I have traveled many times via Amtrak. There have been a number of snafus regarding timing and delays, typically beyond Amtrak's control. Weather, track availability (for those who are unaware, Amtrak does not own the rails, the freight lines do. Amtrak leases the right to use of the same rails), and such.
I have always found the conductors and other Amtrak emplyees to be very polite even during the worst of circumstances (delays of five hours due to snow and foul weather, and having to pull aside to allow the freight trains to make way). They are courteous and kind, and as helpful as they possibly can be.
I do wish Amtrak had day hours as well as their night hours. As one Station clerk explained, the trains can't be in a place at the perfect time of day in all places. Which certainly makes sense. I frankly would love to see more of a return to rails as a travel option. Unfortunately most of the time the trains don't actually go TO the town I'm heading for and middle of the wee hours of the morning pick ups make for difficulty getting to my end destination. Someone has to be out driving between 1:00 am and 4:00am. I am unable to drive at this time due to vision issues, otherwise I would drive and have more reasonable hours.
I DO very much enjoy traveling on Amtrak. Typically I have two seats to myself (though not always) and plenty of room for all my myriad bags, which usually include a computer backpack, my small backpack which acts as a purse, and another bag where I have books, a travel pillow and tiny fleece blanket and my small travel cooler with drinks and food, etc. I am able to get up, stretch my legs, walk, use a nice, and typically quite clean restsroom, head to the cafe car, where I can get ice, or a deck of cards or food, or other items. Much better than a bus, certainly cheaper than flying, and easier than driving (other than the weird hours and not enough stops in my crazy destinations!)
I would like to see Amtrak have better food options, and return to the cafe cars where all the food wasn't pre-processed and pre-packaged. At very least on the main, larger routes. Prices are not unreasonable per se, but beat my budgetary confines for something that is of less quality than something I can bring from home.
All-in-All I would give Amtrak a solid plus rating. I have rideen the trains since the late 1970's itermittently, and resumed riding them since year 2000, again intermittently, until more recent years with the decline in my vision. They were far more likely to run on time in the late-1970's and early-1980's. I don't know what has changed since then, but they seem to run a minimum of one to two hours late. And if weather is an issue, as much as four to five hours late. At least I am not stuck in foul weather in my own vehicle, nor am I stuck in an airport (where I have experienced similar delays). I am free to sleep, move around, eat, etc.
In addition, I saw reviews regarding other passengers. Frankly I have never experienced any problems with other passengers. I have found them to be polite, quiet, pleasant people to travel with. I have also noticed that the conductors try to place famiies, and couples separate from individuals traveling solo, when train seating and space allowes. I think that is likely helpful regarding the noise issues others mentioned. read more