Was told by a coworker to try Andrea's. I walked in and ordered a pizza, it took about 20 minutes and I took it home. Seems like call in orders are pressed smoothly but there were issues with orders before me that people were waiting on for some reason. The pizza was ok, average, nothing special. The pizza was cooked through well and had a light chewy dough. The sauce tasted like a good traditional pizza sauce but the cheese was kind of rubbery. A better cheese would have made this a much better pizza. For a last minute buy it was okay but I'll try other places to hopefully find that "go to" place. read more

If you are looking for delicious, local Italian food, with great service, Andrea's is the place! We stopped in here on a Friday night for dinner with out group of 4 and were seated immediately. The waitress was very kind and patient with our group and answered any questions we had. I had the baked pasta and my husband had the manicotti. Both dishes were so fresh and hot that we had to wait for them to cool, that's a good sign! The flavor was perfect and we really appreciated the normal portion size. I don't like when italian restaurants give me elephant sized portions so we were impressed with Andrea's. We will definitely be back here again soon, oh, and the bread is to die for! read more

Not impressed. The antipasto salad was a plate-filling mess of canned olives and artichokes with iceberg lettuce and deli meats. The self-professed "mess" of a waitress could not produce a wine menu, so I ordered what she insisted on calling Pinot "noor" and it was mediocre, but I was ridiculously overcharged for it because it "comes from Italy". Take your business to Joe and Mimma's in Grafton-the service, food, and prices are much more appetizing. read more

Andreas - Nothing special - Italian Near Me - Yorktown, Virginia

We absolutely love going to Andrea's pizza. Every time we go it's a fantastic family Italian meal and great service with extremely friendly staff. Our little granddaughter loves their meatballs and if Stacey is working she treats our daughter like a little princess to a personal meatball in a cup! Andrea is there a lot and always greets everyone with a friendly smile. The food is always guaranteed to be delicious with a cozy atmosphere. read more

Have never eaten in at this restaurant-- only had the food on a take out basis. I can definitely tell you that the pizza is way better than dominos/ Pizza Hut/ etc. and is reminiscent of New York style pizza. They have always been good about adding a good amount of toppings on if that's what you ordered. The salad is a bit lame-- iceberg lettuce with a tomato or two and dressing that's so so... Bottom line: I have had better pizza, just not around here... read more

You have to try their anti pasta salad! The small feeds 3 people and has fresh everything! Pizza is excellent! Highly recommended it's family run... read more

A great family style Italian restaurant! I've been coming here at this location since well, I cannot remember. I know it has been 15 or 16 years. The pizza is awesome, the staff is great, and its perfect for families. Its a wonderful family restaurant. Calzone is my personal favorite. read more

Wonderful home style fresh authentic Italian. Clean with great service. If busy there is potential for things to take a bit longer (according to their menu). Fried ravioli is excellent, pizza fresh from crust to toppings. Homey feel to the place. Best Italian I have had..and I detest chain restaurants. (If you are looking for something that really feels like authentic, homemade Italian food by people who still care about their product/facility, this is it. I can't wait to try their pasta dishes as they looked excellent as well. read more

Andreas - Andreas pizza -Italian cook came out with glass of wine; proceeded speaking Italian with a small table of friends. - Italian Near Me - Yorktown, Virginia

Our favorite Italian restaurant near by. Terrific Pizza and anything with veal. The staff is attentive and they genuinely care for their customers. The calzones are great too. Sometimes they will do a square Sicilian pizza that is unreal....they also have private event rooms great for small meetings or private family dinners read more

I honestly felt like a guest in someone's home. I heard a server talking to her customers about what they do for a living, and then offered to make chocolate milk for another guest. Our server, Stephanie, tells us they make a ton of the menu fresh to order as I heard an older Italian man talking in the kitchen. We get the jalapeño fried ravioli as an appetizer, clams & linguini and stuffed peppers as our meals. The ravs come with marinara and ranch(we got wasabi ranch for an extra kick). YUM!!!! H finished his linguini, but I got to try a bite and it was really good. It had some amazing flavor to it. I had to let mine cool off but let me tell you WHAT. It was worth the wait. Cheesy, beefy, peppery deliciousness! I only had room for one of my peppers, but they were hands down some of the best stuffed peppers I've eaten. To go box, please? There was just no room for dessert this time, though I hear they have a plethora of options. Between the attentiveness of the staff and the taste, I was overwhelmed. I loved the holiness of this place, the prices were great, and it was an overall awesome experience! We're coming back for sure. We may have to über next time, though. H was so sleepy after! read more

