This place rules. Went in with only about 30 minutes to close. So much stuff but well organized for what it is! Dude working was polite and nice to talk to about the hobby. Overall loved it. Found a piece I've been looking for at a real good price too! read more

I take antique toy collecting serious. I seen several items of interest behind locked cases. I ask the kid at the counter if he could unlock a few cases at different times. So he had to come out behind the counter to assist me. After the third time of striking out on the toys of interest, kid behind the counter made a snide remark, "Is there any other cases you would like me to unlock so you can look at things you are not going to buy?" WTF?!?! Passive aggressive much dude? My g/f was mad I didn't let her know about what he said. She wouldn't have patroned this place and bought toys for the kids. So don't ask to look at any toys that are locked behind cases, unless you are willing to roll the dice and purchase as is. Horrible experience!!! read more

Vintage Toy Mall - Toy Stores Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Dark haired kid behind the counter was extremely rude to my wife. When she came in he was on the phone and had his feet up on the counter. He acted like it was a chore to talk to her. She came in to sell some merch and before even looking at any of it he told her he could only give her 30 bucks for all of it even though she had much much more in her car. This store used to guarantee 30% of max value for your items and now they wont even look at items before belting out a price. Not cool at all. I dont know who this guy is but hes rude and completely unprofessional and from other comments on here it seems to be an unchanged trend. read more

Do not shop here. The owner is a passive-aggressive bigot. The main store worker is often rude. Rolls his eyes, and sighs under his breath everytime you try to ask him a question. Unless your his friend then hell talk to you forever and ignore whomever is at the counter. They rip you off on trade ins and resells. They claim to give you 30% of value but will use every excuse not to. They dont know the value of what they sell/buy and often rate products low to rip you off more. The owner will make up a billion reasons for this but will often have products marked up more than 25% of their value, and im not even talking about vendor products. If it has an FOR tag on it, and is bagged/traded in, very rarely does the price match the value. They told everyone they changed management years ago, but its still the same jerk. There are better stores in tulsa than this place. read more

I give Vintage Toy Mall 4 stars with a caveat that the store is really polarizing - my friend loves this place and once came twice in the same day (5 stars from him). I'm not such a fan (3 stars for me). Vintage Toy Mall really has all its fandom bases covered; they have everything from the nerd pantheon (Marvel, DC, Stars Wars and Trek, LotR, TMNT, Transformers, and more), plus other, smaller fandoms (ex. Nightmare Before Christmas and TsumTsums). Between all of the vendors, there's a huge assortment of merchandise. The standard comics, shirts, posters, and action figures are all there. They also have less expected items, such as tin lunch pails, drinking glasses, and watches. Because there are many different vendors, pricing and item condition vary. My friend said some items were on par with online prices, but other prices were a little steep. All in all, if you love any combination of nerdy things and vintage toys, you will probably love Vintage Toy Mall. read more

See all

Previously posted a review about not being contacted after several phone calls and no returned call from a voice Mail I left. I am updating my review because the owner reached out to me and apologized for the delay. read more

Great vintage toy store, stopped in today. John knows his stuff, is very friendly and helpful. Selection is off the wall awesome, not only did they have what I'm looking for, but I found several other things other collectors are looking for as well, all at reasonable prices!! If your in the area, stop in you won't be disappointed! They also take requests and you can contact them via email, Facebook, or phone! Just a sample of stuff I saw: Gi Joe ( all sizes 60s to 2000's), Megos, Star Trek, Toy Biz, Kenner, Transformers, Shogun Warriors, Star Wars, Thundercats, Power Rangers, Super Powers!!! read more

Beware! They will rip you off! I was charged twice!I Visited this toy mall with my kiddos and made a purchase. As we were getting into our car, the young man working the register came running out to tell me that my card didn't go through. I went back in and he "attempted" to re-run the transaction. He said that there were issues with the card reader and the charge failed again, I paid $54 in cash and left. Later that day I looked at my account and the charge did hit my bank. So I paid twice for my items! I have tried numerous times to contact the company to request a refund and I haven't gotten a call back. I went in a couple of times to be told the owner isn't in to assist. My bank cannot even get a reply from them and I was told by the bank that I was out of luck since I paid with cash the second time around and cannot "prove" I double paid. Won't be shopping here again. I will choose to spend my money at an honest business. read more

Straight to the point. I visited for the first time yesterday and was staggered by the sheer amount of things available here. Do yourself a favor and skip the flea markets. You could spend days combing through the inventory from different vendors and not see everything. The bias against going to these places is usually "Amazon has it cheaper, or I can get a better deal on Ebay". And that's just not true of this place. This is all of those items from Ebay, but you don't have to pay shipping. Highly recommend for the avid collector and the hobbyist for myself. read more

Super great place to go to find some old toys you missed out on. Staff was amazing and friendly even contacted a vender for a question we had. 10/10 GREAT PLACE TO GO! read more

Went in the store to check out some heman toys. One toy caught my eye the owner rasoul told me it was a prototype made for the design team in the UK. I paid 400 for it and then said we could do cash which I thought was sketchy but still I was excited about my purchase. After researching and finding a photo of the same toy that was in Tulsa and contacting those people told me that it was a custom and the straight faced lied to me. After doing more research on the owner and finding 2 restrainging orders with women and how he won't take money from women. Dude a con man and his word as a man ain't worth a penny. Find somewhere ethical to take your business. He's denied a refund/return and continues to lie. He will probably remove this review as he has multiple other bad reviews. After talking to people while researching the origins of the piece I have learned he has a reputation of being a swindler and clearly troubled in any dealings with woman. read more

Man behind the counter, who said he was the manager, ignored my wife completely and seemed put out to answer my questions. Tried to leave a review on their Facebook, but it was deleted within seconds. Place has lots of good vintage items, but customer service is horrible. If you want professionalism and politeness don't go here. read more

I went in there last week and the environment was so negative. The girl that works there had her kids in there running and screaming through the place and she made no effort of controlling the situation. And the owner was in there and had nothing to say about this bad image on his store. It's like he has no respect for his own place. The employees were extremely rude and unhelpful. I will never shop in there again and suggest that nobody else does either. read more