I went to this restaurant for the first time yesterday, and I can only say one thing... It was fantastic! It was recommended to me by my boyfriend and I though, "Why not try it?" Oh, boy. It was the best decision I have ever made. As I do not go to the downtown Mansfield area often, I did not know this place existed. Now I do and will definitely stop in again! Inside of the establishment, the layout was a little strange but they made it work. Let's just say the restaurant is more long than anything. Which, I must say, is reasonable due to the location. The restaurant is well lit and has a nice atmosphere. As I dined in, I came to love the inside and waiting experience. The workers liked to talk and made me feel welcomed, a quality I very much enjoy for customer service workers. They were easy to talk to and were not shy to give opinions of the food. I took a recommendation and loved it! Onto the food, I ordered the buffalo chicken slaw sub. At first, I was a little weary because I had never had slaw on a sandwich before this. The combination seemed a little strange as well, buffalo sauce and slaw. I have to say that I am always up to trying new combinations and this one did not disappoint! The slaw was sweet and the buffalo saucy was spicy. Together, they made the perfect sweet-spicy combo. The chicken was nice and juicy and the bread was crisp, both of which added to the flavor. Honestly, words cannot describe how much I loved this sub. I can even go on to say that it is the best sub I have ever had. Which is not a lie, because it is! I even forced myself to continue eating past being full because I couldn't get enough! I am definitely going to stop here again. I cannot wait to try more food from here! read more

First time eating here since they changed owners and name. Loved it!!! Pizza sauce is still the best I have ever had.

We are always ready for another slice of Two Cousins pizza. When I heard they are making Crab Rangoon pizza, I had to try it as soon as I could! It was even more delicious than I imagined. We will definitely be adding the Crab Rangoon pizza to our order every time we visit. read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Crab Rangoon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Pizza is great Meat lovers Stromboli is outstanding and the taco fold over was awesome

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat on my way up North and it was delicious! A nice lady informed me on all the goods since I hadn't been in before. I got a couple slices of pizza that were ready for the taking and some cannolis which were made fresh . Also the location is a cool spot in town. Def recommend! read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

See all

There's much better pizza in and around Mansfield. The slice has flop, the crust has no crisp, and the flavor is hard to find.

Not the same as it was a few years ago. The evening staff didn't know how to enter a phone order and we paid over $50 for a medium And a large. The food was amazing before the new manager started. It wasn't broken so they shouldn't have tried to fix it. Won't be back, and we are always looking to support local. read more

Loved this place! We stopped there before heading to OSR and had a great experience! The customer service was good and the Stromboli was SOOOOO GOOD!!!! I highly recommend!!! read more

See all

Wonderful pizza . Stuff crust is a Must. I love that they put Parmesan cheese on the top. The sauce is amazing read more

$10 for a Bavarian Pretzel! While it was decent, ten is too much. Gave my cheese pizza away. Tables are so wobbly your pizza will fall off.

So me and my family were in town and while the deep dish was a little pricey this was 100percent the best pizza I've ever had but I would love to come back read more

Two Cousins is all right for pizza in this area. It wouldn't be anything special in the big city. Since it lacks competition, there isn't much to compare it to. Being in Mansfield, there aren't as many pizza places to compete against. This is still good enough if you're looking for some cheap pizza. It has a good downtown location. It's close to the Carousel park. That's a good place for taking it and sitting. It also has plenty of seats in the restaurant. There aren't any outside of it, but there are some at the coffee shop. It has a menu of mostly pizzas. They do have other items like subs. I had the vegetable sub. This is about $6 for a sub with vegetables including mushrooms, peppers, and tomatoes. It comes with a side of seasoned oil. This was pretty good in spite of it looking plain. It has overall good pizza for the area. It's okay to eat inside but most take it. They close earlier than many others. read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Vegetable Sub - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Great pizza and pepperoni rolls! Cleanliness was not a top priority. Staff seemed like they really didn't want customers. Seemed bothered by us. read more

Great pizza! Good little atmosphere too. Get it by the slice or a whole pie. If you're brave try out the massive challenge!!

