Fishing selection is limited. They have some firearms. Archery is their specialty. Staff is…read morefriendly.

This is the 2nd time I went in there and bought something from there and the price that I was…read morecharged and what was marked were different prices each time and I told them about it and they never gave me back the difference. I will never walk in there again!

Plan on spending a lot of time and spending some dinero on high quality, hard to find items!…read more Bows,arrows,pistols, rifles, ammo, sling shots, tree stands, whatever your sports minded heart feels like buying! Buy from experienced individuals, not just clerks/cashiers! Their high quality inventory makes you want to take your credit card to the limit! Happy " hunting"!

They are very generous in trade in values and take care of any problems. I feel they went above and…read morebeyond fixing my problems. No hesitation they replaced with no hassle and apologized for "my" problem! Best gun store ever. Gary D

Great Service,good prices,CCW classes,Gun Smith...Indoor,outdoor shooting ranges, I would recommend…read morethis gun shop to everyone

Great store and amazing customer service. Everytime I go in they are super friendly and they know a…read morelot about there products. I highly recommend this store !

Highly recommend this shop. Friendly, welcoming atmosphere from all of the gentleman who work here…read more I live in Columbus, but since I've stumbled upon this location I make the 45 minute trip here once in a while just to check out their current offerings. they have a great selection of gear at competitive prices. Always new tools coming in and often my visit ends in finding something too good to pass up. The inside of the store is absolutely stacked and lined with firearms and accessories, fun stuff to look at, wood paneled walls, hilarious signs and wall art. It's a homey, cabin like place that and feels like a breath of fresh air compared to the corporate, fluorescent-lit, sterile environments of larger retailers you find in the city. Im sure if I were a fisherman, I'd find even more here that would keep me coming back but, my focus was on all the tools they have for sale. I signed up for yelp just to make this review! Typically I do not engage in comments or reviews but I wanted to give this place a shout in hopes more people support their business. The gentleman here seem knowledgeable and experienced - I would say to anyone who is uncomfortable with guns, new to guns, or just disliked the experience of the larger stores full of corporate employees who don't know and don't care: make the trip out here.

I have purchased from this business in the past and had a great experience. I went back today…read more6/13/25 with my son to look at some long barrels and found that they are out of business at this location.

I think the 2 man's work there they are rases and they know wet this is sad how they treat me in…read moretheir minds they think people like me can't see how they serve me they make me wait more than 1 hour for something take less than 2 minutes it's sad we still have people like this trust me they know what they did is wrong

Surplus has great customer service. They have alittle bit of everything. 1. Hats 2. Patches 3…read more Military shoes. 4. Air guns/knives 5. If they don't have it they can order it. My order came in a week or so. That pretty fast these days. A great place for your Military stuff that you need Darren. MSC USNAVY RETIRED.

I consider myself an advanced collector of militaria. This place does not have it. They have the…read morestandard Army.Navy fare; airsoft guns, compasses, knives, BDUs, camping supplies, etc. However, this place is pretty large and has two stories of army-navy goods. They have a basement with a clearance.discount section that is not bad. I picked up a knife pouch for half off, which was nice. They have free American flag bumper stickers, which is nice. Service was a little slow (the two guys at the counter were helping a young kid with an airsoft gun that had a problem). Better than the average small Army/navy store, but not as good as a real surplus militaria store. 2.5 to 3 star establishment.

Can't spell BS without Buckeye Shooting Center.....RUN AWAY…read more Hard to review a merchant if they CANCEL YOUR ORDER within hours (bought at Noon, cancelled by 400pm). End of the year sale on a beautiful FN at a great price and BSc advertised the manufacturer's rebate as an additional incentive to purchase before the 12/31 deadline. So after checking 'reviews' and thinking a gun store in OH would be run by a group of honorable folks (they advertise 'vet' owned), I bit, made the purchase, giving them all my info (that they can now sell) and they TOOK MY MONEY. What an idiot I am. They later send an email saying the order is cancelled since the item is out of stock.....Wait, what, you are a gun dealer (you literally get guns from manufactures on a daily basis) and you can take the order and my money, yet you don't want to fill the order? Not the buyer's problem that the BSc system, or worker, screwed up. I have been aggrieved. America is the home of capitalism and every business owner has the right to make, or lose, money based on their decisions. This was a FRAUDULENT SALE, as they could have honorably filled the order since the item in question remains in production. Nope. To top it off, in anticipation of the new item, I purchased accessories elsewhere that now are useless and become my problem to eat or return and for sure I will lose money and time dealing with those other merchants who actually honor purchases. I called BSc and got the runaround by the BSc "manager" and "part owner" who were probably the warehouse guys in disguise. They offered nothing to make it right in any way (but my inbox will be full of BSc emails moving forward). A real 'we don't care if you go away mad, we just want you to go away' attitude. STAY FAR AWAY. PS...BSc has issued a response on another platform of 'yeah it's our error, we screwed you, we take ZERO RESPONSIBILITY and we'll have our friends and employee post a bunch of 5-star reviews'. For the record, despite BSc's contention otherwise, I called AMEX and BSc DID CHARGE MY card and later refunded. The BS at BSc continues.

We were at the Newark Hockey Rink today and I needed to strip to get a couple of mags for the ole…read morerifles. Discovered that they had 40 RD Mags and the 30 RD was buy one get one free! Excellent deal! The place was super clean and well stocked. Lots of nice goodies in there and they also can their own veggies, tell me of another gun store that cans their own veggies! The prices in there were so good that we may have walked out with more than what we were looking for! If you're looking for some great prices and custom builds then this is the place for you. They had some nice custom AR builds on the wall that had some of the best prices around. The guy behind the counter was super friendly and answered all of our questions very professionally. We will definitely be doing business here again. Great job fellas.