Andreas - Stuffed peppers, completely covered in cheese. So good. - Italian Near Me - Yorktown, Virginia

See all

Love the service, it was a packed house after we arrived, everyone flooded in at once. There were mostly large families having dinner, it was nice to hear the staff recognize the regulars as they came in. It was practically empty when we arrived, and were offered seating anywhere we wanted. We had our usual large Margherita pizza with two cheeses, basil & tomatoes. Ordered the cannoli since we heard they import the cream, & if they run out, they don't offer the cannoli until they replenish their supplies. The cream filling was not too sweet, it had chocolate chips, chocolate drizzled on the plate. Great food, reasonable prices. Peroni, pizza & 2 cannoli was about $36 bucks. read more

Andreas - Cannoli time. - Italian Near Me - Yorktown, Virginia

See all

Had the torpedo sub and also tasted the chicken Parm sub! Both were very good! Cool place and very friendly staff. Cool set up and excited to try more of their food! Will definitely be going back. Will try their pizza and/or meatball sub next. read more

See all

My boyfriend has been looking ALL OVER for good pizza that reminds him of home (NJ) and THIS IS IT! The customer service is AMAZING every time we come in here! I love it! 10/10 recommendation! John "the lonely cook" is the best read more

Food was below average and was not a good value. There was a "service fee" of $1.69 on the check. When I asked about it I was told that there was a notice posted on the door and on Google (whatever the heck that means). We checked the door on the way out and there was a small sign that stated "cash discount". We won't be back read more

You all need to wear gloves when handling food. The waitress/cashier was handling money and food without washing her hands...disgusting. Invest in gloves. I will not be back. read more

Great food and a friendly welcoming staff! I ordered a Manicotti and it was amazing. Very clean restaurant with furniture that gives off a cozy family vibe. read more

I always enjoy their pizza - the closest to a good New York slice as I've found here. The crust and the sliced sausage topping are the real deal. I was dismayed, though, that the cashier and much of the back of house staff were unmasked when I last ordered take-out in early March. I'll return after everyone is vaccinated. read more

We have been to Andrea's many times and we will keep coming back. Most of the time it's just my wife and I out for an inexpensive relaxing meal. However, we have also taken our grown children and their significant others. The other day my son told me the the Italian CEO of the company he works for brings everyone to Andrea's when he comes to town. I can understand why. The food is simple and delicious served quickly. They have a great selection of appetizers, pizza, subs, pasta and other Italian dishes. Our favorite is the pizza. The staff goes out of their way to look after you. The place is always crowded however they always seem to be able to seat us almost right away. If your in Yorktown and wanting some great Italian food give Andrea's a try. I'm sure you'll like it. read more

Favorite Italian food in Hampton RoadsThe quality of ingredients are superb and they prepare to your specifications superbly

Walked in to Oder and the women in the front were disgustingly rude , honestly horrible customer service would not recommend. Definitely give it 0 stars if I could read more

I've been a fan of Andrea's since 2002. I lived near it for 4 years and still, everytime I get the chance to go back to Virginia, I make the trip to Yorktown to enjoy their pizza. Nice, clean and comfortable restaurant. Surprisingly quiet which helps to enjoy it even more. Thin crust pizza at its best. Usually go for either pepperoni, combination, and their "Pizza di Mare" - probably their best. Last went there on 6/14/2012. Service was great and quick. Generous portion size and if there are any left overs, this is one worthy of boxing and taking home. read more

Our family ate dinner here last month. We will no go back. The food was nothing special and then they charged us an extra 3.9 percent to pay with a card. read more

It was pretty good. The bruschetta lacked seasoning but that was easy to remedy at the table. Most of us ordered pizza which was tasty but different, in that the veg on the pizza was pretty much raw like they forgot it was supposed to be there then thru it on last minute. read more

For one we have never eaten inside and yes the place doesn't look like much but the food is great. People are nice enough, they have pizza that is pretty damn close to Italian pizza. I lived in Italy since I was 12 years old until 17 years old. I know what Italian pizza is and this place has the closest to Italian pizza I can get. I know the place says Italian but you know places that say that and they aren't true Italian places. I love this place they have 20inch pizzas and we always get those. I may not have Eaten inside but I know food is amazing. We tried almost everything on the menu and we like it, but pizza is hands down the best in this area. In our opinion. We just go pick it up since we live about 15 mins away. read more

We stopped in here by chance after a fun but hot day in VA beach. Ordered subs to go. My cheesesteak was delicious....roll was soft, meat had good flavor, and oil/vinegar on the side. Four of us ordered subs and we all enjoyed! read more

Would NEVER eat here again!!!! The customer service is terrible!!!! They mess your food and don't care!!! Ignorant!!!!