Absolutely wonderful food. It is my new to go place for ordering. Comfort food at its finest

Ordered a bakery style pizza with pepperoni & bacon toppings. We have ordered this pizza for years. The pizza we received was thin, not bakery style and we were charged $20.60 for a regular crust medium pizza. Pizza was not ready at promised time because they said the first one they made was messed up & inedible? Very disappointing as this used to be our favorite pizza. read more

Too expensive for me. Large cheese pizza with half pepperoni, 1 stromboli, 2 chef salads and a 2 liter cost me $62.00. On the bright side the staff was friendly. read more

Best pizza and subs in town. Be sure to stop by and say hi to Andy and the crew. Best service from people that care. They truly do an awesome job and want you to have the best experience when dinning in our takeout. Everything on the menu is 5 stars. read more

See all

The restaurant was dirty, the salad was wilted with black slimy spots and the crust of the pizza was not cooked all the way. This place was on Pinterest top pizza places in Ohio. Not sure how this was determined or if this place has changed hands since. We drove down from Cleveland and it was a giant disappointment!!! read more

The best local pizza in Mansfield in my opinion. Perfect ratio of cheese and toppings. Good sauce and AMAZING crust.

Stopped in with my wife and parents for some pizza as my mother is gluten free and they have pizza to accommodate her celiac. From the very start, our experience was not great. The customer service was not great, not one person working that day was pleasant or polite. My wife is dairy free and was trying to get a personal pan pizza that did not have cheese and had some toppings. She was told that they didnt do specialty pizzas in the personal pan (which it does say that there). They said they could do a plain pizza and just add toppings, which she did. When we sat down later and looked at the bill, the personal pan pizza was $20!!! Each topping (onions, peppers, etc) was $2 each! Then my father and I placed orders for slices (5 total, 3 for me and two for him). The personal pan and gluten free came out first. The personal pan was almost all crust and had very little sauce. My wife asked for a little extra sauce, to which another employee responded to say they are supposed to charge for that, but she did give us some. Her whole demeanor speaking to us expressed that she would rather be anywhere else but there. My father and I did not receive our pizzas, so we asked and they brought us out each one slice. We shared that we should have five total slices. They brought out one more and said that was all we paid for. They did provide a receipt to show that only three were placed in the system, and that she wasnt giving me something I didnt pay for. I said I would pay, so they provided the other two slices. There were also issues with the credit card machine that day. Just an overall bad experience in the service. read more

ive been going there for a long time and it's always the best pizza i've ever had!! The workers are so great! Yesterday i went there after work and one of the workers helping me, Named Presley, was very bery helpful and nice. Then i got my food and it, as always, was very good!! read more

Very good pizza and cheesy bread sticks. The sauce has great flavor, as did the crust and fresh toppings.

They are always having deals. The pizza is good and the sauce is better. The service is polite and quick.

No frills pizza joint. The menu is basic, pizza as chips on the side to purchase haha. We were hungry and wanted something quick and they delivered well. The pizza was tasty and service was friendly. What more could you ask for. Would be nice if they had some local beer, however you can drink at the local brewery down the street and they will deliver pizza to you read more

We were visiting from out of state and looked on Yelp for a pizza place. So glad we found it because their pizza was AMAZING! We ordered a meat lovers pizza and a pepperoni pizza. The homemade sauce was delicious and the toppings went all the way up to the crust. We will definitely make a point to stop at Two Cousins Pizza if we are in that area again. read more

Had to stop here for dinner after a day exploring the Ohio State Penitentiary (Shawshank) to get a Redemption Pie. We were not disappointed. The pizza was outstanding and the staff was very friendly. Definitely the place to go for an outstanding pizza. read more

Very yummy fast pizza in a unique location in downtown Mansfield. Close to the carousel park it's perfect for families with kids. Looked like they had plenty of ready pizza by the slice but we order a whole pie. It still was way fast! They also sell Jones potato chips which a also local to Mansfield. read more

Two Cousins Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Yes please! This was our first experience with Two Cousins, def won't be our last! We ordered a XL pepperoni deep dish pizza. Upon receiving our pizza, they opened up the lid, to make sure it was to our satisfaction. When we got home & realized, the crust was STUFFED with more cheese & pepperoni.....We were VERY happy! A deep dish,stuffed crust pizza? Uh ya. Not to mention the fact that its, by far, the best pizza I've had, in the area. Def going to be a loyal, returning customer, even though we live in Ashland. Its worth the drive! read more

