I'd really like to give them a 3.5 out of 5 - the steaks were perfectly cooked to order - doesn't happen often, and especially not at a pub.. or not the pubs I've been to..
"...HISTORIC VICTORIAN HOTEL.. SHOCKING REVIEWS..!! HONESTLY.. NOT THAT BAD ~ WOULDN'T TAKE MUCH TO MAKE IT A 'BLOODY GOOD' BISTRO..."
Tonight, we met friends, for dinner at the historic WESTMEADOWS TAVERN in Ardlie Street, Westmeadows..
POSITIVES:
- Original building - still got the pressed metal ceilings
- Comfortable venue
- 3 bars
- Outdoor area
- Good air-conditioning
- Heaps o' parking
- Seniors discounts
- Weekly specials including a Monday $15 Parma night and a Wednesday $19 Steak night
- Heaps o' staff
- Nice and clean
- Drive-thru bottle shop
- 2 TV's in the dining area - they had a movie going on one
- Pokies
TONIGHT'S F & B:
2 x LLB's - Good ones, 1 x Lime Soda - Nice and limey, 1 x Carlton Draught - Cold pint
COST: $22
2 x 300gm Porterhouse Steak [1 medium rare and 1 medium], Mushroom Sauce, Steakhouse Chips, Dressed Salad in side dish - Both Steaks cooked to perfection but it was a Mushroom Gravy, definitely not a Mushroom Sauce; Just a handful of chips, and they were a bit of a rough batch - broken and some had blackened ends; Nice dressing on the salad, but such a tiny little serving
COST: $31 each
1 x Golden Ale Battered Flathead Tails, Bowl Tartare Sauce, same Chips, same Salad - Nice fresh tasty fish; Batter not too thick; Nice tasting Tartare
COST: $22
1 x Chicken Parmigiana, same Chips, same Salad - The parma was delish - Beautifully cooked, thick, juicy, just the right amount of sauce and melted mozzarella
COST: $23.50
NEGATIVES:
- Whilst proteins were TASTY and WELL COOKED, meal presentation could have been so, so much better...
- Meals could be a little larger - I think people out in the burbs expect a more GENEROUS serving - they tend to get a bit disappointed when it's not the case...
- Meals could be a little less expensive - they're definitely a bit on the pricey side considering it's just kinda basic pub bistro fare - Hey, I love well cooked basic pub bistro fare, but not really at these prices...
- They're not open till late enough - at just prior to 9pm, whilst we were finishing up eating our mains, two sets of people came in and seated themselves, both lots were told the chef had knocked off for the night, and they wouldn't be served a meal - VERY, VERY UNPROFESSIONAL - surely, out of all those staff members, someone should'v been able to step in, as some sort o' basic short order cook, or any sort of cook, for that matter..? Anyway, we were going to order some more drinks, dessert and coffee, but seeing and hearing this.. stopped us dead in our tracks..!! THREE LOTS OF LOST REVENUE ALL WITHIN THE SAME FIVE MINUTES...!!!
Anyway, I suppose I'd be willing to go by there again, but Gee Wizz..!!, if they improved themselves..!!, just a little bit.. I'd WANNA GO there again...!!!
Visited on Saturday 9 January for dinner with friends. read more