The pizza was delicious and was recommended by some coworkers. If you're in the area definitely check it out! read more

Angelo’s Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookville, Pennsylvania

We live in California but hit up Angelo's every time we are in the area. Love it. Perfect combo of crust to toppings and a really good crust at that. One of my Top 5 pizza places anywhere. Strong work guys! read more

Stopped by here during a road trip and got a large cheese pizza. VERY good! Little thicker than New York style but very similar crisp/texture. Sauce is on the sweeter side but it works. Staff is friendly. No frills interior. Would love to visit again. read more

Angelo’s Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookville, Pennsylvania

My kids and I stopped for a bite on our trip to Cleveland. The steak sandwiches were served on hearty bread with a delicious sauce that we HAD to dip our fries into! The ham sub had a balanced vinaigrette and the chicken tenders and fries were piping hot and delicious! If we lived closer, this would be our GO TO place! Miss Mary checked the weather and told us to be safe on our trip. What more could you ask for. read more

It's been 2 years since we were last in Brookville, Pa. We had to stop at Angelo's Pizza. It was great 2 years ago, and it's still great today! Love the crispy crust and the pizza is cooked to perfection. We also tried their Onion Rings which were also tasty. The Andes Candy Brownie was fabulous. Thanks Angelo's ! read more

See all

I grew up with this pizza and even after moving away, it still remains my favorite. The pizza crust has a delicious flavor and is crisp. The sauce has a nice slightly sweet flavor, but my favorite will always be the white pizza which is garlicky and so good. My mom is a fan of the fried mushrooms, whereas I'm partial to the fried ravioli. The restaurant itself has only a small seating area, but service is quick. I usually grab pizza to go and bring it back for the family. The staff has always been friendly every time I've been in there. read more

See all

They have little children running around unsupervised; the food is horrible got sick everytime tried there food! Would not recommend to anyone read more

Best pizza and subs in Brookville. The pizza rivals big city quality. Bread for subs is outstanding. The baked Spicy Italian is my favorite. Staff is always kind. Nice small town pizza shop vibe inside. read more

We visited for the first time today, due to the reviews Angelo's received on yelp.com. Gotta say it was a disappointing experience. I doubt that the thick and crunchy pizza crust is handmade, it tasted like a frozen. The flavor of the pizza itself was not bad, but the texture of the crust detracted from it. Don't think we'll be returning. read more

Best pizza in Brookville! Their strombolis, pasta, and bread is all super delicious too.

The sandwiches - oh, sweet lord, the sandwiches. They are insanely good. Freshly baked bread! I'm from New Jersey. I know subs; subs are a way of life where I'm from. So when I tell you that Angelo's in obscure Brookville makes some of the best subs I've ever had, please understand the magnitude of what I'm saying. The subs are offered on the menu as "cold" or "baked". Get them baked. read more

Great place for pizza and sandwiches! The fries raviolis and mushrooms are amazing!!!

Great place! Clean, bright, friendly. Enjoyed a hot sub, very tasty and lots of food. Recommend! read more

Stopped at angeles on our way back to pittsburgh, and was pretty happy we did. This place is less than 5 minutes off of route 80. We both had the baked spicy Italian hoagie, and it was really quite good. I recommend adding banana peppers. This is an "order at the counter" place and they bring your food to you. I'm guessing most of their business is takeout/delivery. The buns for the hoagies are fresh baked and they're made from the pizza dough as far as I can tell. While the crust is pretty crispy, it isn't overly so. The bun would easily hold up if you went with a meatball or chicken parm. read more

Angelo’s Pizza - Spicy Italian hoagie. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Brookville, Pennsylvania

OMG! Get off the highway!! Take a detour! Spend the extra time! Just GO! The pizza is great! The baked Italian sub is TO DIE FOR!!!!!!! ...... It's the bread!! The meat and cheese is baked inside then lettuce, Tom, onion, oil and vinager Is added (optional). The vinager is not too strong and adds just the right amount of zing to make the whole thing PERFECT! In fact I'm delaying my trip waiting for them to open so I can get another before heading home several states away. Well what are you doing still here? You won't regret it. read more

This is my go-to place in Brookville. I can't remember the last time I had their pizza, but I know it's good. What I go for is their subs! Get it baked! Delicious, football shaped sandwiches in their homemade bread. Can't go wrong with the pizza or anything else for that matter, you can watch them toss and make the pizza from your table. read more

Angelo’s Pizza - Baked Italian sub - Pizza Near Me - Brookville, Pennsylvania

AVOID THIS PLACE! The "Italian" sub is ONE SUPER THIN slice of ham and 2 thinner slices of salami slices on the worst pizza dough I've ever had to gnaw on, hands down! This guy who says he's from NJ is full of shit. Look at the photos. We also had an eggplant parm sub, which seemed to be green and half rotted zucchini mush on the same crappy dough. I seriously almost puked when I tasted it. I really think I'm going to call the board of health. The owner should be ashamed and hide himself in a cave somewhere, seriously! NO excuse! NOTE TO OWNER: Make a deal with a local bakery to buy high quality Italian bread and put some meat on it! Your profits are in volume and soft drinks, not selling crappy sandwiches no one will buy... and for cryin' out loud, learn to make eggplant parm,, with fresh eggplant, or take that slop off the menu! I would be ashamed to have my name on that place with what you serve! read more

