and drawings on the wall. The prices are really inexpensive, and the food was ready so quickly! I ordered the lamb and beef gyro and my fiancé ordered the chicken platter. Both were good but I really loved my gyro... maybe it reminded me of my time in Greece. The pita and hummus were good too, next time I would probably order more sides. Overall would definitely recommend if you're looking for a fast, easy, and cheap meal! The staff were super friendly too. read more

See all

No photos but it was so delicious! I hate that in all my years of coming to Maitland I haven't tried this place. On a whim before going to the Maitland Art and History Museum we stopped by. Busy with both takeout and dine in you order at the counter and pick up at the other end. It was hard to decide what to get because it all looked good and the chicken smelled great! In the end we both got a 1/4 white roasted chicken with a small Greek salad. Pita or roll came with and definitely have to go with the pita! Chicken was moist and deliciously seasoned. The Greek salad was just as I like it--potato salad on the bottom of the bowl and everything super fresh. Large feta and tangy peppers and Kalamata olives. Seasoned with herbs and a simple oil and vinegar dressing on the side. There's a full complement of sides to have with your chicken but also a variety of sandwiches both hot and cold. I'd like to try a gyro next time but it may be hard to move away from the chicken! read more

Amazing! Simply delish! No frills but they don't need it this was an amazing experience

I was impressed with how fresh everything tasted. I had the quinoa and arugula salad with roasted veggies and a light citrus dressing. The veggies were still warm and seasoned well. The arugula gave it a bit of a peppery kick which I liked. Portion was just right not too small, not overwhelming. The staff was really helpful with suggestions. I left feeling full but not heavy, which was perfect. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

Still frequent Athena's when Im in the plaza (I get my nails done a few doors down) we live in Mount Dora so not as often as Id like. I love the zesty chicken pita! So fresh with a little zip of spice and feta. Delish! I always bring home their chicken salad, its the best in the game. Must try! read more

Their food is very good and fresh. Because of this they are very busy. I like most everything including the Avolemeo soup and their Greek potatoes. Of course, their main meal is the baked chicken. You can take out or eat in. The staff is always helpful. Prices are fair. John T read more

Delicious roast chicken with a Greek flare! This business has been open for a long time in Orlando and it shows it with some of its charming decor. It's counter service but they're quick to get the chicken and sides out to you. Definitely gets busy during lunchtime so get there early! read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

See all

So delicious. Loved the zucchini as a side dish and the chicken is perfection when you want an alternate to fried

I didn't realize this business was here but quickly found out it has quite a following for good reason. I ordered the quarter chicken platter with dark meat, green beans, and rice pilaf. My husband ordered the roast chicken gyro with potato salad. We were so impressed with the quality and flavors of the simple meals. The crispy skin was a delight and the potato salad was exactly how my husband hoped it would be. Normally he goes for traditional gyro meat, but because chicken is a specialty of their's, he gave it a try and found it was the best chicken gyro he's had. We also got to try the baklava which was sweet and flakey. I was especially pleased that the dessert wasn't too firm and could be split up with a fork. The service was quick and the location has a nice outside patio with plenty of seating inside and out. I noticed they do takeout, so I might try that on my next visit. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Chicken Platter with Green Beans & Rice Pilaf Chicken Gyro with Potato Salad Baklava - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

Excellent chicken! Flavorful and reminds me of the home-made style I like and enjoy. Service is always kind and professional. Ambiance is comfortable, casual, and always clean. Small little outdoor area is a nice reprieve from the busy indoor space. We enjoy coming here for a fresh and delicious meal when I don't feel like cooking! read more

This family owned business is amazing! The restaurant is located in a nice neighborhood! I walked in and was greeted by family staff and the place is cozy and planets sitting areas and even has some outdoor sitting too! I have ordered gyro on pita with zucchini and hummus an d rice pudding! My son got the gyro on puta with roasted potatoes to go! The food are yummy and full of favors! Have to go back and try the roasted chicken sometime soon! read more

See all

I was in the area and my family and I decided to visit since half of us got into the Yelp elite event for their specials. First off , the celebration was for the 35years of being a great franchise with delicious food items. They are a hidden gem in the wall featuring roasted chicken with delicious things of Greek spices! They were very friendly , gave us our order within 10 mins and friendly staff all around. Ambiance was a bit more quiet, but I believe that it is a hole in the wall that not many customers recognize. I personally ordered the Chicken Gyro and it was delicious with a mixture of Pico, onions,and of course grilled chicken with this white yogurt sauce. It was delicious and definitely was enough to satisfy me. Parking was a bit challenging because of how small the parking lot was, but we found some additional spaces in the back. We really enjoyed this spot and appreciate Yelp for giving them a shout out because they definitely were worth the drive and it is delicious. I hope to be back soon to taste all their other menu items. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Chicken Gyro - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

I had high hopes for this place. Unfortunately, it did not meet my expectation level. Nothing was bad, just not outstanding. I went with a group of managers for lunch, I had heard great things about the chicken and Greek potatoes. Turns out that no one had been there in many years so no one really knew what to expect honestly. When we left we are all like, it was ok ... Just not wow. We probably won't go back again simply because it's a little out of the way and not spectacular, just mediocre. Kinda disappointed though .... Really wanted our experience to be top notch. But try it for yourself and see what you think. It could be that I have the worst tastebuds in central Florida and I'm dead wrong. read more

Great food. Service fast. The ambiance was nice except for the three guys talking about all the ways the could ripe off the government. read more

Athena Roasted Chicken - Chicken Platter with coleslaw and green beans - Greek Near Me - Maitland, Florida

5 Stars for great lunch, but also a fantastic catering experience! I've been a fan of Athena Roasted Chicken for many years and have eaten lunch there (or takeout) on various occasions. This time though, I was needing to cater lunch for 15 people and was stoked that Athena had catering info (with prices) clear and available on their website menu. I ordered the assorted sandwich platter (serves 15-20 and costs $65), the ethnic platter (including tabouli, hummus, feta, olives, pita- costing $75), and the spanakopita ($65/tray for approx 20 people). The assorted sandwich platter was perfect and the fillings were plentiful. The spanakopita was a big winner with the attendees and it was hot and right out of the oven! The ethnic platter was huge and filled with fresh goodies- I saw tons of folks mixing the hummus and tabouli and I continued to get great feedback. Overall, I'm always happy to spend money locally and this family-owned biz deserves all the love. Special shout-out to Jeremy, the manager, who walked the fresh baked spanakopita to my car and made sure everything was well packed to make it to the final destination. read more