My husband and I stopped in for cozy date deal from Eventbrite. We had a reservation for 6pm, but the establishment wasn't notified ahead of time via Eventbrite. The manager was super sweet and apologetic while she set the table for us with a tablecloth and little cute snow flake decorations. She allowed us to get settled and then took our order. My husband ordered the pumpkin pie with banana pudding ice cream and I ordered the pecan pie with pistachio-hazelnut ice cream (can't recall the flavor name). Both pies came out warm from the oven and were absolutely DELICIOUS!!! The service was amazing and I wish I'd grabbed the manager's name. I'd definitely return during the summer months read more

I finished a performance at Symphony Space, so my friends and I wanted to get ice cream. The names and branding is all really cute, and a lot of seating both indoor and outdoor. We tried the strawberry cheesecake flavor and the chocolate ice cream, both of which were creamy and delicious! Oh, and they give generous samples! read more

Ample Hills Creamery - ice cream - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Pretty good ice cream! Service was really great as well, with a good variety of vegan flavors. Would come back here again.

I'm sure their ice cream is creamy and delicious but this review is solely based on the trending Death by Chocolate hot cocoa drink that I've been seeing on TikTok. Looks great, tastes... meh. Bottom line, not worth the hype! I finally caved and tried the Death by Chocolate hot cocoa from Ample Hills at the Upper West Side location. I mean, how could I not? It's all over social media--people raving about how indulgent and amazing it is, with those dramatic chocolate swirls and chunks on top. It definitely looks like a chocolate lover's dream, but unfortunately, the experience didn't live up to the hype. First off, let's talk about the taste. You'd think with a name like "Death by Chocolate," it would have layers of rich, decadent flavor, but it really didn't. It was overly sweet, almost cloying, and felt more like I was drinking a melted candy bar than a well-crafted hot cocoa. There wasn't any complexity to the chocolate--just sugar overload. I was hoping for some deep, dark chocolate vibes, but nope. By the time I got halfway through, I was already over it and regretting my decision. Then there's the texture. It's thick. Like, really thick. I know that's part of what makes it "extra," but it's almost too much. You feel like you're drinking a dessert instead of enjoying a cozy, sippable hot cocoa. It's not the comforting, balanced drink you'd hope for on a cold day--it's just heavy and overwhelming. And let's not ignore the high price of $14.15. For what you get, it's steep. The portion size is pretty small, especially considering how filling (and not in a good way) it is. I made myself finish it, otherwise would've to throw it out but don't want to toss out my money like that. For something marketed as a premium hot cocoa experience, I expected way more but it's pretty underwhelming to say the least. The whole thing feels like it was designed more for social media than for real enjoyment. Sure, it's photogenic, and if all you're looking for is a good shot for your feed, it delivers. But as an actual drink? Hard pass. The cone part at the bottom is not crunchy at all. It's rather very chewy and has the texture similar to cardboard. If you like cardboard, then sure go ahead and take a huge bite out of it. There are definitely way better hot cocoa options out there that don't sacrifice flavors and your wallet for looks. I wouldn't go out of my way for this one again. Been told by staff that people actually call the store beforehand to make sure that there're still available RSVPs for this overhyped hot cocoa dessert drink. There're limited quantities and only available during the weekends. I totally get it about reserving a brunch spot with your girlies or reserving your favorite restaurant to dine in with your significant other. But, I'm not sure about reserving for a smallish + pricey + overhyped hot cocoa drink. Staff's service is very friendly, patient and fast though. There're several chairs, benches, and tables inside for the seating area. Definitely a very warm and clean space. No restroom for customers. Can ask staff for water if you're thirsty. Can pay with cash and credit/debit card. Lastly, it's conveniently located near the 1 train. read more

