I stared at the Station Hostel in Cologne, Germany from November 1st to November 10th. I stayed…read morethere as part of a fairly large group that included high school students and teachers from various places around the world. As such, our reservation was a big one and we used many of the resources and facilities available at the hostel.
As far as the hostel is concerned, I have nothing to which to compare. Before this trip, I never stayed in a hostel before. For privacy reason, I opted to pay the extra money to get a 2-person room with a bathroom. That made my stay at the hostel more comfortable than many of the people I was with. The bed was comfortable, the room was comfortable and nicely decorated (although sparse), and it was nice to have my own bathroom and shower. The shower stall, however, was really tiny and hard to maneuver in. Plus, it only had a shower curtain and no bathmat, so the floor was constantly soaked with water. I ended up having to sacrifice one, and then eventually both, of my tiny thin towels as bathmats. It seems odd to me that they wouldn't invest in bathmats considering renovating the floors and walls must be more expensive than buying some new bathmats every now and again.
Each guest only got one towel and because I was in a double room, I got two. My understanding is that hostels don't normally have towels, so I guess this was an extra at this place. However, I wish I had brought my own towels as these ones were so small and fairly useless.
Besides the shower and towels, another disappointment at the Station Hostel was the wifi. I stayed 9 nights. I think I got internet in my room 3 or 4 of those nights! You can see the routers when you turn on your wifi, but you can't connect to them. The staff said this was because too many people were using the wifi, which I can understand, but if you're a facility like this, why don't you have wifi that can handle more traffic? Even in the lobby and bar the wifi was terrible. If you did get on, chances are it was extremely slow and kicked you off every now and again when it got overloaded. It was not dependable, so if you're traveling for any reason that requires an internet connection, do not stay here.
While I personally did not experience this, a colleague staying at the hostel on this trip got bit by bedbugs on multiple nights, even after changing her mattress twice!
Other minor things: the hallways were always smelly; the elevator was slow and tiny (but at least they had one); the windows were great and new (and had no screens); and the staff was extremely friendly and accommodating.
The hostel has a restaurant/bar on the main floor. They serve a continental breakfast there every morning, which is an extra charge of about 7 euros. It's not worth the cost, go down the street to a bakery. The options for breakfast are limited and the coffee is awful. However, the dinners are absolutely amazing! I ate there at least 3 times and loved everything I ordered. Whoever their chef is, s/he is amazing.
Beer is cheap, while soda is expensive. The tables all seem to be made of wooden pallets, which is neat. Some of the chairs and benches are also made of pallets, which would be neat if they weren't so uncomfortable. The bar stools, on the other hand, are super comfy.
In the warmer weather, they have a patio area in the back, which looks nice even though it wasn't really usable during my visit. I did discover that, unlike Canada, a LOT of people smoke in Germany, and many of them smoke right in front of doors and windows. The backyard area might have been nice to hang out in in the colder weather except for the fact that the smokers all went back there.
While probably not unusual for a hostel, I wasn't prepared for the amount of partying and drunkenness that occurred! Almost every night, people were loud till the wee hours of the morning with absolutely no regard for anyone else. I'm assuming there are no noise bylaws in Cologne.
All in all, I would eat at the hostel again, but I would not stay there again. Maybe I'm stuck in my ways, or maybe I'm just stuck up, but the discomforts far outweighed the comforts and cost savings. I would rather spend a little more to stay in a nice hotel. You do get what you pay for at Station Hostel, as I imagine is the case for most hostels.