I downloaded Yelp after my experience here. I needed a whole glass of water to wash down the one piece of bread that I had. I ordered veal because I was craving some beef. The sauce that came on it tasted like it was pure wine. Me wife was sick within ten minutes o eating it. Next time I'll save my 86 dollars and buy Alfredo sauce from the store. read more

Great food! Chicken Marsala is awesome. Great ambience! Better than Joe and Mimma's will ever be.

Won't go as far as saying this place is a hot mess or bad. It's just extra extra mediocre. The food is alright. Just feels like you could easily make it at home with a can of Preggo and a box of Barilla. I ordered a pasta dish (I can't remember which one) and I was underwhelmed. The marinara sauce was runny and thin, the noodles were cooked properly, and the cheese looked like they took a slice of white american, slapped it on top, and let it melt. I will say the fried ravioli was delicious. However, other than that, I got nothing else. read more

Will never eat here again! Pizza was mediocre, my father has a dangerous cheese allergy, I mentioned this to the server yet "drea" did not seem to bothered and brought out a sandwich with cheese removed anyways! When I questioned it drea simply got an attitude! Completely unprofessional and would rather not eat then eat at this terrible facility! Complete disgrace of Italian food! read more

They have the best pizza I have ever had! The service was great. The moscato wine was delicious. I enjoyed everything and will be going back! read more

Visiting from California and Dad recommended Andreas. The owner came out to say hi and sat down with us....from Palermo, Italy. When he disappeared to the kitchen, he crafted a pizza that was amazingly delicious. I will stop in there again before going home. Thanks for the great customer experience. read more

Best Calzones around!! The service is always great as is the food. Their subs are also delicious and very filling.

Excellent homemade food (great marinara sauce), and friendly staff. A local favorite... Makes you feel right at home!

My family and I have been going to Andrea's for years! They have the best pizza in the area, hands down! My significant other is from Chicago and loves their pizza! That is saying a lot since Chicago is known for their pizza! :) This is usually our Friday night spot! read more

My family and friends went to dinner at Andrea's on a Monday night at 6pm (Jun 26, 2017). It wasn't extremely crowded when we arrived, but soon the place was filling up. I don't know if this is something normal, but the service was horrendous. It took an extremely long time for any food to arrive to the table. I had ordered a side salad and it never came. Two members of our party finally received their meals, about 5 minutes after that my daughter received her meal, about 15-20 minutes after that I received my meal and bread was brought to the table (bread that generally comes when beverages do). My husband received his pizza maybe 5 minutes after I got my meal and then the last member of our party was asked "what did you order?" Apparently her order, a 10" cheese pizza didn't go through. The waiting was excessive and the staggered meal delivery is something I have never experienced in my life. I wholeheartedly believe something should have been complimentary, if nothing else the pizza that was forgotten about and brought to table in a box (per our request). Not to mention drink glasses had to be requested to be refilled, and not even scanning the entire table, only the person who asked for a refill. I had heard great things about this restaurant, I had heard the side salads were pretty amazing, but I am highly disappointed in the service we received. It was a 2 hour experience....I even sent an email to the establishment with no response. read more

I love Andrea's Italian Restaurant! They have the best pizza anywhere in Hampton Roads! The atmosphere in the restaurant is really homey and always smells GREAT! I love their pizza with spinach, Italian sausage, and mushrooms with olive oil and garlic. Their stuffed green peppers are phenomenal. If you like Italian food, you have to try Andrea's. You won't be sorry! read more

We happened upon this restaurant on a Saturday night, and I'm so glad! It had a great cross-section of diners - families, couples young and old, teens. Everyone seemed happy. We had pasta, which was delicious, with good-sized portions, but I really regret not getting a pizza. The table next to ours had one, and it smelled heavenly. Service was fast and friendly. I wish we lived closer, as this is the family place I've been looking for. read more

Their pasta, subs and pizza are superb. Service is excellent in this tiny Italian restaurant. You won't find better on the Virginia Peninsula. I feel like I'm back on Long Island or New York City when I eat there. read more

Don't let the out of date simple decor put you off. My wife and I have eaten at Andreas' a few times and the food is excellent. Service was adequate. We have never had to wait a long time for our food or our drinks replenished. The linguini with baby clams in olive oil sauce is outstanding. read more