See all

I've seen a lot of Instagram ads for Ample Hills Creamery, and their Death by Chocolate campaign caught my attention. It launched around Christmas and promoted hot chocolate-based ice creams. However, the ads they used on Instagram were AI-generated, which was a bit off-putting. Still, I decided to check it out in person. The shop itself matches the whimsical, over-the-top aesthetic they advertise. I visited at the end of January for their Valentine's event, which featured heart decorations and themed promotions. The location I went to, on the Upper West Side, was on the pricey side--around $15 for ice cream. Given how much they invest in marketing and themed experiences (including employees dressed in winged Cupid-style costumes), I figured the price was part of the appeal. I first tried a free sample of Love at First Bite. It had a cherry jelly-like swirl mixed into what tasted like strawberry ice cream. It was extremely sweet, with an artificial flavor that stood out. It was fine as a free sample, but it didn't leave a strong impression. Wanting something more, I ordered the Valentine Chill, their featured item at the time. This was the $15 option. When I got it, the ice cream was already melting and somewhat soupy, likely due to the overload of toppings. It was packed with cookie pieces, salted caramel covered in yogurt, and caramelized Twix-like cookie bits. The flavor was intensely sweet, with a syrupy, gooey consistency from the caramel, a slight saltiness from the pretzel bites, and a noticeable crunch. If you've ever had Ben & Jerry's Netflix & Chill ice cream, this had a similar vibe but with a strawberry flavor twist. Would I return? Probably only if they had another campaign like Death by Chocolate. Otherwise, I wouldn't pay this much for ice cream again based on my experience. That said, the customer service was great--staff were attentive--and I did accumulate points for a future visit. This is more of a novelty spot, ideal for a date, a themed outing, or a place to take kids. It's less about the ice cream itself and more about the experience and aesthetics. read more

See all

Must try: Sweet Cream & Cookies! Why: Loved the Sweet Cream & Cookies as it was deliciously sweet with chunks of Oreos. Def satisfied my sweet tooth! Notes: Nice and clean ice cream parlor with indoor seating. I went around 6:30pm on a Friday and there was no line. I appreciated they had a kid size scoop since I was full from dinner and drinks but wanted something sweet. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Sweet Cream and Cookies Ice Cream ($6 - Kids Size) - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Pretty good ice cream spot. The marshmallow ice cream was pretty good but overall it was sweet. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious ice creamv and plenty of options. Got the flight, which is 6 mini scoops. Regular cones are free! My favorites were the sweet cream and cookies and the oatmeal lace but they were all great. $10 in the city is a great price I think. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

How can it be that every single hire here is simply "phoning it in"? No smiles. Zero graciousness and the real KICKER is that they haven't a CLUE how to relate to CHILDREN!! See kids, excitedly order at the counter only to be met with blank stairs makes this the most depressing ice cream shop EVER! The eight dollar price tag for a small cone was also not fun. One and done. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Another good experience at Ample Hills! When I arrived I parked on the street a couple blocks away. I walked into the spot and was greeted. We were served the butter peacan ice cream and the Death by Chocolate chilled. Both ice cream treats were really good! We had a good experience all in all! read more

See all

I tried to go for ice cream on Saturday April 4th at 4pm. I thought the shop was open but the closed sign was on and the only person working the shop was standing outside cursing someone out on her phone, literally screaming into her phone. These small places of business really need find better people. I know these are just part time jobs and it's not what anyone's dreaming of doing but the customer shouldn't have to be inconvenienced by someone's petty drama and emotional immaturity on one of the first nice weekend days of the spring. Just my opinion. I walked down a couple blocks to Van Leeuwen instead. read more

I came here a couple of days ago and I loved it. The employee was very nice and patient. It was my friend first time and she was really nice. The place inside is very family friendly with different board games. The ice cream was delicious and fresh. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Ooey gooey butter cake - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Vibe: 7/10 - they get extra points because they have seating, but it's nothing special Service: 7.75/10 Value: 7.5/10 - good quantity for the price in NYC! But not the best deal I've ever seen Where this place truly excels is their flavors! There were so many options, I had a hard time choosing. I'll definitely be back! Chocolate milk and cookies: 10/10 Chocolate fudge: 9.5/10 Overall: 8.35/10 (4.18/5) read more

Ample Hills Creamery - 2 scoops: chocolate milk & cookies; chocolate fudge - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Cons: smaller scoops of ice cream and poor unfriendly service. The flavors are incredible! I got peppermint and the Moose chocolate one with pretzels and dark chocolate. They went great together. The sugar cone was great too. I wish the portions were a little larger. Service was grumpy. No fun. Come on, it's an ice cream store! The samples I asked for were not even a teaspoon. Not even fun to try, nor was there enough I could try. Good music inside. Plenty of seating. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Peppermint Pattie Pint - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

