Great selection... The prices were OK. I actually didn't like the way the store was color-coded and…read moreyou had to dig through for size, but I would give another shot because some of the items are rare and fun!

This is a WONDERFUL upscale ladie's consignment store with brand-name labels. It is NOT open on…read moreSundays!

UPDATE MARCH 2017 Since their move south a couple blocks to…read morethe spot across the street from the newish Mickey Finn's, Serendipity seems to have really upped their game. They are a favorite place to stop on First Fridays, when I can hardly get in the door! And the stream of new and fun fashions and accessories is non-stop. Service is friendly and personal, too. Still one of my favorite stops. This is like shopping in a dear friend's great closet. Although the store is tiny, the variety always surprises me, and the service can't be beat. I find interesting items I find nowhere else, and while their prices are consistent with other stores, their sale items make them more affordable. There is even a comfortable place to sit! I have purchased tops, purses, outerwear, scarves, jewelry, and other items. Easy to miss since it is north of Casa Bonita and before the train tracks, up a couple of stairs. But with such a uniquely-vintage location and terrific items and service, it is worth the extra steps. Easy parking right in front, or in the copious parking lots around the corner on Lake Street. No I do not work for them - I am just a huge fan and want to be sure they stay in town!

The Serendipity Shop is my favorite store in Libertyville for anything clothing, jewelry, and…read moreaccessories. I love how I can stop in and get help in finding a last minute gift or a needed something to wear to an outing. Everything in the store is unique and so cute! The staff is great. I love this shop.

After 2 more visits I have to update my review…read more Service: owner is very nice, she said hello and expressed that if I had any questions she will be there for me. The last time I came she was just just chit chatting with an employee so I'm not sure if that was typical. But on this visit she was very accommodating. Selection: nothing much changed in this category. They've got just an ok array of items... but I did learn that she sells online as well so that explains how she's still in business. Maybe sells the good stuff online and whatever's left she sells in the store, which is a good business model. I guess.... Value: I'd say just find their website and buy from there. Cause the stuff in the store is nothing to travel over for. Items in the store are nothing interesting.

I was in this store last week.The woman behind the counter greeted me . There was only one other…read moreperson in the store and she left shortly after I came in. I asked the woman behind the counter if I could bring some of my clothing in for consignment. She was very snippy and told me she was "done for the day" this was 4pm. She said I should come back at 10am another day. She had some hair clips on the counter--I was looking for a certain one. I opened the clip and it fell apart in my hand! She watched me open the clip and saw it fall apart. Very discussed she took the clip and did something on her computer/register and threw it away. I looked around and found a Tommy Hilfiger sweater coat. I liked it but didn't want to purchase it because this woman was so rude. I bought it anyway. I will never come back to this store or recommend it to anyone else.This store is nothing special and certainly not worth your time. Instead go north a few miles to Rochester. The New To You consignment shop is wonderful and the women that work there helpful and very friendly. They take your clothing at any time of day and will either donate or give you any clothing they do not want. The shop has been in this location a long time and very organized.

I am a huge collector of Lilly Pulitzer so I often enjoy visiting thrift stores to see if they have…read moreunique pieces. The Thrifter Sisters is a must-visit place (and one of my secret places) for Lilly treasure! My most recent score was a hard to find Lilly maxi in a stunning print that was priced like a dream! (I also have a new blazer from here that I bought for a dollar-yes one dollar). The Thrifter Sisters was started by three sisters and they have the best stuff. They have a huge variety of name-brand pieces (think everything from Maurice's and Kohls to Carhartt and Janie and Jack Kids) and it's so fun to pop in and see what they have. They also have a room of children's clothes (this is located where the old Kinder Kloset store was). They also sell new hair bows and a small selection of new kids toys too. Thrifter Sisters is clean and they keep their inventory well organized. I liked that they had a lot of brand new accessories for adults and hair bows for kids. There is plenty of free parking and another gift store next door. There is also a yummy coffee shop nearby and a nearby consignment and crystal store that are both great. Everyone is also super genuine and fun to talk to. P.S. thank you again for finding that gorgeous Lilly dress!!!

Great place for slightly used clothing. Very clean and organized. Both my friend and I found…read moresomething we "had to have".

Sandy is very friendly and engaging with everyone that walks in. She loves what she is doing and it…read moreshines through

Got some great deals at this small shop. Sandy is there running her shop in person and she knows…read morefashion, just ask her anything. So many great items as long as you have time to look through everything and try it on. They do not allow returns or exchanges. I got a leather bomber jacket, nude pumps, and 2 purses all for $50. All designer labels, clean, and lightly used. I will check back next season when they have their clearance sale again.

Cute little store in Lake Geneva! I happened upon it when I was walking around downtown -- it's one…read moreof many stores and boutiques in the area. Mostly, they have a lot of shoes. Sporty sneakers, Uggs, Birkenstocks, etc. There's like a whole separate wing of the store just for shoes. Clothing is all women's clothing. The prices are what you'd expect for a boutique in a lake town. But if you're looking for a bargain, Jayne has an outlet store down the street where items are deeply discounted.

Jayne shoe store in Lake Geneva has lovely shoes every style you can imagine. Very accommodating…read moreand friendly service. I recommend you visit the store the next time you're in Lake Geneva.

I have loved coming here, finding unique clothing pieces! The owner Karen is just wonderful. She…read morewill help you find the cutest things and help you with outfits. I have also worked with another person who works there and she was equally as amazing. I now have 5 or 6 pieces from there and they are in regular rotation in my wardrobe! I always try to stop by to see their new stock and Karen just chooses the best selections that really suit so many styles. You can also score some great deals there from the clearance racks! I have found a few amazing pieces that I almost feel bad about since they were worth so much more than what I paid for them. Def check this place out and shop local :)

I was visiting my sister in Chicago and she had a wedding to attend. She needed a top so we happen…read moreto find this wonderful boutique which had many beautiful pieces. Karen, the proprietor, was friendly and very helpful with assisting my sister. The prices are reasonable. The place is clean and inviting. Ladies, treat yourself to a wonderful collection of beautiful clothing.

Just an update. Went in to buy a few Christmas items. Store is still very well managed, and…read morelimited selection due to it's size. Very clean and the staff is very polite, knowledgeable, and attentive. On a foot note, I was kind of disappointed that they got rid of their perfumes and colognes. One of the clerks said Sephora controls that now I'm.

Eh. It's Kohl's. Like all of the other Kohl's quite honestly. Same game plan…read more Had what was needed and quickly checked out and on our way. Close and convenient for me.