Vaughan Insurance

5.0 (1 review)

Home & Rental Insurance, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance

Closed • Closed

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Services - Vaughan Insurance

Homeowner or property

Car and truck insurance

Life insurance

Vaughan Insurance Photos

Vaughan Insurance - Our office - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me - Orrville, Ohio

Vaughan Insurance - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me - Orrville, Ohio

Add Photo

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Vaughan Insurance

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Louise H.

15 years ago

I contacted them because I am going to be needing health insurance soon. WOW! This guy was so helpful and friendly. He took the time to explain the basic ins and outs of coverage so I could make an informed decision and was nice as could be. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Vaughan Insurance

1516 W High St
Orrville, OH 44667
Directions
(330) 682-0396
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.vaughan-insurance.com

From the Business

Specialties

Whether you require a single policy or a total insurance program, you can depend on us to prescribe the very best insurance coverage at an affordable price. Building a long lasting relationship with our clients is very important. You can confidently rely on us to provide you with the protection you need and the savings you deserve for your life, auto, home, farm, business/commercial, church and amish taxi insurance.

History

Established in 1952.

Vaughan Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance agency located in Orrville, Ohio since 1952. We are a firm of professional, caring and conscientious people. We provide personal service and we are an agency that you can depend on. We have over 75 years of combined experience and we are committed to a high standard of excellence in all that we do. We strive to establish a firm relationship of mutual trust and confidence with all of our clients.

More Info

Hours

Ask the Community - Vaughan Insurance

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Justin Haislip - State Farm Insurance Agent

(2 reviews)

Tim at Justin Haslip State Farm insurance did a great job helping us with our insurance questions…read moreand helping us get set up on the safe and save app.

Justin & his staff are truly examples of "good neighbors" as he gives 110% to his clients. First,…read moremaking sure our family was ok and second, streamlining the 1st homeowners claim we ever filed. He answered our questions promptly and thoroughly, despite surely being swamped with the damages throughout our county, and expedited our claim to a satisfying resolve. Our entire family is grateful we had State Farm Insurance on all our cars and homes with Justin Haislip.

Nationwide Insurance Heidi Brillhart

(1 review)

The agents at this location were wonderful. Very helpful and willing to go over everything with me…read more I had to switch my insurance and Heidi went over every detail with me and even went as far as to call and make sure I still wanted to cancel with my old provider. She even helped me with the cancellation of that server's I wasn't sure how to do it. Overall the service I received at this insurance company was exceptional. And a bonus was she helped me get a bunch of savings as well. I would definitely recommend that if you are looking for insurance or needing to switch that you go see Heidi and Lizzy in Smithville!!!

Vaughan Insurance - homeinsurance - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Orrville, Ohio Restaurants near Vaughan Insurance

BEST of Orrville, Ohio Pizza near Vaughan Insurance

BEST of Orrville, Ohio Breakfast near Vaughan Insurance

Related Cost Guides

Auto Insurance

Currency Exchange

Financial Advising

Home and Rental Insurance

Insurance

Life Insurance

Tax Services

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Vaughan Insurance also viewed

Mindy Covington - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(1 review)

I needed to get a better rate on my insurance but didn't want to lose all of my great coverage…read more Arianna at my State Farm office worked with me, listened to my needs and expectations and got me a better deal than i expected. I had begun looking into other companies but though the pricing was nice the coverage did not even begin to compare with Stste Farms. As a 25 plus years customer I very pleased that I didn't need to leave to get what I needed.Thank you Arianna and thank you State Farm! VJP

Brad Carpenter - State Farm Insurance Agent

3.7

(6 reviews)

Great agent and service! Very happy with the consultation and convenience of working with them!read more

Don't go to brad carpenter. He will lie to you and tell you you have to go to their preferred shop…read more You do not! It is your car and you can take it to whoever you want. It is illegal to require customers to use a specific repair shop. If I could give zero stars, I would

Buell & Olivieri Insurance

5.0

(2 reviews)

Excellent service and personalized attention. Staff responds quickly to any questions. Working with…read morethem thru a complicated vehicle claim was fabulous, I can't recommend them enough.

We moved from another state, leaving behind a 50 year relationship with our insurance agent. Buell…read moreand Olivieri Insurance came recommended to us, and we have been SO incredibly grateful that we have found an agent as helpful, available, and trustworthy as the one we left behind. Tony Olivieri has helped us with all our insurance needs and is always there for us, answering questions and advising us. I have complete faith in him.

Dennis Tzouloufis - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.0

(4 reviews)

I really appreciate how easy it was to get a quote from State Farm and then complete a contract…read morewith Mr. Tzouloufis even on the weekend. Great job. Thank You so much.

Dennis has been my insurance agent since I learned to drive and purchased my first car almost 20…read moreyears ago. The office is very responsive to customer concerns and Dennis works with you personally to resolve issues. I contacted him today, due to spam texts, and he was promptly answered and checked my account. If you like to speak with an actual person, this is your office.

Hanlin Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

I've been with Hanlin since 1990. I wouldn't consider changing. Great people, great service,…read morewonderful coverage, and excellent premium, and I worked at another insurance company! Hanlin can't be beaten! I've had home, multiple vehicles, renter's, motorcycle and teenagers who switched cars frequently! Lorie was my agent.. she knew me by my voice. Lol We were friends. Everyone there is friendly and helpful. You won't find a lower premium anywhere! (Not even for those teenagers!) I'm so happy I found them, and they were my company and I value them, both as my insurance agent, and as the people that I have a friendship with! This is the Insurance agency you've been hoping for, and I'm not a relative or personally involved in the financial part of their agency.. I'm just a customer who is very satisfied!

Sharon Guilliams - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(1 review)

Professional, friendly, reliable and respectful ... Sharon and her staff respond quickly to…read morequestions and concerns. They periodically review policies to ensure the best coverages for life changes. I have peace of mind knowing, like a good neighbor, Sharon is there!

Jim McKinney - State Farm Insurance Agent

3.0

(2 reviews)

Very friendly and patient. They make you feel like familyread more

Horrible service by the agent. After more than a decade of paying premiums without a claim, he told…read moreus that his office couldn't help us with basic questions on a very small claim. I mean BASIC questions on coverage. He gave us the 800 number and said to call there instead. When we called the 800 number, the call center representative said, "I can help, but your agent should be answering these questions for you." Call this agent only if you like lining someone's pockets with no expectation of service after the sale!

Vaughan Insurance

Services - Vaughan Insurance