So happy to try this neighborhood ice cream shop. The service was friendly. She was chatty and offered samples to help me decide on a flavor. I enjoyed my peppermint chip and cookie au lait. The ice cream was creamy, delicious and loaded with chunks. Just the way I like my one cream! read more

See all

Pros Traditional and non traditional flavors Vegan options Delicious Ice cream Lovely seating area Moderately priced Cons Zero read more

See all

Even in December cannot stop spoke from enjoying delicious ice cream! Me and some friends were walking by and one of my friends persuaded us to trying out some flavors and some of my friends ended up buying. You're able to try out the flavors before purchasing and they have a various amount of mixed favors that was so delicious. The place is buzzing with music and seating is available as well. Service was attentive as well and helped with our asks. I didn't purchase that day but will be back when an ice cream fix is needed! read more

See all

Had my daughters 5th birthday party here. The place is cute. The children had a great time, and the ice cream is great too! Dan was a pleasure to work with! read more

I LOVE AMPLE HILLS! I'm so glad they're back in business because this is my go to ice cream spot in the Upper West Side. They have so many different flavors from the classic flavors to plant-based vegan flavors to creative fun and funky fusions. My go to is the Chocolate Milk and Cookies and Cookie au Lait. Definitely recommend this place for all ice cream connoisseurs in Manhattan!! read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Average taste. Nothing special. $7 for this scoop has sealed the deal never to come here again. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Average taste. Nothing special. $7 for this scoop has sealed the deal never to come here again. - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Incredible spot. All ample hills are great and this is no exception. HUGE selection of different ice creams with large portions, friendly staff, great ambience. Each ice cream is unique and has a detailed description. Must try for all ice cream fanatics. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Ice cream - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

My favorite ice cream spot in NYC is back! Came here on a weekend and had the best experience. The staff is always so welcoming and I'm always able to try flavors. I love the peppermint patty and butter pecan but the ooey gooey is always a crowd pleaser. Such a cute spot with lots of indoor and outdoor seating. I'm hoping they open more locations soon! read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

What sets this place apart is the variety. SO many flavors-- and not just your usual run of the mill flavors, but UNIQUE flavors. Their menu is extensive and requires you to tap into those fast reading skills, acquired from not reading any history textbooks fully, to get through them all and see what you want to have. They also offer hefty samples-- I tried three: the Corn to Run, Summer of Love, and Kokomo (key lime pie). I ended up getting one scoop of the Kokomo, which was so delicious for key lime pie lovers-- it had an intense lime flavor with bits of crust mixed in that added texture. The others were honestly great as well, and if I had more time I would have sampled them all. We came in at almost-closing time, and they started to get a bit busier, so that might have been the reason for this but the service could have been better. Although they did offer us samples, they were also extremely short with us, demanding that the next person in line order, and glaring me down while I was eating the samples I was given. The one scoop itself also feels a bit small for the price. All that aside, though, I'd definitely return to try some of their other special flavors! read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Kokomo (Key Lime Pie) - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Adorable little ice cream place with courteous staff and a wide range of flavors. I had the butter pecan pie crumble on a waffle cone and it was delicious. read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Butter pecan pie crumble - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

For time visit was opening day when I tried the flavor created for the UWS. It was a small scoop so I can't say I really tasted all that's put into this ice cream. It was rich and good. I wanted more! I went back today to check it out as a paying customer. I've been leery over what they charge for 1 scoop because when you see the size of the cup it's so small!!! Either way I ordered a medium (2 scoops) to try 2 flavors. It cost a little under $8 with tax. I tried the Commodore which is supposed to have honey in it but it tasted more like caramel to me. I could barely taste the chocolate covered potato chips. This flavor is also considered one of the creamiest; before I even paid my cone almost toppled over. I also tried the Hopelessly Devoted to Moo. This has a vanilla base but it overall tasted more like a chocolate flavor. The pudding, which is like fudge, can definitely be tasted! Again, I might have gotten one piece of the black out cake that's in it. read more

See all

Really liked this ice cream place!! They have a lot of unqiue and special flavors, I'm itching to go back and try more of their ice cream. My little sister is not a fan of dessert that is too sweet so she was skeptical, but we both really loved the fruity pebble ice cream. The guys behind the counter were really nice and let us try out a couple of samples as well! read more