Angelos pizza is truly talked about in awe by people as far away as Akron Ohio, i once stopped to rent a car there, and when they heard i was from Brookville Their first response was. Is Angelo's still there? When you go to Angelo's. You will truly get freshly made Italian food at its best, prepared (and hand tossed) right in front of your eyes. The food is superb, the taste is all Italy, and if you haven't been there, you really need to go! read more

Very good friendly service. Was greeted upon arrival very clean . Food was great homade bread was delicious. Salads we're crammed in a smaller container but it was very good. Try this place out. Authentic Italian style. read more

Awesome subs and salads. Absolutely love the Chicken Parm, Baked Italian, and Sausage Parm! The bread here is the best. My wife likes the small loaf of bread that comes with the salads. We travel 25 min to eat here and it is so worth it!! My wife used to work in Brookville and she would bring home food from here every week!! read more

Truckers: drop your trailer and bobtail down to Angelo's for some of the best pizza you can find. There is room in the alley to park. I travel all around America and I can tell you Angelo's is better than 95% of the pizza I've had. The crust was crisp and flavorful, the sauce and cheese were also good. I like a little provolone so it'd be nice if they offered a four cheese option or something. As for the spicy Italian sub: Most reviewers loved them and one guy hated it, so I had to try one. The meats are top quality and it was on the tastiest ciabatta bread I've ever had. Personally, I prefer an Italian style bread for a sub; ciabatta is heavier than standard sub rolls so I think that is why it got a negative review. The place was clean, employees were friendly, and most important the men's room was clean. My Aunt Georgina always said to check out the restroom before eating in a new place. "The same mentality that cleans the restroom cleans the kitchen. If the restroom is filthy, you don't want what comes out of the kitchen." I'll be back (and I don't say that too often). read more

Gollll-ly. Can't speak to the quality of the pie, but those sandwiches are crazy good. Must be that bread. Don't know what it is or where they get it, but that's the best sandwich bread in history. Can't beat one of Angelo's Italian subs. read more

Disappointed in the taste of his sauce in his Chicken Park Sandwich. I guess. I'm wired differently than the previous reviewers. Less sweet, more garlic and a pinch of salt. Bread was also fair at best. read more

A favorite when we're in town for pizza and sandwiches! The secret to the sandwich bread and pizza dough is that they make it themselves. Definitely the best local pizza around. read more

Placed order (as we do at least once a week, usually more), told be unfriendly worker that it would be delivered in 45 minutes. Wait 1 hour 15 minutes, call to ask if they forgot about it, talked to same unfriendly employee....she said it had just left. This was at 6:40. Delivery man finally showed up 15 minutes later (we live two blocks from the restaurant) said, "Sorry they were really busy, I haven't had many deliveries, but the ovens are full." So we sit down to eat and everything is COLD (1 1/2 hours after order place for delivery in a town of 3000 people). I call them, same unfriendly employee gives me attitude. So I get it my car and take them one of the items from our order - cold. I ask if the owner is in, his son says he isn't and gives me attitude and makes it seem like there's nothing wrong with my food that is 50° F. No apology, just rudeness. I will never eat there again. In this little town they are one of two eateries that deliver. From now on I will just order from Fox's Pizza Den. Oh, and when I went to the restaurant with the cold food to complain....there were two tables of two people each in the little restaurant. Not busy at all. And the owner's kid had the nerve to blame it on the amount of orders. Our credit card was run through at 6:40 (one hour and ten minutes after the order - pretty much at the same time that we first called to see where our food was at). Also, our kids' pizza looked like it had been dropped on the floor. There was cheese and sauce on the bottom and the cheese was all messed up on top. This is an extreme case, but Angelos has all their food delivered in a semi-truck. The owner might be Italian, but the food is cafeteria grade Sysco-type factory food. From now on, when my wife and I don't want to cook, we'll simply order from the other 15 restaurants in our interstate exit town and go pick up the food or order from Fox's. It's nice to have food delivered, but when you get served cold crap and have to deal with employees with no personality and no customer service skills, it's just easier to drive to Burger King and have your food and be eating it in 10 minutes. read more

Great place for a pizza! We stopped off I-80 based on The Yelp review and ordered a medium pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was very good and I have have pizza all over the US. Good ingredients cheese, sauce and toppings. Crust as good as well maybe a little on the crustier side. The two of us had dinner for less and twenty bucks and enjoyed every bite. I would definitely make the short drive off the highway if I was ever in the area again. read more

