My daughter and I were looking for ice cream late on a Friday night and were delighted to find this…read moregem on the north side of Mount Vernon! The cow on top of the building is a good tip-off that this will be a fun place. We each ordered a couple of scoops to try two different flavors, and we both loved our selections! The patio that separates the parking lot and the indoor shop is very nice and well-maintained. The picturesque windows leading into the shop make the place feel welcoming. There's plenty of parking in their gravel lot. It is clearly a place for local families to hang out on Friday evening, so we felt right at home.

Great selection. My wife had the chocolate shake, and I had the frozen coffee. Service was…read morefriendly, and the a/c kept us cool. Try it, you'll like it.

It's a good thing I'm from out of town because I could come here every day! Some of the best ice…read morecream I've ever had.

A delicious and affordable coffee shop with such a cute atmosphere! I got an iced matcha latte and…read moreit was great, and the ice cream was delicious too. They even had a gluten free cone available. Their coffee was very smooth and not bitter and cheaper than a chain store while being way better. The decor was super charming, with taxidermy and antiques that made the space feel really unique. They also sell cute merch like sweatshirts and totes, plus ice cream cakes and their prepackaged coffee and matcha. They had bagels, muffins, and other baked goods for sale too. The shop was also very clean. The employee was busy mopping and tidying while I was there, and it definitely showed with how clean it was.

It was just ok. Ice cream was more more like frozen slush than a creamy texture, suggesting there…read morewas really more water than milk. It was not that good.

This is a MUST VISIT if you like ice cream! It's the same as making it in your old fashion machine…read moreat home, but with much less work and no cleanup! Fantastic ice cream.

This is a typical Whits. I almost always get the flavor of the week and it never disappoints…read more Service was quick and the employees were friendly. While the inside appears to be dated, it did look clean.

They sell really good custard and milk shakes with a weekly special flavor. This is also the only…read moreshop I've been to that also had a vegan option. The vegan flavor is whatever the weekly flavor is and they can also make it as a milk shake too (typically using oat milk I think). This ice cream shop is located along a main road so pretty easy to find with good parking. They often have a food truck at local events too. The Whit's in other towns do not have the same flavors or options for some reason.

Good food, good prices, great service at the counter. Don't take my word for it, definitely find…read moreout for yourself

Been stopping by this little gem for at least 5 years. If your in the area you need to stop and…read moregrab a quick bite or a cone. Wife likes the root beer floats I'm a shake guy Try it!

Stopped by during the Bucyrus Bratwurst festival. They also had a truck at the fest, but I wanted…read moreto see all their flavors. Got a junior cup of coffee chip, which I enjoyed. Great outdoor seating and very nice staff.

Very cute walk up location in downtown Bucyrus with nice metal tables with umbrellas outside to eat…read moreunder. They have all your expected flavors and types, cones, cups, sundaes etc and it's very reasonably priced. The ice cream has a unique homemade consistency that will appeal to many people. Overall nice location to visit. They also have truck they take to events to sell ice cream which is a bonus. If you are near Bucyrus it's worth checking out.

I love the atmosphere with the decorative front porch and old school seating inside. So many…read morechoices for ice cream, sundaes, and shakes. I went with a simple butter brickle ice cream scoop. It was delicious especially on a hot summer day. The servers were quick and efficient. We will be back!

Pros: The were open on a chilly Easter Sunday…read moreTastes using regular spoon instead of plastic - the Earth thanks you! Super creamy ice creams with lots of flavor options Friendly service Cons: 6 dollars a scoop The caramel flavor didn't taste anything like caramel. If I closed my eyes I would have guessed it was vanilla. I'll try another flavor the next time. Pro tip: If you are visiting Buckeye Lake, it's worth a visit for the novelty.

I love their flavored milk, its the best i have ever tasted..i am addicted,i am sad when ever the…read moregrocery store is sold out.

Hartzler does its job well. If you want good ice cream and milk, you're going to get good ice cream…read moreand milk. With a strong selection of flavors in both categories, you're bound to be satisfied. Tip: Don't be afraid to try the discounted milk. Though it's closer to expiration, you could not tell via smell or taste. You can get great value if you're looking to sample different flavors (ex: chocolate, strawberry) or if you're feeding a family of thirsty lactose tolerants

Bang for your buck: 10/10 Quality: 9/10…read moreService: 10/10 Ambiance/Location: 10/10 Overall: 10/10

We stopped in after dinner for dessert. We selected counter service and were immediately greeted…read more We both tried the Black Raspberry Ice Cream cone. It was delicious. The man at the counter was very nice and helpful. It was a great stop for dessert! The restaurant was quite busy and very clean.