Just came in the shop with my 6 yo and her 2 friends plus the moms, and it was not nice! The woman behind the counter looked bothered and bored to help us and rushed us in our selection of flavors No thank you no nothing Handed the cups and moved on I'm not expecting a dance party or backflips but at least be congenial And the ice cream although it is delicious, cost $7.50 for a small cup so it bothered me that we spent $30 and not so much as a thank you read more

The Cap'n Crunch ice cream is the best ice cream I've ever had in my life. I had it about 3 weeks ago, and I don't think 5 straight minutes have passed without me thinking about it. I cannot wait to return and order it again. read more

Another one of those hyped up NYC places. Takes the same $$$ as Amorino and Van Leuwen down the street but the quality is not even close. The flavors very creative (I guess that's where the hype comes from) but nothing that was actually tempting. Potato chips ice cream anyone? I didn't actually know what to eat. I went with the most regular they had, strawberry cream and a scoop of peach with croissant flakes, but it just all tasted like heavy cream with lots of sugar. My friend had mango, but the flavor was off. Service was more meh, than great. Overall, disappointing experience after the excitement of a new shop on the block. read more

So Happy ample hills is finally closer to me .. I was getting tired of driving to queens. Literally the best Ice cream place you will ever find in NYC. I promise . It is better than the hype . This new location is just in time for summer . It's super cute and nestled right in the heart of Amsterdam . Located by tons of cool bars and good eats. I stumbled upon it while heading to a bar. ( go figure) ANYWAYS. They have a ton of cool ice creams to choose from. And I'm Not talking your ordinary vanilla and chocolate. I always get the same thing but I definitely try the other cool flavors they have to offer . But if you want the exact recipe that has got me hooked. It's the ooey gooey butter cake ice cream on a pretzel cone. Yes I said it . A pretzel Cone. So gooood. Would I go back ? I'm going back as soon as I leave this bar Should you?? Absolutely. Run don't walk. read more

Okay folks if you're on a diet stop reading now. If you want a delicious treat that is very likely going to set you back several hundred calories but totally worth it this one's for you. I tried the company favorite called Ooey Gooey butter cake with Oreo and brownie toppings (like I said a few hundred calories) I only had one scoop which is enough because it's very rich and I know this has to be very high in calories. It's really good, the only reason and this is totally a personal preference it's just a little too rich for me, but then again I'm a little boring when it comes to my ice cream preferences. read more

The ice cream was very creamy and delicious. The staff working that day were hospitable and helpful. The decorations and the music made the place inviting and chill. read more

I rarely ever write reviews. Just left the Upper Westside location: asked the server for his favorite flavor and he told me "I don't like any flavors here". Rudest server in ages and the other two were worse. When we left one said "thanks for wasting our time". Left without getting anything. Train your staff in basic kindness. These three should be fired. read more

i legitimately cried happy tears when the UWS location reopened. my favorite flavor is the strawberry. chefs kiss read more

The ice cream was better than expected. The staff was SOO nice, helpful and very friendly. The ambiance was good - typical Sunday afternoon type. I'll definitely go back for more. Thanks! read more

The company is coming back (per NY Times on June 16, 2023). I hope they reopen this UWS location. They had great ice cream and a variety of flavors. read more

My husband doesn't eat chocolate ice cream but he shared mine and finished it! He said it's the best ice cream he's ever had. The key is that: it has TRUE flavor, not just sweet or sugary. Definitely the best in NYC. read more

great service, good music and a clean store. the ice cream flavors were also amazing! read more

Ample Hills Creamery - Chocolate Milk & Cookies & Nonna D's Oatmeal Lace / The King of Mangoes - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I am always going to be a fan of an ice cream shop with lots of seating indoors and outdoors, plus a bathroom. This spot also has some unique, fun flavors alongside the classics. A little pricy but worth it. read more

Supperrr yummy ice creams and really interesting flavors! Unfortunately the only thing that dims my experience is the staff. They can be a bit rude sometimes. I don't expect the happiest, friendliest, over-the-top service anywhere I go, but at least not being condescending would be nice... read more