Horrible customer service. We arrived at 8:32 and they charged us for dine in after asking us if we wanted to dine in then told us we could not eat in. We drove an hour to eat there. read more

I love TCP and if it weren't for the "fattening factor", I would probably eat here/carry out every day! They have great pizzas and great subs that will fill your tummy. You can call and order food from them from the Phoenix Brewing Company, and they will walk your order down and deliver it to you while you enjoy your brews! How cool is that? They have a decent sized dining room that often looks like it's been heavily trafficked, especially if you arrive in the evening. It's probably because they are pretty busy filling orders. Their pizzas have that perfect chewy, bubbly, appropriately thick crust topped with a rich, tangy sauce. They are generous with the toppings as well. I've never been disappointed with their pizza or subs. read more

My son and I come here for lunch each time we visit the buckeye children's museum (1 block away). Each time we are happy with our meal. They have a kids personal size pizza which is FREE with a $5 purchase. This is an amazing deal! Also my son can create his own pizza. They provide the cheese, sauce and choice of topping in cups and my son can arrange it as he likes and then they bake his little pizza. He loves this!!! I don't know what kind of dough they use but it's amazing! The dough for their pizza, pizza rolls, and Stromboli is delicious and so airy yet crispy. I find myself eating the crust from the pizza first cause it's so good. Also if In a hurry, they have hot pizzas ready and you can buy per slice. Lastly, the people working there are always super nice! We definitely recommend this place!! read more

The food here is absolutely amazing and the owner has a heart of gold. I live in Chicago and will make a point to eat here every time I come back to Mansfield. Mmmmmmmmmmmmm read more

Something has happened to this place. Used to be a quaint little out of the way place to get reliably good pizza. Not anymore. It was started years ago by an entrepreneur who used to work at Leaning Tower Pizza. He decided to branch out on his own and obviously brought his pizza craft skills from his time working at the legendary Leaning Tower to this new downtown pizza shop. They had great pizza, fresh salads, single slice options, plus other items that became local favorites. I don't believe he is any longer associated with the business, he sold it. Sadly it shows. The new owners seem to have no clue about running an eatery. When were were there last week the place was absolutely filthy. The floors looked like a barnyard dirt floor, the tables had not been bussed in who knows how long, and the table with condiments was a mess. None of the 3 woman working there were wearing hairnets or gloves, and the one making the pizzas was seen several timed eating some of the toppings as she made the food. The pizza itself tasted different and we decided it was the cheese, wondering if it was s lower quality. This is a health department field day on how to get cited in heartbeat. Sad to see what was once a go to option for good pizza fall into the hands of owners that could care less about the appearance of the establishment or following Health Dept. guidelines. read more

Some of the best pizza in the area and we good prices too. The staff is friendly and preparation is fast. My only complaint is that their pizza oven is one of those belt driven ones, which I suppose works for them since they're able to knock out really good pizza. read more

i literally love this place the food is 10/10 if i could live here i would tbh i wish i had enough money to buy from them everyday!!!! butni dont cause i dont have money's but i hope my horse prince goves me money so i can die happily (not a paid review trust) read more

I love this place. Whenever I'd visit from California I'd make sure this place was one of the first places I'd go. The pizza is always delicious and the employees are very helpful and sweet! The bacon ranch pizza is my absolute favorite. read more

Awesome pizza and stromboli. Nive little cozy place in downtown Mansfield. They even offer their pizza at the local brewery across the street. We enjoy a local pizza, over the typical chain stores. I recommend giving them a shot. I think they also advertise on local lynx app. Look, or ask for deals. read more

Pizza and breadsticks are solid, atmosphere is just WAAYYYYY too noisy. The acoustics are terrible. Sound just bounces off everything - think Chipotle. At 12:30 p.m. we had to take the chairs off the tables to be able to sit down. A crack head who was high made some comments to us when we left the restaurant too. Like I said, good food though. read more

Got here after visiting Ohio reformitory. Ordered our food and my friend didn't even get his food. Pizza was really greasy and layered in cheese. Don't go to this place. read more