I'm a New Yorker, so I know pizza! I stopped in here on a road trip, and ordered the pizza sub. It hit the spot; really great bread and sauce. Plus, the girl behind the counter was super cute - admittedly not really relevant to a Yelp review, but I felt like sharing! read more

They bake fresh pizza dough to use as rolls for their subs. I had the chicken special, which is a crispy chicken sandwich. It was excellent. My wife and kids had a simple cheese pizza. Again, excellent dough, with quite a bit of oregano in the sauce. Nice job guys! read more

I agree totally with other reviews that describe how delicious the sub sandwiches are. I had the spicy Italian and it was so good I came back two days later for another one. The restaurant is family run and folks are friendly and nice. read more

Stopped here on the way back from Michigan to New Jersey. The chicken parm was great and the bread was awesome. The staff was great and let my kids watch as they made pizzas. read more

Had grilled chicken salad & turkey sub. Cheese was fresh and wonderful ..salad was just yummy! Bread on sub was like a pizza crust. Like no other bread we have had. Secret recipe . Great job Angelos!! Will be back when we visit this way again !! read more

I'm from upstate NY, from a city known for its food. I could get killed for saying this but the spicy Italian sub was the best I have ever had. The bread, THE BREAD!! Great great place to eat. read more

I'm a self proclaimed NY pizza snob, and I can tell you Angelo's is the absolute best west of Hoboken! Great crust and seasonings, great service. Highly recommend! read more

This was my first time here, and I ordered my usual when trying a pizza place for the first time, a plain pizza and an Italian hoagie. Both were awesome! The pizza was a medium , 14 inch 8 cut, with a light thin crust that was crispy on the bottom and soft, light and chewy on the inside. The sauce is really good, not too sweet, not too garlicky, and plenty of delicious cheese. The Italian comes in one size, I think about 9 inches, and it comes served on a homemade bread that is almost like a flatbread or a wedgie crust. Plenty of meat and toppings, and for 6 dollars, you won't find a better Italian hoagie anywhere! I can't wait to try more items on the menu. The girl who answered the phone was extremely polite, and the young guy who waited on me when I got there, Enzo, gave outstanding service. You can tell that this is a family owned business and they put lots of love and passion into there food. We will definitely be back. read more

Wow. Some of the best pizza I've ever had. About a 45 minute wait but worth it. Great service to match the great food. Definitely visiting again. read more

They have great pizza and french fries! And are very nice people.

Angelos is my favorite pizza place in brookville. The crusts are hard, the bottom doesn't sag, and they cook it just right. If you want to customize it, you can. The hoagies, strombolis, and spaghetti dinners are amazing as well read more

While the food was merely average the service was less than acceptable. Had a pizza delivered 2 blocks from the store. When it arrived almost a full hour later the pizza was in the box upside down. When complained was met with a "So what". Will never give them another dime. read more

For 10 years I have been enjoying Angelo's pizza and subs......I can honestly say that there was only one time that I was not happy with my food. Compared to all the other places I've eaten, that's an excellent record in my book. I love their pizza and love watching them make them with fresh dough. Their subs are awesome. Their prices are reasonable. We use Angelo's Pizza for special "treats" as we can't afford to eat out very often - but when we can, we always choose Angelo's. Fresh cheese, fresh dough, awesome! read more

The best pizza and stromboli in town for sure, but what really gropes my goose are the sandwiches. My affinity for them will surely lead to the development of type II diabetes later in life, but when in my golden years as I am reflecting on my time spent shoveling carbohydrates into my face as quickly as possible at Angelo's restaurant, I will have no regrets. Even as my toes are being removed one by one, my eyesight is deteriorating due to years of glucose build up in the capillaries, and my kidneys are limping to life's finish line, I will still be eating Angelo's subs because they are that good. I keep a rotation heavy on the turkey, spicy Italian, and cheese steak deluxe. I generally try to avoid ordering an extra side of bread and sauce, but I admit that my will is weak and I often succumb to the primal urges that come hot and heavy when I'm thinking about that sweet, sweet Angelo's bread. But hey, this is just my opinion. Maybe you're the type of person who'd prefer to take the advice of some hick slap from Big Run (population 686) who thinks the board of health cares whether or not he liked his sandwich. Maybe you're the type of person who would rather follow the lead of a guy who will make "NOTE TO OWNER" posts on Yelp instead of just talking to the owner while you were in his shop standing next to him. Maybe you are the type of person who gets so offended by sandwiches that you use CAPS LOCK!!! AND EXCLAMATION POINTS!!! all over a restaurant review site. If that is the case, Angelo's is probably not for you, so kindly retreat back to your shanty where you can continue authoring malicious diatribes against great food and great people without exposing the rest of society to your ignorance. If you are not that type of person, I'd recommend the Spicy Italian (baked, duh) with LTO, oil & vinegar, and maybe an extra bread and sauce for later. read more