Love Good Things…read more Over the past few months, I have consigned dozens of items here. The staff are competent, professional and kind--I absolutely adore every single person including the owner, and especially Gita. As both a seller and a buyer, the prices are extremely fair and the endless supply of beautiful objects (with high turnover) keep me reinvesting all my earnings back into the store. I highly recommend consigning items here, or browsing the aisles for gorgeous, unique items in lieu of mass produced, lower quality modern equivalents. You will leave happy every time.

I brought items in to consign a few weeks ago. I had done this before with a good experience and I…read morelike this store. Wow was I shocked at Gita's rudeness, impatience & general unpleasantness! I had dealt with him before & found him pleasant so this completely took me off guard. He was brusque, condescending I would have stormed out after he kept repeating himself & trying to educate me on the inferiority of my items except said items were spread out over a table & trolley. Impossible to escape! Fire this guy, he is arrogant & unprofessional!

Brought in some of my mothers antiques to sell (as well as do a little shopping!). I thought the…read moregroup would be worth a couple hunderd at the most - something my mother would have been very happy with. The owners gave me quite the shock when they informed me that a box of old cameras had one in it that was worth twice what I was asking for the card load I brought in! I admit that I had shopped around to two other vintage stores before visiting this one and , while I was treated very nicely at the other shops, the offers I recieved were less than half of what I first though my mothers items were worth. What I really appreciated about my experience with Everything Old was that they were transparent about what my Mom's things were really worth and ended up buying most of what I brought in for more than what I was asking for everything! I like that they are clear, ethical and humble. I also appreciated the excitement they showed over some of the cameras - so refreshing!

I had previously really liked this store although it is a bit higher priced in comparison to some…read moreother island antique stores - and it has really a great selection of items. But on my birthday August 2023 I treated myself to a reproduction horse statue that I later realised I was way overcharged for, as in, I paid $250 and the item is all over ebay for as low as $30. I won't go back there and gave the item away as I didn't even want to look at it anymore. I had regrets at the time even for paying so much for an item I couldn't afford, but now realising I can't even sell it and get my money back is a real disapointment.

My husband and I have been buying jewellery from Stephen Fortner Goldsmith for over 30 years. He is…read moreour go-to person for all things shiny n gold! Stephen has made many rings, necklaces, earrings for us over the years and we continue to use his skills and creativity to design new pieces and redesign old ones. Stephen is kind, thoughtful and honest and listens to your needs and ideas.

I have been buying from Stephen for 22 years since we commissioned our engagement and wedding rings…read morefrom him. His quality of design, work and eye are superb. Today we bought an exquisite sapphire and diamonds ring he created from scratch after choosing the sapphire in Thailand. Stephen travels, shops and chooses the best. We are very lucky to know him!

Great little, local consignment shop tucked away by Thrifty's and Spinnakers. Love the reasonable…read moreprices. Have not sold anything here, but do love to shop it. Huge selection of china and tea cups, silver, antique items, home and kitchen items, art, etc. Good place to find classy and/or quirky gifts. Friendly service.

Super nice staff, great variety of goods all super clean and beautifully displayed! Very helpful…read morestaff always make sure your purchased items work properly, fit well and are in good condition. And great background music will leave you happily humming while you browse!

We have bought lots of quality furniture from Porter's Wood Furniture over the years. Our guests…read moreare always quick to compliment the various pieces we have throughout our home. The staff is always helpful and the service is always exceptional. Thanks for being our go-to furniture store!!

From start to finish this company provided first class service with attention to details and made…read moreme feel like they wanted and appreciated my business . In a world where customer service always appears on the mission statement but is primarily ignored when the customer is shopping , they were a breath of fresh air . This included the final delivery and set-up by their delivery team . Thanks to everyone . I would say I will be back for my next bedroom suite , however at 83 I may not be able to honor that commitment .

Fabulous consignment shop, super friendly staff...the best selection of quality items. Perfect in…read moreevery way. You won't find a better household consignment shop. A must visit shop.

This is a wonderfully stocked consignment store. The owner has a great eye and accepts high…read morequality diverse items to sell in the store. I have consigned my clothing there with great success. The sad thing is- I often spend my earnings gathering more of her great finds. Friendly service in a well put together high quality store. I would highly recommend that this be one of your regular go to spots. You do need to stop in regularly as the stock changes often with more great items all of the time. Donna

Lovely people working and volunteering there. Always some…read morewonderful finds. I donate and also buy regularly. Rarely leaving empty handed. 100% recommended!

I have been shopping at Community Closet with one of my girlfriends for almost a year now, and we…read moreboth have enjoyed our shopping experiences very much. The volunteers who staff the shop are wonderful, and the many varied items are always beautifully clean and affordable. A relaxing way to shop. Thank you!

We dropped in here and looked around the little shop filled with collectibles and old things. Fun…read morestuff and the prices looked reasonable compared to similar shops. Great location in a small shopping area called Cook St Village. Word is, this a good shop with some unique pieces.

karen has a real speciality in knowing what to buy for her clients Lovely display of curated itemsread more